Clean Agent System Utilizing FM-200® and Automatic Sprinkler System

Eric Forssell; Mark Robin; Steven Ginn; Lance Harry
March 2007
Fire Technology;Mar2007, Vol. 43 Issue 1, p3
Academic Journal
Abstract??Data processing and telecommunication (telco) facilities are commonly protected against fire with a clean agent system, an automatic sprinkler system, or with both a clean agent and an automatic sprinkler system. The degree of protection provided by these systems is vastly different, as is the cost incurred in employing these systems.Comparison testing of a clean agent system utilizing FM-200? (HFC-227ea) and an automatic sprinkler system was performed in order to illustrate the differences in the protection provided by gaseous clean agent systems and automatic sprinkler systems. The tests were performed in a simulated data processing/telecommunications facility, and examined the performance of the suppression systems on a plastics fire located inside a metal electronic equipment cabinet.In the clean agent system test, the fire was detected while it was small in size and was extinguished 17?sec after system actuation. Damage to the simulated facility and its contents was limited solely to the dislodging of several ceiling tiles near the clean agent nozzle, and a slight scorching of the cabinet containing the fuel array. The facility could be re-occupied and all systems within the facility, other than those damaged inside the cabinet involved in the fire, would be functional immediately following the extinguishment of the fire. Cleanup of the facility would not be required prior to its use following the fire event, as no residues were produced during extinguishment.Under the identical fire scenario, the automatic sprinkler system actuated approximately three minutes later than the clean agent system, and the fire was not extinguished by sprinkler system. The sprinkler system did achieve its primary objective of containing the fire to the room of origin and managing the temperatures at the ceiling to prevent structural damage and/or collapse, as the suspended ceiling remained intact, and the fire did not spread beyond the cabinet that contained the fuel array. Damage to the simulated facility was much more extensive than that resulting from the clean agent system test. All ceiling tiles were discolored and the tiles around the sprinkler heads that activated were warped and sagging. The walls were discolored throughout the entire simulated facility and a dark ring of varying intensity and width was observed just below the level of the suspended ceiling. Paper items located within the simulated facility suffered extensive water damage, and the simulated facility floor was covered in water containing large amounts of soot. Immediate reoccupation of the facility and resumption of business would be impossible under these circumstances, as the fire and smoke damage experienced by the facility and its contents would require the replacement of the facility walls, ceiling, and floor, and would likely require the replacement of water-damaged electronic equipment.The test results are discussed in detail as are the implications of the results in the design of fire protection systems for data processing and telecommunication type facilities.


Related Articles

  • Water Mist Explored. Pepi, Jerome S. // Buildings;Oct99, Vol. 93 Issue 10, p42 

    Focuses on water mist systems. Fire suppression performance demonstrated by water mist nozzles; How water mist systems are classified; Types of nozzles.

  • EXTINGUISHING SYSTEMS.  // Fire Safety Engineering;Dec2008/Jan2009, Vol. 15 Issue 10, p35 

    The article focuses on automatic extinguishing and suppression systems. In 2008, the Fire Industry Association of Great Britain published Europe's first code and practice in designing and installing fire extinguishing systems. The article features a sprinkler system that sprays a fine...

  • The Benefits of CPVC Fire-Sprinkler Systems. Kuwatch, Matthew // Buildings;May2008, Vol. 102 Issue 5, p42 

    This article discusses the benefits of chlorinated polyvinyl chloride (CPVC) fire-sprinkler systems. CPVC pipe and fittings have a long, low-maintenance service life that typically exceeds metallic systems. They are not combustible and will not contribute to flashover. Additionally, CPVC will...

  • Obstructions to sprinkler discharge pattern development. Kaiser, Daniel // Minnesota Fire Chief;Jul/Aug2009, Vol. 45 Issue 6, p32 

    The article discusses the obstructions that can affect the sprinkler discharge spray patterns. According to the author, it is important to consider the basic performance objectives and to categorize obstructions when evaluating the impact of obstructions on sprinkler discharge development. The...

  • Fire-Sprinkler Plans that Work. Piccolo, Richard A. // Buildings;Aug2007, Vol. 101 Issue 8, p28 

    The article presents the common mistakes that could make a sprinkler plan rejected. These include improper design classification or labeling, missing or inaccurate water-flow test data, installation of the wrong sprinklers, inaccuracy of hydraulic calculations and missing design documents. It...

  • Specifying fire suppression agents. Prymak, Tom // Consulting-Specifying Engineer;May2009, Vol. 45 Issue 5, p28 

    The article provides an overview on the most efficient fire suppression agents. It states that fire sprinklers can be use as a replacement in providing continued fire protection while the primary system is out of service. A fire suppression technology eliminates the need for automatic sprinkler...

  • Tragedy again pushes sprinkler retrofits. Mader, Robert P. // Contractor Magazine;Mar2003, Vol. 50 Issue 3, p1 

    Fire sprinkler industry officials are reluctant to take advantage of the fire break-out tragedy which took place on Feb. 20, 2003 at The Station nightclub to promote sprinklers. "If there were sprinklers in this building, we would not be here right now" were the comments of fire chiefs at the...

  • How dirty is your data? Wieland, Ken // Telecommunications - International Edition;Sep2006, Vol. 40 Issue 9, p24 

    The article discusses the prevalence of inaccurate network inventories and defective customer identification information, some of the biggest and costly problems confronting telecommunication companies. It is inferred that a call center agent or the network engineer could help operators waste...

  • Tomorrow's OSS is here today. Means, Ed // Telephony;4/24/95, Vol. 228 Issue 17, p84 

    Discusses the cable industry's transaction management and billing systems that could be adopted by telephone companies for their operations support systems (OSSs). Description of CableData's Intelecable subscriber and transaction management and billing system; Use of open and relational...


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics