Gene Technology and its Citizen-Subjects

Robins, Rosemary
May 2006
Acta Botanica Mexicana;2006, p45
Academic Journal
Within the recombinant DNA debate, a formative categorisation of gene technology has occurred by which matters of concern must be separated into either those that belong to nature or those that belong to society. With reference to the work of Ulrich Beck and Bruno Latour, I trace these separations through the lives of two objects of gene technology: a genetically modified bacterium and genetically modified canola. I argue that the categories, institutions and regulatory systems of gene technology that emerge along with these objects, are generative of a citizen-subject who, in order to participate in decision-making processes, must be able to dissect their concerns and allocate them appropriately either to nature or to society but not to both. Citizens do not neatly separate their concerns in this way and for many citizens the citizen-subject generated by gene technology is an alienating one. As a consequence, citizens are encouraged into a sub-politics to which governments must respond. This process of separations, citizen-subject formation and alienation is generative of a politics that undermines the legitimacy of gene technology and its institutions.


Related Articles

  • Diálogos entre Bruno Latour e Ulrich Beck: Convergências e divergências. Rotondaro, Tatiana Gomes // Civitas - Revista de Ciências Sociais;jan-abr2012, Vol. 12 Issue 1, p145 

    This paper aims to expose and reflect on the debate between remarkable social scientists of our time: Ulrich Beck and Bruno Latour. However, I still suggest that this debate goes beyond the level of their convergences and divergences in providing indicative of some trends in the humanities. One...

  • Disability and the Open City. Gleeson, Brendan // Urban Studies (Routledge);Feb2001, Vol. 38 Issue 2, p251 

    For at least three decades, the issue of physical accessibility has been a focus of analysis amongst some spatial scientists, including geographers, urban planners and architects. Whilst such 'conventional' access studies have assumed an important role as policy evaluation/ critique, their...

  • genetic engineering, dangers for the Third World. Mason, Mike // Globalization & Development: A Glossary;2005, p57 

    An encyclopedia entry for "genetic engineering, dangers for the Third World" is presented. According to the article, much of the agricultural economy of Third World countries depends on growing specialty commodities once found only in tropical species. With recombinant DNA, these specialty...

  • The Use of Format Adaptation in Danish Public Service Programming. Jensen, Pia Majbritt // Critical Studies in Television;Summer2013, Vol. 8 Issue 2, p85 

    The article investigates Danish public service broadcasters' use of format adaptations over a twelve-year period in order to examine claims that formats constitute a potential threat to public service broadcasting and the national Danish television industry and culture. The article's findings,...

  • I confini dell'uguaglianza. Riconoscimento, inclusione, esclusione. Scuccimarra, Luca // Scienza & Politica;2014, Vol. 26 Issue 51, p209 

    According to the sociologist Ulrich Beck, the contemporary debate on social inequalities is an exemplary case study of the phenomenon of systematic distortion of «scientific perspective of the observer» which he proposed to define as methodological nationalism. In this horizon of...

  • ULRICH BECK.  // Management Today;Jun2000, p50 

    Provides information on Ulrich Beck, professor of sociology at the University of Munich in Germany and Visiting Professor at the London School of Economics in England. Authorship of bestselling book `Risk Society,' `The Reinvention of Politics' and `Democracy Without Enemies'; Beck's offer of...

  • Juridicidade do Dano Ambiental: gestão da zona costeira e aspectos da exploração do pré-sal pelo Brasil. Morato Leite, José Rubens; Alves da Silva, Leonio José // Revista Seqüência;dez2012, Vol. 33 Issue 65, p305 

    This text aims to comment on the leading of the Brazilian process of oil exploration in the region of Subsalt and the application of risk society theory, developed by Ulrich Beck in 1986 in Germany, addressing the globalization of ecological problems, the environmental crisis, legalizes of...

  • Risk: now you see it, now you don't. Bonfiglioli, Catriona // Chemistry in Australia;May2011, Vol. 78 Issue 4, p39 

    The article focuses on impacts of risks to society as they are used and published by journalists. Author Ulrich Beck stated that society is sensitized to risk and that people are sensitized to risk imposed by others for profit. Beck indicated that some risks are obvious like riding the airplane,...

  • Social perception of Risk and Threat of “Cyber Warefare” in the German speaking blogosphere. Höpker, Henrike Francesca // Politikon;Dec2015, Vol. 28, p27 

    This paper presents some selected findings from a previous study. It aimed at establishing an overview of the discourse on “cyberwar” within the German speaking blogosphere. A profound basis could be established collecting data, to be analyzed with the Sociology of Knowledge Approach...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics