Spiffed-Up Channels: The Role of Spiffs in Hierarchical Selling Organizations

Caldieraro, Fabio; Coughlan, Anne T.
January 2007
Marketing Science;Jan/Feb2007, Vol. 26 Issue 1, p31
Academic Journal
We study a channel relationship in which manufacturer(s) use independent sales representatives (rep firms), which employ salespeople to do the actual selling. We show that commission-only payments by manufacturers to rep firms lead to suboptimal outcomes for the manufacturer relative to those obtained under a vertically integrated channel. From the manufacturer's standpoint, these inefficiencies can be ameliorated through the use of sales incentives given to the rep firm's salespeople directly by the manufacturer (called "spiffs"). In a monopolistic environment, spiffs are shown to improve the manufacturer's profits in the face of contractual restrictions on the channel members' ability to set separate commission rates by product. For certain types of restrictions, spiffs may generate manufacturer outcomes close to the fully coordinated ones achieved under vertical integration even when compensating the rep firm through commission-only contracts. In a competitive environment, spiffs are shown to be used by a powerful manufacturer that shares a rep firm's sales efforts with the product of a weaker manufacturer (i.e., in the case of "common agency"). In this case, spiffs are used as a strategy to deter the weaker manufacturer from challenging the stronger manufacturer for the salesforce's valuable selling effort.


Related Articles

  • Professional Service Representation. Test, Alan // American Salesman;Jan2007, Vol. 52 Issue 1, p23 

    The article discusses the competitive advantages of professional service representatives or rep firms. Unlike regular sales employees, rep firms are compensated based solely on their sales output. A reputable rep firm should be able to demonstrate market expertise on the product that it...

  • Quota-based compensation plans for multiterritory heterogenous salesforces. Raju, Jagmohan S.; Srinivasan, V. // Management Science;Oct96, Vol. 42 Issue 10, p1454 

    We compare quota-based salesforce compensation plans with the BLSS plan, i.e., the optimal curvilinear agency-theory-based compensation plans proposed in Basu, Lai, Srini-vasan and Staelin (1985). A quota plan pays a fixed salary which is supplemented by commission income that is a prespecified...

  • Utilizing CRM Systems in Sales Management Classes. Erffmeyer, Robert C.; Honeycutt, Earl D.; Loe, Terry; Tanner Jr., John F. // Society for Marketing Advances Proceedings;2008, p281 

    Companies with professional salespeople as their primary go-to-market channel have moved from sales force automation technology to fully-featured customer relationship management (CRM) software. But teaching CRM and sales management has many challenges. In this interactive session, we explore...

  • Consequences of Sales Management's Behavior- and Compensation-Based Control Strategies in Developing Countries. Piercy, Nigel F.; Low, George S.; Cravens, David W. // Journal of International Marketing;2004, Vol. 12 Issue 3, p30 

    The authors examine the consequences of sales management's behavior- and compensation-based control on important salesperson and organizational consequences from the sales manager's perspective. The few existing studies on this topic have been conducted in developed countries. The authors...

  • Create A Sales Strategy That Will Be Your Ticket To Success.  // Sales Leader;11/6/2006, Vol. 12 Issue 18, p1 

    The article offers a number of tips for creating a sales strategy that will be lead to success. Developing a sales strategy is the best way to maintain an organized plan. There are several points a salesperson should first consider when coming up with a sales strategy. Some of these points are:...

  • SELF-EFFICACY, COMPETITIVENESS, AND EFFORT AS ANTECEDENTS OF SALESPERSON PERFORMANCE. Krishnan, Balaji C.; Netemeyer, Richard G.; Boles, James S. // Journal of Personal Selling & Sales Management;Fall2002, Vol. 22 Issue 4, p285 

    This paper posits and tests a model of the individual characteristics of self-efficacy, competitiveness, and effort as potential antecedents of salesperson performance. Based on two studies in different selling contexts, it is observed that whereas effort mediates the relationship between...

  • Dancing with the competition? Watch it. Gitomer, Jeffrey // Inside Tucson Business;12/29/2003, Vol. 13 Issue 25, p12 

    Presents tips for salespeople on how to deal with the competition. Inclusion of the identification of major customers; Importance of learning a competitor's areas of strength and weakness; Recommendations regarding ways to deal with competition on a sales call.

  • The Influence of Up line Support on Change Success in Malaysian Health Care Products Direct Selling Industry. Md Isa, Filzah; Cheng Wei Hin; Mohd Yunus, Jasmani // International Journal of Business & Management Science;Jul2012, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p51 

    The main purpose of this study is to explore the relationship between up line support and both change success proxies namely sales performance and job satisfaction, among salespersons in direct selling industry of Malaysia. Six hundred ninety structured questionnaires were distributed to...

  • How to Achieve the Status of Consultant. Gitomer, Jeffrey // Business News New Jersey;05/24/99, Vol. 12 Issue 21, p16 

    Points out the difference between a sales representative and a person with a consultative approach to selling. Consultant's willingness to forego short-term gains to achieve greater long-term benefit to himself and the customer he serves; Ways by which a consultant gains and builds credibility;...


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics