Repentance and forgiveness: the undoing of time

Wyschogrod, Edith
December 2006
International Journal for Philosophy of Religion;Dec2006, Vol. 60 Issue 1-3, p157
Academic Journal
Mass death resulting from war, starvation, and disease as well as the vicissitudes of extreme poverty and enforced sexual servitude are recognizably pandemic ills of the contemporary world. In light of their magnitude, are repentance, regret for the harms inflicted upon others or oneself, and forgiveness, proferring the erasure of the guilt of those who have inflicted these harms, rendered nugatory? Jacques Derrida claims that forgiveness is intrinsically rather than circumstantially or historically impossible. Forgiveness, trapped in a paradox, is possible only if there is such a thing as the unforgivable. “Thus, forgiveness, if there is such a thing,” can only exist as exempt from the law of the possible. Does this claim not open the way for hopelessness and despair? More troubling for Derrida is his concession that forgiveness may be necessary in the realm of the political and juridical. If so, is not the purity of the impossibility of forgiveness so crucial for him, contaminated? In pointing to some of the difficulties in Derrida’s position, I shall appeal to Vladimir Jankelevitch’s distinction between the unforgivable and the inexcusable. I shall also consider the significance of repentance in the theological ethics of Emmanuel Levinas and Max Scheler. Forgiveness, I conclude, is vacuous without expiation, a position that can be helpfully understood in the context of Judaism’s analysis of purification and acquittal in the Day of Atonement liturgy. I argue that what disappears is Derrida’s assurance of the impossibility of forgiveness, a disappearance that allows for hope.


Related Articles

  • PERDÓN Y ARREPENTIMIENTO: LA EXPERIENCIA DE JEAN AMÉRY. Rueda, Camila // Ideas y Valores;2012, Vol. 61 Issue 148, p79 

    Jacques Derrida has suggested that forgiveness should understood as the unforgivable: in order for forgiveness to be pure, its object must be the unforgivable. Furthermore, he states that no conditions should be imposed on granting forgiveness. The article seeks to show that this purity has to...

  • Forgiveness: An unCONVENTIONal Weapon in a Conventional World of Conflict. Oludaja, Bayo // Conference Papers -- National Communication Association;2008, p1 

    The importance of forgiveness may be readily evident against the backdrop of broken promises and/or relationships. But what is not so evident is the paradoxical nature of forgiveness which makes it unCONVENTIONal in cases where it is sometimes most desirable. Using Jacques...

  • 'As If' There Were a 'Jew': The (non)Existence of Deconstructive Responsibility. Gaon, Stella // Derrida Today;May2014, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p44 

    The argument of this paper hinges on Derrida's relation to Judaism as a religious heritage and/or as an essential experience. If he can be said to 'appropriate his Jewish roots' at all, as Colby Dickinson (2011) has recently proposed, this is not because Derrida concurs that all belief in an...

  • Suturing the Wound: Derrida's "On Forgiveness" and Schlink's The Reader. Worthington, Kim L. // Comparative Literature;Spring2011, Vol. 63 Issue 2, p203 

    An essay is presented on the familiar moral terminology used in the novel "The Reader," by Bernhard Schlink. The author explores the concept of forgiveness in "The Reader" and its conceptual linkage to comprehension. He also considers the moral terms used in Schlink's novel in reference to the...

  • Reconciliation and Founding Wounds. Drabinski, John E. // Humanity: An International Journal of Human Rights, Humanitarian;Spring2013, Vol. 4 Issue 1, p117 

    An essay is presented on the importance of forgiveness and reconciliation as modes of politics-toward-the-future. It cites the critical development of philosopher Jacques Derrida's theory on globalatinzation and his insight on forgiveness. The author also argues how the idea of reconciliation...

  • Resented and Unforgiven. Minkkinen, Panu // Harvard Unbound;2006, Vol. 2 Issue 1, p57 

    Discusses the trend of developing law that incorporates a structural and symbolic element of forgiveness to establish transitional justice after periods of conflict and crimes. Proof that the modern law failed to deliver the objective of social justice; Implication of the ethical and political...

  • On Cosmopolitanism and Forgiveness (Book).  // Contemporary Review;Jun2002, Vol. 280 Issue 1637, p381 

    Reviews the book 'On Cosmopolitanism and Forgiveness,' translated by Jacques Derrida, Mark Dooley and Michael Hughes.

  • The Politics of Justice and the French Blood Affair in Hélène Cixous's The Perjured City. Erlingsdóttir, Irma // Paragraph;Nov2015, Vol. 38 Issue 3, p369 

    In the article, I examine Hélène Cixous's play La Ville parjure ou le Réveil des Erinyes ( The Perjured City) as a political contribution to the debate over memory and justice. The focus is on the question of how the telling of a story of atrocities may be therapeutic to both the victim...

  • Hegel and Derrida on Forgiveness: The Impossible at the Core of the Political. María del Rosario, Acosta López // Derrida Today;May2012, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p55 

    In order to illuminate the very complex relationship between ethics and politics in the thought of Jacques Derrida, this paper stages the (dis)encounter between Hegel's and Derrida's notion of forgiveness. It will be shown how for these two authors forgiveness is closely related both with...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics