An evaluation of Medline published paediatric audits from 1966 to 1999

O'Gorman, Clodagh Sheila; Ziedan, Yasir; O'Neill, Michael Brendan
April 2007
Archives of Disease in Childhood;Apr2007, Vol. 92 Issue 4, p309
Academic Journal
Aim: To evaluate the quality of paediatric audits from 1966 to 1999. Methods: A Medline search was performed using the MeSH terms audit, child, paediatric (and pediatric). Predefined core elements of audit were used as inclusion criteria for entry of an article into this study. These criteria were as follows: (1) an article deals with a healthcare topic; (2) a standard is predefined; (3) actual practice is evaluated; (4) actual practice is compared with the standard. The fifth criterion of audit, dissemination of information and reaudit, was not an inclusion criterion, as it was not used in the early years covered by this study. Empirical grading of standards was used. Results: The search yielded 442 articles, of which 303 (100%) were related to paediatric healthcare and were reviewed. Standards were defined in 115 (38%) articles. Audit against the standard was performed in 92 (30.4%) articles, of which 42 (45.6%) were published before, and 50 (54.3%) after, 1990. 18 (5.9%) articles were re-audited: 6 (14.3%) were published before, and 12 (24%) after, 1990. Of the 188 paediatric studies rejected, 119 (63.3%) described practice observations. Conclusion: Many articles in paediatrics are published as ‘audits’, but they do not contain the core elements of audit. Although audit is a potentially valuable tool in clinical medicine, the publication of poor-quality audits may lead to the decline of the audit concept. Suggestions on ways to improve the quality of published audits are made.


Related Articles

  • A NOVEL APPROACH TO DETERMINING BEST MEDICAL PRACTICES: LOOKING AT THE EVIDENCE. Tucker, John // Houston Journal of Health Law & Policy;2010, Vol. 10, p147 

    The article discusses the effective guidelines for best medical practices for the improvement of health care in the U.S. The guidelines incorporate clinician workflow and strategies for compliance in the guideline delivery system. The legislators will also play a key role in meeting the...

  • Towards complete and accurate reporting of studies of diagnostic accuracy: the STARD initiative. Bossuyt, Patrick M.; Reitsma, Johannes B.; Bruns, David E.; Gatsonis, Constantine A.; Glasziou, Paul P.; Irwig, Les M.; Lijmer, Jeroen G.; Moher, David; Rennie, Drummond; de Vet, Henrica C.W. // Annals of Clinical Biochemistry;Jul2003, Vol. 40 Issue 4, p357 

    Background: To improve the accuracy and completeness of reporting of studies of diagnostic accuracy in order to allow readers to assess the potential for bias in a study and to evaluate the generalizability of its results. Methods: The Standards for Reporting of Diagnostic Accuracy (STARD)...

  • Physician Clinical Performance Assessment: Prospects and Barriers. Landon, Bruce E.; Normand, Sharon-Lise T.; Blumenthal, David; Daley, Jennifer // JAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association;9/3/2003, Vol. 290 Issue 9, p1183 

    The performance of physicians in their day-to-day clinical practices has become an area of intense public interest. Both patients and health care purchasers want more effective means of identifying excellent clinicians, and a variety of organizations are discussing and implementing plans for...

  • Who is leading guideline development in tissue viability? Coull, Alison // British Journal of Nursing;10/28/2004, Vol. 13 Issue 19, pS3 

    Discusses the development of evidence-based guidelines in tissue viability practice in Great Britain. Information on the best practice statements produced by the Nursing and Midwifery Practice Development Unit in Scotland; Impact of the presence of specialist nurses on tissue viability...

  • Bridging the gap between basic science and clinical practice: a role for community clinicians. Kahn, Katherine; Ryan, Gery; Beckett, Megan; Taylor, Stephanie; Berrebi, Claude; Cho, Michelle; Quiter, Elaine; Fremont, Allen; Pincus, Harold // Implementation Science;2011, Vol. 6 Issue 1, p34 

    Background: Translating the extraordinary scientific and technological advances occurring in medical research laboratories into care for patients in communities throughout the country has been a major challenge. One contributing factor has been the relative absence of community practitioners...

  • Evidence based case report: Assessing developmental delay. Dorling, Jon; Salt, Alison // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);7/21/2001, Vol. 323 Issue 7305, p148 

    Reports on an evidence based medical assessment of an 18 month old boy who could not walk independently. Search for information on cerebral palsy, Duchenne muscular dystrophy and creatine kinase levels as possible causes; Details of studies related to each condition; Thoughts on the benefits...

  • Healing Thought From The Strangest Places. Duncan, James // Subconsciously Speaking;May/Jun2005, Vol. 20 Issue 3, p4 

    The article discusses the healing process and therapeutics related thereto applied by the medical personnel in order to cure a disease. Focusing on the experiences of various physicians it is reported in the article that inspiration to a patient works like a canon shot. If a doctor treats a...

  • Talk Back. Kano, Jane; Temple, James P.; Brumm, Lynn F. // Medical Economics;11/19/2010, Vol. 87 Issue 22, p15 

    Several letters to the editor are presented in response to articles in previous issues including "Care goes beyond sophisticated tests," by Hien Nguyen in the October 8, 2010 issue, "A good job," by Jennifer Frank in the October 8, 2010 issue, and one which discusses midlevel care by physician...

  • Good clinical practice and informed consent are inseparable.  // Heart;Feb2002, Vol. 87 Issue 2, p103 

    It is now widely accepted that clinicians should negotiate rather than dictate what is in the best interests of patients.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics