Reflections on the centrality of power in medical sociology: An empirical test and theoretical elaboration

Broom, Alex
December 2006
Health Sociology Review;Dec2006, Vol. 15 Issue 5, p496
Academic Journal
This paper explores the contemporary relevance of sociological theorisations centred on medical power, including the medical dominance and deprofessionalisation theses. To achieve this it examines two issues that have been tentatively linked to the relative decline of the power and autonomy of biomedicine - complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) and the Internet-informed patient. Drawing on these two different but interconnected social phenomena, this paper reflects on the potential limitations of power-based theorisations of the medical profession and its relationship to patients and other non-biomedically situated professional groups. It is argued that power-based conceptual schemas may not adequately reflect the non-linear and complex strategic adaptations that are occurring among professional groups.


Related Articles

  • Power and Dependence in Intimate Exchange. Van de Rijt, Arnout; Macy, Michael W. // Social Forces;Mar2006, Vol. 84 Issue 3, p1455 

    A division of labor is mediated by exchange of valued goods and services. We use social exchange theory to extend this principal to "labors of love." Sexual activity in a close personal relationship seems outside the domain of bargaining and exchange. Nevertheless, we explore the possibility...

  • An Experimental Analysis of Imbalance in Punishment Power. Molm, Linda D. // Social Forces;Sep89, Vol. 68 Issue 1, p178 

    Abstract The restriction of power-dependence theory to reward-based power has limited knowledge of power use in exchange relations in which actors control both rewarding and aversive outcomes for one another. This study, the second in an experimental program studying exchange relations that...

  • Perspectives on and Conceptualizations of Compliance and Compliance-Gaining. Garko, Michael G. // Communication Quarterly;Spring1990, Vol. 38 Issue 2, p138 

    Scholars have offered a number of different conceptualizations of compliance and compliance-gaining which reflect broader competing perspectives. While there have been attempts to synthesize and clarify the empirical literature on compliance-gaining, there has been little attention devoted to...

  • Why are there still dinosaurs in the business world? Lustig, Tricia; McGill, Lynda // e-Organisations & People;Winter2012, Vol. 19 Issue 4, p56 

    The article focuses on organizations that, like dinosaurs, are doomed to be extinct. A comparison is made between organizations which operate like dinosaurs and human beings who think like apes in terms of the inertia of heritage and the power of the future. The concept of a Self-Renewing...

  • American Exceptionalism or American Visitor Hedgehoggism? Therivel, William A. // Journal of Social Behavior & Personality;Jun97, Vol. 12 Issue 2, p417 

    A new personality type is proposed, the visitor hedgehog, to describe Americans, especially when contrasting them to other people, e.g., Europeans. Visitor hedgehog combines visitor (Therivel, 1992, 1995) the modal personality of people living for centuries under division of power, and hedgehog...

  • Exploring Dimensions, Scales, and Cross-scale Dynamics from the Perspectives of Change Agents in Social--ecological Systems. Vervoort, Joost M.; Rutting, Lucas; Kok, Kasper; Hermans, Frans L. P.; Veldkamp, Tom; Bregt, Arnold K.; van Lammeren, Ron // Ecology & Society;Dec2012, Vol. 17 Issue 4, p274 

    Issues of scale play a crucial role in the governance of social--ecological systems. Yet, attempts to bridge interdisciplinary perspectives on the role of scale have thus far largely been limited to the science arena. This study has extended the scale vocabulary to allow for the inclusion of...

  • From Status to Power: New Models at the Intersection of Two Theories. Thye, Shane R.; Willer, David; Markovsky, Barry // Social Forces;Mar2006, Vol. 84 Issue 3, p1471 

    The study of group processes has benefited from longstanding programs of theory-driven research on status and power. The present work constructs a bridge between two formal theories of status and power: Status Characteristics Theory and Network Exchange Theory. Two theoretical models, one for...

  • BECAUSE MY MASTER BATHES ME. Farmer, David John // Administrative Theory & Praxis (Administrative Theory & Praxis);Jun2003, Vol. 25 Issue 2, p205 

    Shouldn't we do more to correct the power imbalance afflicting PA theory and practice? I suggest a corrective program incorporating a relevant theory of PA reform. Relevant are layers of phenomena now virtual strangers in traditional PA thinking. Relevant is Dominique Laporte's analysis of...

  • Hi-tech can free us from jobs system. Boggs, Grace Lee // Michigan Citizen;10/23/2011, Vol. 33 Issue 50, pA10 

    The article offers the author's insights on the influence of high technology on the empowerment of individuals to spread information and produce their own goods and services to destroy the industrial job system in the U.S.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics