Response of paramedics to terminally ill patients with cardiac arrest: an ethical dilemma

Guru, Veena; Verbeek, P. Richard; Morrison, Laurie J.
November 1999
CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;11/16/99, Vol. 161 Issue 10, p1251
Academic Journal
AbstractBackground: In an environment characterized by cuts to health care, hospital closures, increasing reliance on home care and an aging population, more terminally ill patients are choosing to die at home. The authors sought to determine the care received by these patients when paramedics were summoned by a 911 call and to document whether do-not-resuscitate (DNR) requests influenced the care given.Methods: The records of a large urban emergency medical services system were reviewed to identify consecutive patients with cardiac arrest over the 10-month period November 1996 to August 1997. Data were abstracted from paramedics' ambulance call reports according to a standardized template. The proportion of these patients described as having a terminal illness was determined, as was the proportion of terminally ill patients with a DNR request. The resuscitative efforts of paramedics were compared for patients with and without a DNR request.Results: Of the 1534 cardiac arrests, 144 (9.4%) involved patients described as having a terminal illness. The mean age of the patients was 72.2 (standard deviation 14.8) years. Paramedics encountered a DNR request in 90 (62.5%) of these cases. Current regulations governing paramedic practice were not followed in 34 (23.6%) of the cases. There was no difference in the likelihood that cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) would be initiated between patients with and those without a DNR request (73% v. 83%; p = 0.17). In patients for whom CPR was initiated, paramedics were much more likely to withhold full advanced cardiac life support if there was a DNR request than if there was not (22% v. 68%; p < 0.001).Interpretation: Paramedics are frequently called to attend terminally ill patients with cardiac arrest. Current regulations are a source of conflict between the paramedic's duty to treat and the patient's right to limit resuscitative efforts at the time of death.


Related Articles

  • Incompetent Patients with Limited Care in the Absence of Family Consent. Brennan, Troyen A. // Annals of Internal Medicine;11/15/88, Vol. 109 Issue 10, p819 

    Provides information on a study that examined the factors that distinguished terminally ill, incompetent patients who are given do-not-resuscitate status by physicians against the wishes of the patient's family. Methodology of the study; Results and discussion on the study.

  • Exploring the Definition of an Informed Health Care Proxy. Ma, Joseph D.; Benn, Melanie; Nelson, Sandahl H.; Campillo, Ashleigh; Heavey, Sean F.; Cramer, Arlene; Revta, Carolyn; Thornberry, Kathryn; Roeland, Eric J. // Journal of Palliative Medicine;Mar2016, Vol. 19 Issue 3, p250 

    The article presents a study on establishing a health care proxy amid discussing advance care planning and end-of-life treatment with patients. Topics covered include the focus on advance directives, physician orders for life-sustaining treatment and code status, the consultation with the...

  • Increased rate of DNR status in hospitalized end-of-life patients in Taiwan. Cheng, Ming-Tai; Hsih, Fu-Yuan; Tsai, Chu-Lin; Tsai, Hung-Bin; Tsai, Daniel; Fang, Cheng-Chung; Tsai, Daniel Fu-Chang // Intensive Care Medicine;Nov2016, Vol. 42 Issue 11, p1816 

    A letter to the editor is presented in response to the article "Increased rate of DNR status in hospitalized end-of-life patients in Taiwan" in the August 25, 2016 issue.

  • When communication fails: Resolving end-of-life impasses. Davenport, Lisa Z.; Schopp, Georgeanne // JAAPA: Journal of the American Academy of Physician Assistants (;Jun2014, Vol. 27 Issue 6, p28 

    Various protocols and advance directives can prepare physician assistants for difficult conversations with patients about end-of-life care. This case scenario explores the roles and influences that complicated one patient's care and how the situation was resolved

  • Revival of confidence. Dean, Erin // Nursing Standard;12/3/2014, Vol. 29 Issue 14, p24 

    The use of cardiopulmonary resuscitation has posed logistical and ethical challenges for the law, healthcare professionals, patients and their families. New guidance offers help, reports Erin Dean.

  • Are these Statements about Hospice on or off the Mark?  // Long-Term Care Survey Alert;Sep2010, Vol. 12 Issue 9, p72 

    The article provides answers to questions related to hospices in the U.S. including the do-not-resuscitate (DNR) policy, prescription medication privileges, and single care plan.

  • Diffuse Pontine Glioma in Jordan and Impact of Up-front Prognosis Disclosure With Parents and Families. Qaddoumi, Ibrahim; Ezam, Najeeb; Swaidan, Maisa; Jaradat, Imad; Mansour, Asem; Abuirmeileh, Najyah; Bouffet, Eric; Al-Hussaini, Maysa // Journal of Child Neurology;Apr2009, Vol. 24 Issue 4, p460 

    For patients with diffuse pontine glioma, our institution offers local radiotherapy and supportive care only. The prognosis and do-not-resuscitate orders are discussed upfront with patients' parents. To investigate the effectiveness of this policy, we retrospectively reviewed records of patients...

  • Prevalence of Patients With Do-Not-Resuscitate Status on Acute Geriatric Wards in Flanders, Belgium. De Gendt, Cindy; Bilsen, Johan; Van Den Noortgate, Nele; Lambert, Margareta; Stichele, Robert Vander; Deliens, Luc // Journals of Gerontology Series A: Biological Sciences & Medical ;Apr2007, Vol. 62 Issue 4, p395 

    Background. Elderly hospitalized patients have low survival rates after cardiopulmonary resuscitation, especially in the long term. This study aims to investigate the prevalence of patients with do-not-resuscitate (DNR) status on acute geriatric wards and the characteristics of the preceding...

  • Use of the Physician Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment (POLST) Paradigm Program in the Hospice Setting. Hickman, Susan E.; Nelson, Christine A.; Moss, Alvin H.; Hammes, Bernard J.; Terwilliger, Allison; Jackson, Ann; Tolle, Susan W. // Journal of Palliative Medicine;Feb2009, Vol. 12 Issue 2, p133 

    Background: The Physician Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment (POLST) Paradigm Program was designed to ensure the full range of patient treatment preferences are honored throughout the health care system. Data are lacking about the use of POLST in the hospice setting. Objective: To assess use...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics