Comparing public and private sector decision-making practices

Nutt, P. C.
January 2006
Journal of Public Administration Research & Theory;1/2/2006, Vol. 16 Issue 2, p289
Academic Journal
Public and private sector decision making is studied with an experiment. The study compares decision making in a tax-supported general purpose governmental agency with that done by a business firm selling to a market, using a simulation to capture differences in the preferences and practices of mid-level managers working in the two sectors. The simulation calls for participating managers to assess the risk and prospect of adopting budgets tailored to match each sector. A cognitive culture that stresses analysis, speculation, bargaining, or networking is employed to fashion a budget appropriate for a public and a private sector organization, each with a controversial and a noncontroversial budget amount. The literature on public/private differences was consulted to make predictions, suggesting that public sector managers would favor bargaining and networking and private sector managers would favor analysis and speculation. The cognitive style literature suggests that managers favor budgets constructed with an approach that is consistent with their preferred cognitive style and see less risk in the choice, except in a public setting where risk would be unaffected. The study finds that private sector managers are more apt to support budget decisions made with analysis and less likely to support them when bargaining is applied. Public sector managers are less likely to support budget decisions backed by analysis and more likely to support those that are derived from bargaining with agency people.


Related Articles

  • Advances and Challenges for Adoption of Activity Based Costing (ABC) by Public Sector: A Comparative Study of Brazil, Colombia, Uruguay and United States. Carmo, Luís Paulo F.; Padovani, Fernando // International Business Research;Feb2012, Vol. 5 Issue 2, p150 

    This article aims to evaluate the advances and challenges to the adoption of the activity based costing system (ABC) by the public sector of countries like Colombia, Uruguay and Brazil, always keeping a comparative perspective with the historical experience of the United States. Considering the...

  • Public Real Estate Management -- Adapting Corporate Practice to the Public Sector: The Experience in Cleveland, Ohio. Simons, Robert A. // Journal of Real Estate Research;Fall93, Vol. 8 Issue 4, p639 

    Abstract. This paper addresses the issue of public real estate management, focusing on the potential to adapt corporate management practice to the public sector. The research begins with a review of the survey literature on real estate management practice and decisionmaking among American...

  • 'Going private': a qualitative comparison of medical specialists' job satisfaction in the public and private sectors of South Africa. Ashmore, John // Human Resources for Health;2013, Vol. 11 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: There is a highly inequitable distribution of health workers between public and private sectors in South Africa, partly due to within-country migration trends. This article elaborates what South African medical specialists find satisfying about working in the public and private...

  • ALTERNATIVES IN PUBLIC SECTOR Factfinding with binding recommendations. Haber, Herbert L.; Lubersky, William F.; Guinan, Matthew; Shanker, Albert L.; Wollett, Donald H. // Monthly Labor Review;Sep73, Vol. 96 Issue 9, p43 

    Focuses on search for alternatives to the strike in the public sector. Viability of a factfinding or advisory arbitration; Variations in third-party decisionmaking; Segregation of public sector from private sector employees in defining collective bargaining rights.

  • Estudio de la imagen corporativa de las residencias de mayores en el sector solidario. Tous Zamora, Dolores; Bermúdez González, Guillermo // CIRIEC - España, Revista de Economía Pública, Social y Cooper;2011, Issue 71, p175 

    Organizational culture and corporate image are the crucial two sides of the coin for the reputation of any organization. In-depth studies have been made of the concept of image and identity in different areas of the economy and society but the literature contains practically no research on...

  • Public-private partnerships and social performance in the forest industry. Kokko, Suvi; Lukkarinen, Jonathan; Mark-Herbert, Cecilia // Social Business;Spring2014, Vol. 4 Issue 1, p15 

    Purpose The objective of this paper is to describe the motives, conditions and perceived outcomes of public-private partnerships as they are currently practiced in the forest industry in Sweden. Design A comparative case study of three Swedish forest products companies, operating nationally,...

  • Critical Stages of Decision-Making Process by Commanders of the Czech Republic Defence Department. Štěpánková, Eva; Richter, Jiří // Proceedings of the European Conference on Management, Leadership;2015, p445 

    The article summarizes partial outputs of the research Solving Unstructured Decision-Making Problems in the Department of Defence of the Czech Republic. The research is focused on data acquisition and evaluation in relation to the use of methods of decision making and problem solving within the...

  • Greed, Ethics, and Public Policy. Rivlin, Alice M. // Public Integrity;Fall2003, Vol. 5 Issue 4, p347 

    Assesses the resemblance and differences of leaders in public and private sectors with respect to the nature and causes of temptations to present misleading information. Information on several personality traits common to leaders of both sectors; Complexity of the decision-making process in...

  • Employee Empowerment in Indian Banks: An Empirical Study. Jain, Sheelam; Jain, Ravindra // Journal of Institute of Public Enterprise;Jul-Dec2014, Vol. 37 Issue 3/4, p32 

    The aim of the present study is to assess and compare the level of employee empowerment among managers of public sector, private sector and foreign banks operating in India. Employee empowerment was measured with respect to two dimensions viz., 'participative decision making' and...

  • Study finds public sector workers more pro-socially motivated than their private sector counterparts.  // Biomedical Market Newsletter;9/30/2011, Vol. 21, p816 

    The article presents a comparative study that compares the motivation level of public sector workers and private sector employees.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics