TITLE

Silence Speaks Volumes: The Effectiveness of Reticence in Comparison to Apology and Denial for Responding to Integrity- and Competence-Based Trust Violations

AUTHOR(S)
Ferrin, Donald L.; Kim, Peter H.; Cooper, Cecily D.; Dirks, Kurt T.
PUB. DATE
July 2007
SOURCE
Journal of Applied Psychology;Jul2007, Vol. 92 Issue 4, p893
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
Prior research on responses to trust violations has focused primarily on the effects of apology and denial. The authors extended this research by studying another type of verbal response that is often used to respond to trust violations but has not been considered in the trust literature: reticence. An accused party may use reticence in a sincere and even legitimate attempt to persuade a trustor to withhold judgment. Yet, by considering information diagnosticity and belief formation mechanisms through which verbal responses influence trust, the authors argue that reticence is a suboptimal response because it combines the least effective elements of apology and denial. Specifically, reticence is a suboptimal response to an integrity violation because, like apology, it fails to address guilt. And reticence is a suboptimal response to a competence violation because, like denial, it fails to signal redemption. Results from 2 laboratory studies, simulating different contexts and using research participants from 2 different countries, provide support for the prediction. The results offer important implications for those who might use reticence to respond to a perceived trust violation and also for those who must judge another's reticence.
ACCESSION #
25742199

 

Related Articles

  • Apologize Right. Booher, Dianna // Personal Excellence Essentials;Jun2009, Vol. 14 Issue 6, p12 

    The article deals with the importance of apologizing to someone. It describes several kinds of fake apologies including one with denial, one with good intentions and that asks for some credit, one with excuses, one with personal problems as reason for committing a mistake, and one with an...

  • 8 Ways to Live in Denial. Martin, Peter // Esquire;May2003, Vol. 139 Issue 5, p44 

    Presents a list of ways to live in denial.

  • SILENCE SPEAKS VOLUMES: THE EFFECTIVENESS OF RETICENCE IN COMPARISON TO APOLOGY AND DENIAL FOR REPAIRING INTEGRITY- AND COMPETENCE-BASED TRUST VIOLATIONS. Ferrin, Donald L.; Kim, Peter H.; Cooper, Cecily D.; Dirks, Kurt T. // Academy of Management Annual Meeting Proceedings;2005, pC1 

    Prior research on trust repair has focused primarily on the effects of apology and denial. We recognize another form of verbal response: reticence. Although reticence is sometimes used for strategic reasons (e.g., to unjustifiably evade culpability), reticence is also used in many situations...

  • The Denial Strategy. Roach, Thomas J. // Rock Products;May2007, Vol. 110 Issue 5, p10 

    The author presents his views about denial strategy. He mentions that in the early days of public relations, the standard policy would be to keep quiet and, if forced to comment, to deny the allegation even if it were true. He states that in most cases admission of guilt, while it temporarily...

  • REFUSING TO FACE THE FACTS.  // Mayo Clinic Women's Health Source;Apr2007, Vol. 11 Issue 4, p7 

    The article explains how denial can impact health conditions. The term denial refers to an unconscious defense mechanism a person uses to resolve emotional conflict. Denial can be protective when a person faces intense trauma or grief. However, denial can also be harmful to a person. The author...

  • The Dynamics of Denial.  // Electronic Ardell Wellness Report (E-AWR);12/7/2007, Issue 412, p2 

    The article discusses the health function of denial. It explains the disadvantages and advantages of this mental state on health as well as explores various studies related to the use of this defense mechanism. The author notes that the key to effective denial is balance between actual reality...

  • STRATEGIES TO MANAGE THE CLAIM DENIAL PROCESS. WOODCOCK, ELIZABETH // Medical Economics;5/25/2015, Vol. 92 Issue 10, p48 

    The article offers tips on how to harness denials to improve the performance of one's practice. Topics discussed include improving denial management, preventing denials, and examples of controllable denials. Some of the tips mentioned include being positive, focusing on process, and assessing...

  • Denying Impending Death.  // Mayo Clinic Guide to Women's Cancers;2005, p570 

    This article focuses on the denial of impending death by a cancer patient. Some people with advanced cancer find it difficult, if not impossible, to accept that their treatments are no longer working and that their cancers are terminal. They may employ a defense mechanism known as denial. Denial...

  • A Micro-primer on Corruption.  // Economic & Political Weekly;12/26/2015, Vol. 50 Issue 52, p9 

    The article offers information on corruption as one of the most pressing requirements of achievement and success in the modern world. It mentions the things that children should do when caught in the corruption act which include denial and claim ignorance of the facts and assert their...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics