Is Rebalancing a Portfolio During Retirement Necessary?

Spitzer, John J.; Singh, Sandeep
June 2007
Journal of Financial Planning;Jun2007, Vol. 20 Issue 6, p46
Academic Journal
• This paper investigates the strategy of rebalancing the retirement portfolio during the withdrawal phase. The goal is to provide the largest number of equal (real) withdrawals from a given retirement portfolio. • The study investigates six different allocations of stock and five different harvesting rules, only one of which rebalances the portfolio annually. The methods are tested using five different withdrawals rates (37 percent).The results look at shortfalls over 30 years, as well as shorter periods, • The study uses two analysis methods: bootstrap and historical inflation-adjusted rates of return in their true temporal order. Both methods find that rebalancing provides no significant protection on portfolio longevity, and this holds for al! withdrawal periods. In fact, in some cases, rebalancing increases the number of shortfalls, • Withdrawing bonds first, over stocks, performs the best of all the methods, though the resulting stock-heavy portfolio may make some investors uneasy. This method also is most apt to leave a larger remaining balance at the end of 30 years, while rebalancing leaves the smallest amount, • Withdrawing stocks first leaves more shortfalls than withdrawing low first or high first. • Confirming previous research, the larger the proportion of stocks to bonds, the longer the portfolio lasts: the higher the withdrawal rate, the more shortfalls. • The results suggest that the use of lifecycle funds or a life-cycle strategy that decreases stock proportions as one grows older needs empirical justification.


Related Articles

  • Know goals before investing. Howell, Steve // Fort Worth Business Press;2/13/2004, Vol. 17 Issue 6, p31 

    Focuses on investment portfolio management. Discussion on retirement and insurance plans; Importance of prioritizing financial goals; Information on flexibility of investment portfolio.

  • Investing lessons a turtle would love. Hauke, Keenan // Indianapolis Business Journal;8/3/2009, Vol. 30 Issue 22, p24 

    The article discusses the lessons that the investors must learn from sea turtles on investing. The author said that patience and simplicity are the secrets to grow portfolio on a long-term sustainable basis. Moreover, the author suggests to put some money to work if the investor has the ability...

  • Good Steward or Salesman? How to Evaluate Fund Managers. Marsh, Ann // Financial-planning.com;6/26/2015, p8 

    The article discusses the guidelines for selecting fund managers that exercise high standards of stewardship of investor assets over those who employ salesmen tactics to accumulate managed funds. Recommended actions are to review director and manager profiles for expertise and stability, to...

  • Across the great divide. Southon, Mike; West, Chris // Director;Jan2006, Vol. 59 Issue 6, p18 

    This article discusses a series of investment-readiness programs that would be helpful to new investors. The challenges commonly faced by investors are assessed. The complaints raised by lenders against investors are provided. The importance of employing financial analysts to small business is...

  • Fund charges - fact vs fiction. Patel, Mona // Money Marketing;3/8/2012, p50 

    The author comments on the criticisms against the fund management industry. She claims that the campaign against the industry is fabricated. She discusses some of the fabricated charges against the industry, including that fund managers hide the cost of trading, high trading costs resulting to...

  • Triumph of the Yardstick. Riepe, Mark W. // Journal of Financial Planning;Oct2002, Vol. 15 Issue 10, p40 

    This article focuses on the stock indexes, rating agencies and auditing firms that hold influence on the companies they rate or evaluate. Stock indexes, in various forms, have been around for over 100 years. Though their original purpose was to describe what was happening in a particular market,...

  • The Six Biggest Money Mistakes [And How To Avoid Them]. Chatzky, Jean; Bigda, Carolyn; Jervey, Gay // Money;Dec2004, Vol. 33 Issue 12, p92 

    The article presents the results from the MONEY/MLIM Survey of Americans and Their Money Mistakes and explains how to avoid six big financial mistakes. Not saving enough: nearly half of those who took the MONEY/MLIM survey confessed that they had waited too long to start saving and investing,...

  • Danger points. Nicholson, Colin // BRW;2/16/2006, Vol. 28 Issue 6, p94 

    The article relates the author's views on the factors that affected small and speculative stocks based on the recent correction. Genepharm Australasia is defined as a speculative stock that should not be part of risk-averse investment portfolios. This marked where the optimistic speculator had...

  • Household Portfolio Diversification: A Case for Rank-Dependent Preferences. Polkovnichenko, Valery // Review of Financial Studies;Winter2005, Vol. 18 Issue 4, p1467 

    The proliferation of novel preference theories in financial economics is hampered by a lack of non-experimental evidence and by the theories' additional complexity which has not been shown to be critical in applications. In this article I present arguments in support of preferences with rank...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics