Limitations of the New York Heart Association functional classification system and self-reported walking distances in chronic heart failure

Raphael, Claire; Briscoe, Cathy; Davies, Justin; Whinnett, Zachary Ian; Manisly, Charloite; Sutton, Richard; Mayet, Jamil; Francis, Darrel P.
April 2007
Heart;Apr2007, Vol. 93 Issue 4, p476
Academic Journal
Background: Two ways to evaluate the symptoms of heart failure are the New York Heart Association (NYHA) classification and asking patients how far they can walk (walk distance). The NYHA system is commonly used, although it is not clear how individual clinicians apply it. Aim: To investigate how useful these measures are to assess heart failure and whether other questions might be more helpful. Methods: 30 cardiologists were asked what questions they used when assessing patients with heart failure. To assess interoperator variability, two cardiologists assessed a series of 50 patients in classes II and III using the NYHA classification. 45 patients who had undergone cardiopulmonary testing were interviewed using a specially formulated questionnaire. They were also asked how far they could walk before being stopped by symptoms, and then tested on their ability to estimate distance. Results: The survey of cardiologists showed no consistent method for assessing NYHA class and a literature survey showed that 99% of research papers do not reference or describe their methods for assigning NYHA classes. The interoperator variability study showed only 54% concordance between the two cardiologists. 70% of cardiologists asked patients for their walk distance; however, this walk distance correlated poorly with actual exercise capacity measured by cardiopulmonary testing (p=0.04, p=0.82). Conclusion: No consistent method of assessing NYHA class is in use and the interoperator study on class II and class III patients gave a result little better than chance. Some potential questions are offered for use in assessment. Walking distance, although frequently asked, does not correlate with formally measured exercise capacity, even after correction for patient perception of distance, and has never been found to have prognostic relevance. Its value is therefore doubtful.


Related Articles

  • Global Insights.  // Health Affairs;Jan/Feb2009, Vol. 28 Issue 1, p178 

    The article discusses various reports published within the issue, including one by Chris Ham on the origins, organization and results of efforts in managing chronic diseases in Great Britain, and another by Julie Sochalski and colleagues on the examination of studies in the management of heart...

  • The Contribution of Chronic Conditions and Disabilities to Poor Self-Rated Health in Elderly Men. Hoeymans, Nancy; Feskens, Edith J. M. // Journals of Gerontology Series A: Biological Sciences & Medical ;Oct99, Vol. 54 Issue 10, pM501 

    Investigates the contribution of chronic conditions and disabilities to poor self-rated health from the perspectives of the patient and the population in Zutphen, Netherlands. Importance of self-rated health; Health impact of lung and musculoskeletal diseases for evaluation of one's own health;...

  • New recommendations urge 4-drug regimen for chronic heart failure. Pinkowish, Mary Desmond // Patient Care;4/15/1999, Vol. 33 Issue 7, p49 

    Summarizes the data supporting the use of a four-drug regimen for the treatment of chronic heart failure. Effectiveness of the combined use of digitalis, diuretics, beta-blockers and angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors; Reduction of mortality and morbidity associated with heart failure;...

  • Chronic heart failure with reduced ejection fraction. Moayedi, Yasbanoo; Kobulnik, Jeremy // CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;4/7/2015, Vol. 187 Issue 7, p518 

    The article presents questions and answers related to the diagnosis and treatment of chronic heart failure with reduced ejection fraction.

  • Self-rated health in patients with chronic heart failure: distribution and association with mortality. Farkas, J.; Nabb, S.L.; Zaletel-Kragelj, L.; Cleland, J.G.F.; Lainscak, M. // European Journal of Heart Failure. Supplements;Jun2008, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p94 

    An abstract of the article "Self-rated health in patients with chronic heart failure: distribution and association with mortality," by J. Farkas and colleagues is presented.

  • A study comparing validity and reliability of the incremental shuttle walk test and 6-minute walk test in chronic heart failure. Cowie, A.; Thow, M.; Granat, M.; Mitchell, S. // European Journal of Heart Failure. Supplements;Jun2008, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p74 

    An abstract of the article "A study comparing validity and reliability of the incremental shuttle walk test and 6-minute walk test in chronic heart failure," A. Cowie and colleagues is presented.

  • Six-minute walk test helps assess peripheral arterial disease, heart failure.  // Modern Medicine;Aug98, Vol. 66 Issue 8, p28 

    Presents an abstract of the articles `The Clinical Utility of a Six-Minute Walk Test in Peripheral Arterial Occlusive Disease Patients,' by P.S. Montgomery and A. W. Gardner from the`Journal of American Geriatrics Society' dated June 1998 and `Effects of Maximally Tolerated Oral Therapy on the...

  • Development of a Spiritual Self-Care Practice Scale. White, Mary L.; Myers Schim, Stephanie // Journal of Nursing Measurement;2013, Vol. 21 Issue 3, p450 

    Background and Purpose: Development of a valid, reliable instrument to measure spiritual self-care practices of patients with heart failure. Methods: African American patients (N = 142) with heart failure participated in the study. Spiritual advisors from several religious groups reviewed the...

  • Clinical digest. Walking groups deliver health bene ts to people with long-term conditions.  // Nursing Standard;2/4/2015, Vol. 29 Issue 23, p17 

    The article reports on the findings of a study which showed that joining an outdoor walking group can result in significant health benefits to adults with long-term conditions.


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics