Effects of Cobalt-60 Exposure on Health of Taiwan Residents Suggest New Approach Needed in Radiation Protection

Chen, W. L.; Luan, Y. C.; Shieh, M. C.; Chen, S. T.; Kung, H. T.; Soong, K. L.; Yeh, Y. C.; Chou, T. S.; Mong, S. H.; Wu, J. T.; Sun, C. P.; Deng, W. P.; Wu, M. F.; Shen, M. L.
January 2007
Dose-Response;2007, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p63
Academic Journal
The conventional approach for radiation protection is based on the ICRP's linear, no threshold (LNT) model of radiation carcinogenesis, which implies that ionizing radiation is always harmful, no matter how small the dose. But a different approach can be derived from the observed health effects of the serendipitous contamination of 1700 apartments in Taiwan with cobalt-60 (T1/2 = 5.3 y). This experience indicates that chronic exposure of the whole body to low-dose-rate radiation, even accumulated to a high annual dose, may be beneficial to human health. Approximately 10,000 people occupied these buildings and received an average radiation dose of 0.4 Sv, unknowingly, during a 9-20 year period. They did not suffer a higher incidence of cancer mortality, as the LNT theory would predict. On the contrary, the incidence of cancer deaths in this population was greatly reduced-to about 3 per cent of the incidence of spontaneous cancer death in the general Taiwan public. In addition, the incidence of congenital malformations was also reduced-to about 7 per cent of the incidence in the general public. These observations appear to be compatible with the radiation hormesis model. Information about this Taiwan experience should be communicated to the public worldwide to help allay its fear of radiation and create a positive impression about important radiation applications. Expenditures of many billions of dollars in nuclear reactor operation could be saved and expansion of nuclear electricity generation could be facilitated. In addition, this knowledge would encourage further investigation and implementation of very important applications of total-body, low-dose irradiation to treat and cure many illnesses, including cancer. The findings of this study are such a departure from expectations, based on ICRP criteria, that we believe that they ought to be carefully reviewed by other, independent organizations and that population data not available to the authors be provided, so that a fully qualified epidemiologically-valid analysis can be made. Many of the confounding factors that limit other studies used to date, such as the A-bomb survivors, the Mayak workers and the Chernobyl evacuees, are not present in this population exposure. It should be one of the most important events on which to base radiation protection standards.


Related Articles

  • Understanding and characterisation of the risks to human health from exposure to low levels of radiation. Goodhead, Dudley T. // Radiation Protection Dosimetry;Dec2009, Vol. 137 Issue 1/2, p109 

    Exposure to ionising radiation can lead to a wide variety of health effects. Cancer is judged to be the main risk from radiation at low doses and low dose rates, and controlling this risk has been the main factor in developing radiation protection practice. Conventional paradigms of radiobiology...

  • Uncomfortable issues in radiation protection posed by low-dose radiobiology. Mothersill, Carmel; Seymour, Colin // Radiation & Environmental Biophysics;Aug2013, Vol. 52 Issue 3, p293 

    This paper aims to stimulate discussion about the relevance for radiation protection of recent findings in low-dose radiobiology. Issues are raised which suggest that low-dose effects are much more complex than has been previously assumed. These include genomic instability, bystander effects,...

  • Linear, no threshold response at low doses of ionizing radiation: ideology, prejudice and science. Kesavan, P. C. // Current Science (00113891);7/10/2014, Vol. 107 Issue 1, p46 

    The linear, no threshold (LNT) response model assumes that there is no threshold dose for the radiation-induced genetic effects (heritable mutations and cancer), and it forms the current basis for radiation protection standards for radiation workers and the general public. The LNT model is,...

  • MDCT Causes Few Secondary Cancers in Elders.  // Radiology Today;May2012, Vol. 13 Issue 6, p33 

    The article reports a study which revealed that secondary cancer risk from multidetector computed tomography (CT) scans (MDCT) is low among older adults, although concerns are raised on cancer caused by CT-induced radiation. It discusses a study by Aabed Meer, which showed that the risk of...

  • Computer-assisted formulas predicting cancer mortality risk after exposure to acute low dose ionizing radiation in humans. Sung Jang Chung // Journal of Biomedical Science & Engineering;Apr2012, Vol. 5 Issue 4, p176 

    A clear relationship between dose of radiation and mortality in humans is still not known because of lack of human data that would enable to determine human tolerance in total body irradiation. Human data for analysis have been primarily from radiation accidents, radiotherapy and the atomic bomb...

  • Desmantelamiento del irradiador autoblindado Gammacell 500. Llanes Rodríguez, Marisleidys; Rodríguez Perdomo, Yanet; Benítez Navarro, Juan Carlos; Salgado Mojena, Mercedes; Fraga Acosta, Daniel; Soto Álvarez, Evelio; Pérez Reyes, Yolanda; Soler Roger, Dulce María; Abreu Méndez, Yuliel // Nucleus;2011, Issue 50, p36 

    The National Center for Animal and Plant Health used a Gammacell 500 irradiator, with twelve cobalt 60 sealed sources, for sterilization and decontamination of medical devices, pharmaceuticals and several raw materials. As the equipmenty had been in operation for 25 years, the decision was taken...

  • Removal of Alcyon II, CGR, MeV 60Co Teletherapy Head and Evaluation of Exposure Dose. Selim, Yasser Tawflk; Lasheen, Yasser Fouad; Hassan, Mahmoud Ali; Zakla, Tarik Mohamed El // Journal of Environmental Protection;Dec2013, Vol. 4 Issue 12, p1435 

    Teletherapy units containing 60Co source are used in Egypt and worldwide for treatment of cancer diseases. One of the widely used in Egypt is Alcyon CGR MeV. Different radiotherapy facilities need to unload this 60Co unit after being disused. The head containing the source was removed and put...

  • FCC proposes new RF radiation limits. Scully, Sean // Broadcasting & Cable;4/19/93, Vol. 123 Issue 16, p68 

    Focuses on the proposed radio-frequency radiation exposure limits set by the Federal Communications Commission. 1992 revision of exposure standards by the American National Standards Institute. Controlled environments, uncontrolled environments and induced currents; Estimate of extent of effect...

  • More news from Exeter. Tobias, Jeffrey // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);12/17/88, Vol. 297 Issue 6663, p1566 

    Reports the management of radiotherapy for radiation accidents in Exeter, England. Evaluation of the calibration error; Effectivity of high medical dosages; Examination of the claims settlement.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics