The Prediction of Extratropical Storm Tracks by the ECMWF and NCEP Ensemble Prediction Systems

Froude, Lizzie S. R.; Bengtsson, Lennart; Hodges, Kevin I.
July 2007
Monthly Weather Review;Jul2007, Vol. 135 Issue 7, p2545
Academic Journal
The prediction of extratropical cyclones by the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) and the National Centers for Environmental Prediction (NCEP) ensemble prediction systems (EPSs) has been investigated using an objective feature tracking methodology to identify and track the cyclones along the forecast trajectories. Overall the results show that the ECMWF EPS has a slightly higher level of skill than the NCEP EPS in the Northern Hemisphere (NH). However in the Southern Hemisphere (SH), NCEP has higher predictive skill than ECMWF for the intensity of the cyclones. The results from both EPSs indicate a higher level of predictive skill for the position of extratropical cyclones than their intensity and show that there is a larger spread in intensity than position. Further analysis shows that the predicted propagation speed of cyclones is generally too slow for the ECMWF EPS and shows a slight bias for the intensity of the cyclones to be overpredicted. This is also true for the NCEP EPS in the SH. For the NCEP EPS in the NH the intensity of the cyclones is underpredicted. There is small bias in both the EPS for the cyclones to be displaced toward the poles. For each ensemble forecast of each cyclone, the predictive skill of the ensemble member that best predicts the cyclone’s position and intensity was computed. The results are very encouraging showing that the predictive skill of the best ensemble member is significantly higher than that of the control forecast in terms of both the position and intensity of the cyclones. The prediction of cyclones before they are identified as 850-hPa vorticity centers in the analysis cycle was also considered. It is shown that an indication of extratropical cyclones can be given by at least 1 ensemble member 7 days before they are identified in the analysis. Further analysis of the ECMWF EPS shows that the ensemble mean has a higher level of skill than the control forecast, particularly for the intensity of the cyclones, from day 3 of the forecast. There is a higher level of skill in the NH than the SH and the spread in the SH is correspondingly larger. The difference between the ensemble mean error and spread is very small for the position of the cyclones, but the spread of the ensemble is smaller than the ensemble mean error for the intensity of the cyclones in both hemispheres. Results also show that the ECMWF control forecast has ½ to 1 day more skill than the perturbed members, for both the position and intensity of the cyclones, throughout the forecast.


Related Articles

  • Assimilation of SSM/I Radiances in the NCEP Global Data Assimilation System. Okamoto, Kozo; Derber, John C. // Monthly Weather Review;Sep2006, Vol. 134 Issue 9, p2612 

    A technique for the assimilation of Special Sensor Microwave Imager (SSM/I) data in the National Centers for Environmental Prediction (NCEP) global data assimilation and forecast system is described. Because the radiative transfer model used does not yet allow for cloud/rain effects, it is...

  • An Hourly Assimilation–Forecast Cycle: The RUC. Benjamin, Stanley G.; Dévényi, Dezsö; Weygandt, Stephen S.; Brundage, Kevin J.; Brown, John M.; Grell, Georg A.; Kim, Dongsoo; Schwartz, Barry E.; Smirnova, Tatiana G.; Smith, Tracy Lorraine; Manikin, Geoffrey S. // Monthly Weather Review;Feb2004, Vol. 132 Issue 2, p495 

    The Rapid Update Cycle (RUC), an operational regional analysis–forecast system among the suite of models at the National Centers for Environmental Prediction (NCEP), is distinctive in two primary aspects: its hourly assimilation cycle and its use of a hybrid isentropic–sigma...

  • A Comparison of Adaptive Observing Guidance for Atlantic Tropical Cyclones. Majumdar, S. J.; Aberson, S. D.; Bishop, C. H.; Buizza, R.; Peng, M. S.; Reynolds, C. A. // Monthly Weather Review;Sep2006, Vol. 134 Issue 9, p2354 

    Airborne adaptive observations have been collected for more than two decades in the neighborhood of tropical cyclones, to attempt to improve short-range forecasts of cyclone track. However, only simple subjective strategies for adaptive observations have been used, and the utility of objective...

  • Short- and Medium-Range Prediction of Tropical and Transitioning Cyclone Tracks within the NCEP Global Ensemble Forecasting System. Buckingham, Christian; Marchok, Timothy; Ginis, Isaac; Rothstein, Lewis; Rowe, Dail // Weather & Forecasting;Dec2010, Vol. 25 Issue 6, p1736 

    The NCEP Global Ensemble Forecasting System (GEFS) is examined in its ability to predict tropical cyclone and extratropical transition (ET) positions. Forecast and observed tracks are compared in Atlantic and western North Pacific basins for 2006--08, and the accuracy and consistency of the...

  • Assessing Predictability with a Local Ensemble Kalman Filter. Kuhl, David; Szunyogh, Istvan; Kostelich, Eric J.; Gyarmati, Gyorgyi; Patil, D. J.; Oczkowski, Michael; Hunt, Brian R.; Kalnay, Eugenia; Ott, Edward; Yorke, James A. // Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences;Apr2007, Vol. 64 Issue 4, p1116 

    In this paper, the spatiotemporally changing nature of predictability is studied in a reduced-resolution version of the National Centers for Environmental Prediction (NCEP) Global Forecast System (GFS), a state-of-the-art numerical weather prediction model. Atmospheric predictability is assessed...

  • Strong Trends in the Skill of the ERA-40 and NCEP–NCAR Reanalyses in the High and Midlatitudes of the Southern Hemisphere, 1958–2001. Bromwich, David H.; Fogt, Ryan L. // Journal of Climate;Dec2004, Vol. 17 Issue 23, p4603 

    The European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) Re-Analysis (ERA-40) and the National Centers for Environmental Prediction–National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCEP–NCAR) reanalysis (NCEP1) data are compared with Antarctic and other mid- to high-latitude station...

  • Climatology and interannual variability of storm-tracks in the Euro-Atlantic sector: a comparison between ERA-40 and NCEP/NCAR reanalyses. Trigo, Isabel Franco // Climate Dynamics;Feb2006, Vol. 26 Issue 2/3, p127 

    An objective methodology is applied to ERA-40 (European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts 40-year Reanalysis) and NCEP/NCAR (National Centers for Environmental Prediction/National Center for Atmospheric Research) reanalyses, to build two storm-track databases for the Euro-Atlantic sector...

  • Estimation of Predictability with a Newly Derived Index to Quantify Similarity among Ensemble Members. Yamada, Tomohito J.; Koster, Randal D.; Kanae, Shinjiro; Oki, Taikan // Monthly Weather Review;Jul2007, Vol. 135 Issue 7, p2674 

    This study reveals the mathematical structure of a statistical index, Ω, that quantifies similarity among ensemble members in a weather forecast. Previous approaches for quantifying predictability estimate separately the phase and shape characteristics of a forecast ensemble. The diagnostic...

  • The Skill of Ensemble Prediction Systems. Atger, Frederic // Monthly Weather Review;Sep99, Vol. 127 Issue 9, p1 

    The performance of ensemble prediction systems (EPSs) is investigated by examining the probability distribution of 500-hPa geopotential height over Europe. The probability score (or half Brier score) is used to evaluate the quality of probabilistic forecasts of a single binary event. The skill...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics