The Cost-Effectiveness of CT Colonography in Screening for Colorectal Neoplasia

Vijan, Sandeep; Inku Hwang; Inadomi, John; Wong, Roy K. H.; Choi, J. Richard; Napierkowski, John; Koff, Jonathan M.; Pickhardt, Perry J.
February 2007
American Journal of Gastroenterology;Feb2007, Vol. 102 Issue 2, p380
Academic Journal
BACKGROUND: We examined the cost-effectiveness of 2- and 3-dimensional computerized tomography (CT) colonography as a screening test for colorectal neoplasia. METHODS: We created a Markov model of the natural history of colorectal cancer. Effectiveness of screening was based upon the diagnostic accuracy of tests in detecting polyps and cancer. RESULTS: CT colonography every 5 or 10 yr was effective and cost-effective relative to no screening. Optical colonoscopy dominates 2-dimensional CT colonography done every 5 or 10 yr. Optical colonoscopy is weakly dominant over 3-dimensional CT colonography done every 10 yr. 3-D CT colonography done every 5 yr is more effective than optical colonoscopy every 10 yr, but costs an incremental $156,000 per life-year gained. Sensitivity analyses show that test costs, accuracy, and adherence are critical determinants of incremental cost-effectiveness. 3-D CT colonography every 5 yr is a dominant strategy if optical colonoscopy costs 1.6 times more than CT colonography. However, optical colonoscopy is a dominant strategy if the sensitivity of CT colonography for 1 cm adenomas is 83% or lower. CONCLUSIONS: CT colonography is an effective screening test for colorectal neoplasia. However, it is more expensive and generally less effective than optical colonoscopy. CT colonography can be reasonably cost-effective when the diagnostic accuracy of CT colonography is high, as with primary 3-dimensional technology, and if costs are about 60% of those of optical colonoscopy. Overall, CT colonography technology will need to improve its accuracy and reliability to be a cost-effective screening option.


Related Articles

  • Management of Portuguese Patients with Hyperplastic Polyposis and Screening of At-Risk First-Degree Relatives: A Contribution for Future Guidelines Based on a Clinical Study. Lage, P.; Cravo, M.; Sousa, R.; Chaves, P.; Salazar, M.; Fonseca, R.; Claro, I.; Suspiro, A.; Rodrigues, P.; Raposo, H.; Fidalgo, P.; Nobre-Leitão, C. // American Journal of Gastroenterology;Sep2004, Vol. 99 Issue 9, p1779 

    BACKGROUND: Hyperplastic polyposis (HP) is a rare condition characterized by the presence of multiple hyperplastic polyps in the colon, which has been associated to an increased risk of colorectal cancer (CRC). Guidelines for management of this disease remain, so far, undefined.AIMS: To...

  • Colonic perforation during screening CT colonography using automated CO2 insufflation in an asymptomatic adult. Bassett, John T.; Liotta, Robert A.; Barlow, Duncan; Dong Lee; Jensen, Donald; Lee, Dong // Abdominal Imaging;Sep/Oct2008, Vol. 33 Issue 5, p598 

    CT colonography has become a potential alternative technique to optical colonoscopy for the detection of colorectal polyps and cancer. While considered safer than optical colonoscopy, CT colonography is not without risk. We report a case of colonic perforation during CT colonography using...

  • A Comparison of Virtual and Conventional Colonoscopy for the Detection of Colorectal Polyps. Fenlon, Helen M.; Nunes, David P.; Schroy, Paul C.; Barish, Matthew A.; Clarke, Peter D.; Ferrucci, Joseph T. // New England Journal of Medicine;11/11/99, Vol. 341 Issue 20, p1496 

    Background: Virtual colonoscopy is a new method of imaging the colon in which thin-section, helical computed tomography (CT) is used to generate high-resolution, two-dimensional axial images. Three-dimensional images of the colon simulating those obtained with conventional colonoscopy are then...

  • Association between colonic polyps and diverticular disease. Hirata, Tetsuo; Kawakami, Yuko; Kinjo, Nagisa; Arakaki, Susumu; Arakaki, Tetsu; Hokama, Akira; Kinjo, Fukunori; Fujita, Jiro; Costa, Francesco; Seow-Choen, Francis; Basson, Marc // World Journal of Gastroenterology;4/21/2008, Vol. 14 Issue 15, p2411 

    AIM: To evaluate the association between colonic polyps and diverticular disease in Japan. METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed the medical records of 672 consecutive patients who underwent total colonoscopy between August 2006 and April 2007 at Nishinjo Hospital, Okinawa, Japan. Patients with a...

  • Inflammatory Tumor of the Cecum Simulating Neoplasm. Forde, Kenneth A.; Di Sant' Agnese, Paul; Waye, Jerome D. // American Journal of Gastroenterology;Oct1980, Vol. 74 Issue 4, p366 

    Barium enema performed on a 36-year old man prior to the operative repair of a rectal stricture demonstrated a large cecal filling defect which radiologically was consistent with a villous adenoma or carcinoma. At the time of exploratory celiotomy (for possible ileocolectomy) intraoperative...

  • Colorectal cancer screening and surveillance with CT colonography: current controversies and obstacles. Van Gelder, R. E.; Florie, J.; Stoker, J. // Abdominal Imaging;Jan/Feb2005, Vol. 30 Issue 1, p5 

    Computed tomographic (CT) colonography has been advocated as an alternative colorectal screening method because studies in populations with a high prevalence of polyps have demonstrated that sensitivity for patients with large (> or =10 mm) polyps is generally high (approximately 90%). In three...

  • Screening colonoscopy in the asymptomatic 50- to 59-year-old population. Mehran, A.; Jaffe, P.; Efron, J.; Vernavay, A.; Liberman, A.; Vernava, A // Surgical Endoscopy;Dec2003, Vol. 17 Issue 12, p1974 

    Background: In an effort to decrease the death rate from colorectal cancer, a multitude of medical societies and task forces recommend routine screening for colorectal cancer beginning at age 50. Yet, there is no consensus as to the best and most cost-effective screening method....

  • Colorectal Cancer Screening and Surveillance. SHORT, MATTHEW W.; LAYTON, MILES C.; TEER, BETHANY N.; DOMAGALSKI, JASON E. // American Family Physician;1/15/2015, Vol. 91 Issue 2, p93 

    Colorectal cancer is the third most common cancer in men and women. The incidence and mortality rate of the disease have been declining over the past two decades because of early detection and treatment. Screening in persons at average risk should begin at 50 years of age; the U.S. Preventive...

  • Quality Assessment of Colonoscopy Reporting: Results from a Statewide Cancer Screening Program. Jun Li; Nadel, Marion R.; Poppell, Carolyn F.; Dwyer, Diane M.; Lieberman, David A.; Steinberger, Eileen K. // Diagnostic & Therapeutic Endoscopy;2010, p1 

    This paper aimed to assess quality of colonoscopy reports and determine if physicians in practice were already documenting recommended quality indicators, prior to the publication of a standardized Colonoscopy Reporting and Data System (CO-RADS) in 2007. We examined 110 colonoscopy reports from...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics