External validity of randomised controlled trials in asthma: to whom do the results of the trials apply?

Travers, Justin; Marsh, Suzanne; Williams, Mathew; Weatherall, Mark; Caidwell, Brent; Shirtcliffe, Philippa; Aldington, Sarah; Beasley, Richard
March 2007
Thorax;Mar2007, Vol. 62 Issue 3, p219
Academic Journal
Background: Asthma is a heterogeneous disease with a wide range of clinical phenotypes, not all of which may be encompassed in the subjects included in randomised controlled trials (RCTs). This makes it difficult for clinicians to know to what extent the evidence derived from RCTs applies to a given patient. Aim: To calculate the proportion of individuals with asthma who would have been eligible for the major asthma RCTs from the data of a random community survey of respiratory health. Methods: A postal survey was sent to 3500 randomly selected individuals aged 25-75 years. Respondents were invited to complete a detailed respiratory questionnaire and pulmonary function testing. Participants with current asthma were assessed against the eligibility criteria of the 17 major asthma RCTs cited in the Global Initiative for Asthma (GINA) guidelines. Findings: A total of 749 participants completed the full survey, of whom 179 had current asthma. A median 4% of participants with current asthma (range 0-36%) met the eligibility criteria for the included RCTs. A median 6% (range 0-43%) of participants with current asthma on treatment met the eligibility criteria. Interpretation: This study shows that the major asthma RCTs on which the GINA guidelines are based may have limited external validity as they have been performed on highly selected patient populations. Most of the participants with current asthma on treatment in the community would not have been eligible for these RCTs.


Related Articles

  • COMPLICATED BRONCHIAL ASTHMA.  // Cortlandt Forum;06/25/2001, Vol. 14 Issue 6, p83 

    Answers queries on complicated bronchial asthma of patients with restrictive component on pulmonary function testing in Lorain County, Ohio. Causes of the asthma; Determination on the relation between obstructive and restrictive components; Evaluation of lung disease.

  • Registrar: MRCGP Exam update - Asthma management. Newson, Louise // GP: General Practitioner;5/13/2005, p90 

    This article focuses on clinical features of asthma and on associated latest therapeutic developments. Asthma, reportedly, is a multi-faceted disease process with intermittent smooth muscle contraction causing airflow obstruction and underlying endobronchial inflammation. The dose-response curve...

  • Clinical Characteristics of Asthma Combined with COPD Feature. Hea Yon Lee; Ji Young Kang; Hyoung Kyu Yoon; Sook Young Lee; Soon Suk Kwon; Young Kyoon Kim; Chin Kook Rhee // Yonsei Medical Journal;Jul2014, Vol. 55 Issue 4, p980 

    Purpose: In clinical practice, some patients with asthma show incompletely reversible airflow obstruction, resembling chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). The aim of this study was to analyze this overlap phenotype of asthma with COPD feature. Materials and Methods: A total of 256...

  • Genetic association between human chitinases and lung function in COPD. Aminuddin, F.; Akhabir, L.; Stefanowicz, D.; ParĂ©, P.; Connett, J.; Anthonisen, N.; Fahy, J.; Seibold, M.; Burchard, E.; Eng, C.; Gulsvik, A.; Bakke, P.; Cho, M.; Litonjua, A.; Lomas, D.; Anderson, W.; Beaty, T.; Crapo, J.; Silverman, E.; Sandford, A. // Human Genetics;Jul2012, Vol. 131 Issue 7, p1105 

    Two primary chitinases have been identified in humans-acid mammalian chitinase (AMCase) and chitotriosidase (CHIT1). Mammalian chitinases have been observed to affect the host's immune response. The aim of this study was to test for association between genetic variation in the chitinases and...

  • ALLERGEN EXPOSURE AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF ASTHMA. Sporik, R.; Platts-Mills, T. A. E. // Thorax;Sep2001 Supp, Vol. 56, pii58 

    Background: In a prospective birth cohort study, we assessed the relevance of mite and cat allergen exposure for the development of childhood asthma up to age 7 years. Methods: Of 1314 newborn infants enrolled in five German cities in 1990, follow-up data at age 7 years were available for 939...

  • Accuracy of asthma and COPD diagnosis in Australian general practice: a mixed methods study. Abramson, Michael J.; Schattner, Rosa L.; Sulaiman, Nabil D.; Del Colle, Eleonora A.; Aroni, Rosalie; Thien, Francis // Primary Care Respiratory Journal;Jun2012, Vol. 21 Issue 2, p167 

    Background: Spirometry is the 'gold standard' for diagnosing asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) but is rarely used in general practice. Aims: To compare doctor diagnoses with patient reports/spirometry and to determine doctors' perceptions of spirometry. Methods: Patients...

  • Prevalence of Exercise Induced Asthma in Female School Students. Marefati, Hamid; Nikbine, Helimeh; Boskabady, Mohammad Hossein // Iranian Journal of Allergy, Asthma & Immunology;2011, Vol. 10 Issue 4, p273 

    The prevalence of exercise induced asthma (EIA) in Iran is not known. In the present study the prevalence of EIA among female students of guidance school in the city of Mashhad was evaluated. A total of 1690 female students aged 12-14 years in ten randomly selected schools in north east of Iran...

  • Impulse oscillometry: an alternative modality to the conventional pulmonary function test to categorise obstructive pulmonary disorders. Al-Mutairi, S.; Sharma, P.; Al-Alawi, A.; Al-Deen, J. // Clinical & Experimental Medicine;Jun2007, Vol. 7 Issue 2, p56 

    Impulse oscillometry (IOS) was introduced as an alternative modality to the conventional pulmonary function test (cPFT) to test lung mechanics. The objective of this study is to assess the use of IOS as an alternative, or in conjunction with cPFT, to categorise an obstructive respiratory...

  • Prevalence of untreated asthma in a population sample of 6000 older adults in Bristol, UK. Dow, L.; Fowler, L.; Phelps, L.; Waters, K.; Coggon, D.; Kinmonth, A. L.; Holgate, S. T. // Thorax;Jun2001, Vol. 56 Issue 6, p472 

    Background-A study was undertaken to estimate the prevalence of untreated asthma in older adults. Methods-A cross sectional population based survey of 6000 men and women aged 65 years and over was performed in 21 general practices in north Bristol, south west England. The main outcome measure...


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics