TITLE

Reliability of disclosure forms of authors' contributions

AUTHOR(S)
Ilakovac, Vesna; Fister, Kristina; Marusic, Matko; Marusic, Ana
PUB. DATE
January 2007
SOURCE
CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;1/2/2007, Vol. 176 Issue 1, p41
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
Abstract Background The contribution disclosure forms used by medical journals to assess and confirm authorship are surveys of self-reported behaviour that follow the cognitive rules of psychometric instruments. We sought to analyze how autobiographical memory, defined as memory for events and issues related to oneself, affected the reliability of contribution forms for the judging of authorship of research articles. Methods We conducted a prospective study, which ultimately included 919 authors of 201 articles submitted to a general medical journal from July 2001 through December 2002. A authorship disclosure form with a checklist of 11 possible contribution choices for all authors was sent first to each article's corresponding author, who was asked to fill it out for all authors. A blank form was then sent to each author individually to disclose his or her own contribution to that article. The main outcome measure was test- retest differences between the corresponding authors' self-declarations, expressed in percent as the gross difference rate (GDR) for each article. Results More than two-thirds of the corresponding authors (69.7%) differed in at least 1 contribution choice between the 2 disclosure statements made about their own contributions. The reliability of their answers was low to moderate (GDRs > 10%), especially for contributions on the provision of study materials or patients or final approval of the article (GDR 22.9%), guarantor of the study (GDR 20.9%) and drafting of the manuscript (GDR 20.4%). As a proxy for their coauthors' contributions, corresponding authors also differed from them in the perception of noncorresponding authors' contributions, disagreeing in 69.4% of cases. Of the 718 noncorresponding authors, 204 (28.4%) met all the criteria for authorship set out by the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors according to the statement given by the corresponding author. When they described their own contributions, this prevalence increased to 40.5%. Interpretation Psychological factors such as autobiographical memory may confound contribution disclosures as an evaluation tool for authorship on scientific articles and affect responsible authorship and publication practices.
ACCESSION #
24990860

 

Related Articles

  • Reliability of disclosure forms of authors' contributions. Llakovac, Vesna; Fister, Kristina; Marusic, Matko; Marusic, Ana // CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal Supplement;1/2/2007, Vol. 176 Issue 1, p41 

    Background: The contribution disclosure forms used by medical journals to assess and confirm authorship are surveys of self-reported behaviour that follow the cognitive rules of psychometric instruments. We sought to analyze how autobiographical memory, defined as memory for events and issues...

  • ICMJE Form for Disclosure of Potential Conflicts of Interest.  // Journal of Rehabilitation Research & Development;2012, Vol. 49 Issue 4, p1 

    The article presents a disclosure form for authors submitting to the journal.

  • The Effect of Regulation on Earnings Announcement Timing: Evidence from Regulation G. Pawlewicz, Robert J. // Proceedings of the Northeast Business & Economics Association;2010, p91 

    Regulation G (Reg G, SEC 2003), effective for all earnings announcement press releases made on or after Mach 28, 2003, requires companies to furnish the SEC their earnings releases on a Form 8-K. Thus, Reg G created a new environment for earnings announcements, previously unregulated, by...

  • THE SCOPE OF DISCLOSURES OF FAIR VALUE MEASUREMENT METHODS OF FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS IN FINANCIAL STATEMENTS OF BANKS LISTED ON THE WARSAW STOCK EXCHANGE. Kunz, Bożena // Research Papers of the Wroclaw University of Economics / Prace N;2015, Issue 381, p158 

    The fair value is one of the most significant of valuation categories. The reliable assessment of the value of assets and liabilities contributes to the accuracy and usefulness of information presented in financial statement, which is essential for capital market participants. The purpose of...

  • Toward More Uniform Conflict Disclosures: The Updated ICMJE Conflict of Interest Reporting Form. Drazen, Jeffrey M.; de Leeuw, Peter W.; Laine, Christine; Mulrow, Cynthia D.; DeAngelis, Catherine D.; Frizelle, Frank A.; Godlee, Fiona; Haug, Charlotte; Hébert, Paul C.; Kotzin, Sheldon; Marusic, Ana; Reyes, Humberto; Rosenberg, Jacob // Annals of Internal Medicine;8/17/2010, Vol. 153 Issue 4, p268 

    The authors talk about the development of an electronic uniform disclosure form by the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE). They express their gratitude to authors, editors and other interested parties who commented on the form and contributed on its implementation. They...

  • Discussion of 'Is fair value accounting information relevant and reliable? Evidence from capital market research'. Deans, Sarah // Accounting & Business Research (Wolters Kluwer UK);2007 Special Issue, p31 

    In this article the author comments on "Is fair value accounting information relevant and reliable? Evidence from capital market research," by Wayne R. Landsmen, an article that appears elsewhere in this edition of the journal. The author raises a number of questions about the conclusions formed...

  • Full disclosure. Angaran, David M. // American Journal of Health-System Pharmacy;6/15/2007, Vol. 64 Issue 12, p1331 

    The article presents the author's full-disclosure form which covers several questions concerning health care professionals' acknowledgement of potential financial conflicts of interest. The form focuses on questions about authorship disclosure, financial disclosure, dual publication, study...

  • Happy New Year—Until You Have to Deal with New Loan Disclosures. McDermott, John // Origination News;Jan2012, Vol. 21 Issue 4, p8 

    The article presents the author's insights on the proposed settlement disclosure form, developed by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau under the Dodd-Frank Act, which requires combining the Truth in Lending disclosure and the HUD-1 Settlement Statement.

  • Less Work, Less Respect: Authors' Perceived Importance of Research Contributions and Their Declared Contributions to Research Articles. Ivaniš, Ana; Hren, Darko; Marušić, Matko; Marusšić, Ana // PLoS ONE;2011, Vol. 6 Issue 6, p1 

    Background: Attitudes towards authorship are connected with authors' research experience and with knowledge of authorship criteria of International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE). The objective of this study was to assess association between authors' perceived importance of...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of VIRGINIA BEACH PUBLIC LIBRARY AND SYSTEM

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics