Extended Resection for Thyroid Disease has Less Operative Morbidity than Limited Resection

Seiler, Christian; Vorburger, Stephan; Bürgi, Ulrich; Candinas, Daniel; Schmid, Stefan
May 2007
World Journal of Surgery;May2007, Vol. 31 Issue 5, p1005
Academic Journal
Theodor Kocher, surgeon and Nobel laureate, has influenced thyroid surgery all over the world: his treatment for multinodular goiter—subtotal thyroidectomy—has been the “Gold Standard” for more than a century. However, based on a new understanding of molecular growth mechanisms in goitrogenesis, we set out to evaluate if a more extended resection yields better results. Four thousand three hundred and ninety-four thyroid gland operations with 5,785 “nerves at risk” were prospectively analyzed between 1972 and 2002. From 1972 to 1990, the limited Kocher resections were performed, and from 1991 to 2002 a more radical resection involving at least a hemithyroidectomy was performed. The incidence of postoperative nerve palsy was 3.6%; in the first study period and 0.9%; in the second ( P < 0.001, Fisher’s exact). Postoperative hypoparathyroidism decreased from 3.2%; in the first period to 0.64%; in the second ( P < 0.01). The rate of reoperation for recurrent disease was 11.1%; from 1972 to 1990 and 8.5%; from 1991 to 2002 ( P < 0.01). Extended resection for multinodular goiter not only significantly reduced morbidity, but also decreased the incidence of operations for recurrent disease. Our findings in a large cohort corroborate the suggestions that Kocher’s approach should be replaced by a more radical resection, which actually was his original intention more than 130 years ago.


Related Articles

  • Changes in the choice of thyroidectomy for benign thyroid disease. Citgez, Bulent; Uludag, Mehmet; Yetkin, Gurkan; Yener, Faruk; Akgun, Ismail; Isgor, Adnan // Surgery Today;Jun2013, Vol. 43 Issue 6, p625 

    Purposes: There is an increasing trend towards performing more radical resections instead of a subtotal resection for benign thyroid disease. The aim of this study was to examine the effect of this change in practice on the surgical treatment of bilateral thyroid diseases in this unit. Methods:...

  • State of the art: surgery for endemic goiter-a plea for individualizing the extent of resection instead of heading for routine total thyroidectomy. Dralle, Henning; Lorenz, Kerstin; Machens, Andreas // Langenbeck's Archives of Surgery;Dec2011, Vol. 396 Issue 8, p1137 

    Background: During the past 150 years of nodular goiter surgery, the pendulum has been swinging from limited to more extensive forms of thyroidectomy and all the way back reflecting the challenges of striking a balance between surgical morbidity and disease recurrence. Purpose: This article...

  • Nüks nodüler guatr vakalarında tiroidektomi sonrası hipoparatiroidi: Klinik deneyimlerimiz. Öztürk, Gürkan; Akçay, Müide Nuran; Akçay, Güngör; Başoğlu, Mahmut; Özoğul, Bünyamin; Atamanalp, Selçuk; Aydınlı, Bülent // Journal of Dialog in Endocrinology / Endokrinolide Diyalog Dergi;Dec2011, Vol. 8 Issue 4, p152 

    Aim: There are reports indicating that a second operation after thyroidectomy because of recurrence augments the risk of hypoparathyroidism and recurrent nerve paralysis. With this study, we aimed to investigate the frequency of hypoparathyroidism following total thyroidectomy of recurrent...

  • Reoperative surgery for thyroid disease. Lefevre, Jérémie; Tresallet, Christophe; Leenhardt, Laurence; Jublanc, Christelle; Chigot, Jean-Paul; Menegaux, Fabrice // Langenbeck's Archives of Surgery;Nov2007, Vol. 392 Issue 6, p685 

    Reoperative surgery for thyroid disease is rare. However, it is sometimes indicated for nodular recurrence after partial surgery for initially benign thyroid disease or for a completion total thyroidectomy when a final diagnosis of well-differentiated thyroid cancer (WDTC) is confirmed on a...

  • Benign nodüler guatrda cerrahi yaklaşım; 72 olgunun analizi. Yorgancilar, Ediz // Dicle Medical Journal / Dicle Tip Dergisi;2009, Vol. 36 Issue 1, p35 

    Surgical resection is usually prefered for the treatment of benign nodular goiter. But the extention of thyroidectomy in the surgical management of benign nodular goiter still remains controversial. Seventytwo patients underwent thyroid surgery between April 2002- July2007 in Kiziltepe State...

  • Evidence-Based Surgical Management of Substernal Goiter. White, Matthew L.; Doherty, Gerard M.; Gauger, Paul G. // World Journal of Surgery;Jul2008, Vol. 32 Issue 7, p1285 

    A number of reports have been published concerning the surgical treatment of substernal goiters; however, there is yet to be a comprehensive review of this body of literature using evidence-based methodology. This article is a systematic review of the literature using evidence-based criteria and...

  • The Factors Related with Postoperative Complications in Benign Nodular Thyroid Surgery. Simsek Celik, Aysun; Erdem, Hasan; Guzey, Deniz; Celebi, Fatih; Celik, Atilla; Birol, Selim; Kaplan, Rafet // Indian Journal of Surgery;Jan2011, Vol. 73 Issue 1, p32 

    Thyroid gland is an important endocrine organ because of its functions. Although the morbidity and mortality of thyroid surgery have decreased markedly, serious complications may still occur. The aim of this retrospective study was to identify the factors influencing the complications in benign...

  • Management of occult papillary thyroid cancer found incidentally during surgery for benign disease. Solares, C. A. // Journal of Postgraduate Medicine;Jan-Mar2007, Vol. 53 Issue 1, p6 

    The article reflects on total thyroidectomy as the procedure of choice in treating thyroid carcinoma. The author stresses that this procedure may have serious complications. He emphasizes that it is appropriate to individualize which patients may require such procedure based on risk factors for...

  • Risks of complication following thyroidectomy. Burge, Mark R.; Zeise, Tanja-Maria; Johnsen, Michael W.; Conway, Martin J.; Qualls, Clifford R.; Burge; Burge, M R; Zeise, T M; Johnsen, M W; Conway, M J; Qualls, C R // JGIM: Journal of General Internal Medicine;Jan1998, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p24 

    Objective: Because hypoparathyroidism is a serious complication of thyroidectomy, we attempted to elucidate factors determining the risk of this postoperative outcome.Setting: Four tertiary care hospitals in Albuquerque, New Mexico.Patients: A retrospective...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics