Report of 255 Clinical Ethics Consultations and Review of the Literature

Swetz, Keith M.; Crowley, Mary Eliot; Hook, C. Christopher; Mueller, Paul S.
June 2007
Mayo Clinic Proceedings;Jun2007, Vol. 82 Issue 6, p686
Academic Journal
OBJECTIVE: To review clinical ethics consultations at a tertiary care academic medical center. METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed all ethics consultations (and associated patient medical records) conducted at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn, between April 6, 1995, and December 31, 2005. RESULTS: Of the 255 consultations, 101 (40%) reviewed intensive care unit care, 103 (40%) involved patients who died during hospitalization, and 174 (68%) were requested by physicians. The most common primary diagnoses of the patients involved were malignancy (18%, n=47), neurologic disease (18%, n=47), and cardiovascular disease (17%, n=43). Most cases involved multiple issues: patient competency and decision-making capacity (82%, n=208), staff member disagreement with care plans (76%, n=195), end-of-life and quality-of-life issues (60%, n=154), and goals of care and futility (54%, n=138). Withholding or withdrawing measures was the focus of 132 (52%) of the consultations. We also identified previously published reports of ethics consultations and compared the findings of those reports with ours. CONCLUSIONS: Despite advances in medicine, the nature of ethical dilemmas remains relatively unchanged. Issues of communication, family conflict, and futility continue to give rise to ethical quandaries.


Related Articles

  • MEWS to e-MEWS: From a Paper-Based to an Electronic Clinical Decision Support System. O'Kane, Tom; O'Donoghue, John; Gallagher, Joe; Aftab, A.; Casey, Aveline; Angove, Philip; Torres, Javier; Courtney, Garry // Proceedings of the European Conference on Information Management;2010, p301 

    It is now well established that many patients already in hospital can suddenly become acutely ill but experience delayed recognition of their physiological deterioration resulting in late referral to critical care or in some cases death. In recent years there has been significant growth in the...

  • Determinants of outcome in elderly patients admitted to the intensive care unit. Vosylius, Saulius; Sipylaite, Jurate; Ivaskevicius, Juozas // Age & Ageing;Mar2005, Vol. 34 Issue 2, p157 

    Background: age is thought to be strongly associated with intensive care outcomes, but this relationship may be confounded by many clinical variables. Objectives: to compare clinical characteristics of elderly patients (≥65 years) admitted to the intensive care unit (ICU) with those in...

  • A national analysis of the relationship between hospital factors and post-cardiac arrest mortality. Carr, Brendan G.; Goyal, Munish; Band, Roger A.; Gaieski, David F.; Abella, Benjamin S.; Merchant, Raina M.; Branas, Charles C.; Becker, Lance B.; Neumar, Robert W. // Intensive Care Medicine;Mar2009, Vol. 35 Issue 3, p505 

    We sought to generate national estimates for post-cardiac arrest mortality, to assess trends, and to identify hospital factors associated with survival. We used a national sample of US hospitals to identify patients resuscitated after cardiac arrest from 2000 to 2004 to describe the association...

  • Skin Breakdown in Acute Care Pediatrics. Suddaby, Elizabeth C.; Barnett, Scott; Facteau, Lorna // Pediatric Nursing;Mar/Apr2005, Vol. 31 Issue 2, p132 

    Purpose: To develop a simple, single-page measurement tool that evaluates risk of skin breakdown in the pediatric population and apply it to the acutely hospitalized child. Methods: Data were collected over a 15-month period from 347 patients on four in-patient units (PICU, medical-surgical,...

  • Consultant Input in Acute Medical Admissions and Patient Outcomes in Hospitals in England: A Multivariate Analysis. Bell, Derek; Lambourne, Adrian; Percival, Frances; Laverty, Anthony A.; Ward, David K. // PLoS ONE;Apr2013, Vol. 8 Issue 4, p1 

    Recent recommendations for physicians in the UK outline key aspects of care that should improve patient outcomes and experience in acute hospital care. Included in these recommendations are Consultant patterns of work to improve timeliness of clinical review and improve continuity of care. This...

  • Network helps hospitals develop own evidence-based medicine. Johnston, Cameron // CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;03/10/98, Vol. 158 Issue 5, p642 

    Discusses how the Critical Care Research Network, based in London, Ontario, aims to improve hospital care by having hospitals share information. Comments from Dr. William Sibbald, who heads the network; Example of how the research network uses all four points in the `how-are-we-doing-so-far'...

  • Organisation of intensive care. Bennett, David; Bion, Julian // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);05/29/99, Vol. 318 Issue 7196, p1468 

    Focuses on the status of intensive care in Great Britain. Origin of intensive care; Policy on the allocation of intensive care nurses; Costs of intensive care.

  • Assessing intensive care. Lowry, Stella // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);5/6/89, Vol. 298 Issue 6682, p1205 

    Evaluates intensive care in Great Britain. Disadvantages of intensive care units for patients; Guidelines for the management of intensive care units; Criteria for the admission to intensive care units.

  • Prologue. López Beceiro, Ana Mª // Spanish Journal of Rural Development;Mar2013 Special Issue, Vol. 4, preceding p1 

    An introduction is presented in which the editor discusses various topics within the issue including zoo and wild fauna conservation, hospitalization, and critical care.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics