Evaluation of Operational Model Cyclone Structure Forecasts during Extratropical Transition

Evans, Jenni L.; Arnott, Justin M.; Chiaromonte, Francesca
November 2006
Monthly Weather Review;Nov2006, Vol. 134 Issue 11, p3054
Academic Journal
Cyclone structure is known to be directly linked to the sensible weather effects produced by the weather system. The extratropical transition (ET) process leads to immense changes in cyclone structure and therefore to changes in the associated weather experienced. Although structure is clearly an important cyclone characteristic, validation of cyclone structure forecasts in operational numerical models has not been previously performed. In this study, short-term (12–36 h) forecasts of cyclone structure from tropical genesis to the completion of ET are validated using fields from the Navy Operational Global Atmospheric Prediction System and the NCEP Aviation model. The cyclone phase space (CPS) is used to quantify differences between forecast and analyzed storm structure, both on a point-by-point basis and through a cyclone-type-based comparison. This cyclone-type comparison exploits a previously defined breakdown of cyclone structure regimes in the CPS. The impacts of synthetic vortex insertion on the ensuing agreement between forecast and analyzed storm structure are explored. While the results show reasonable forecast skill for well-defined (i.e., nonhybrid) systems, cyclones in the process of ET are found to be poorly forecast, emphasizing the need for improved understanding and simulation of the structural changes experienced by ET cyclones.


Related Articles

  • Probabilistic Prediction of Tropical Cyclones. Part I: Position. Weber, Harry C. // Monthly Weather Review;Jul2005, Vol. 133 Issue 7, p1840 

    A new objective aid for operational prediction of the positions of tropical cyclones is presented. Its method is based on a simple analysis of the performance of all operationally available numerical models during a training period. In a subsequent forecast period, the results of this analysis...

  • HURRICANE HUNTERS.  // Time;9/27/2004, Vol. 164 Issue 13, p40 

    Discusses how technological advances have improved hurricane forecasting over the past 25 years. Consideration of how clusters of thunderstorms gather to form low-pressure areas which draw in air and generate spin in a counterclockwise direction; Process in which warm ocean water fuels the...

  • A Comparison of Adaptive Observing Guidance for Atlantic Tropical Cyclones. Majumdar, S. J.; Aberson, S. D.; Bishop, C. H.; Buizza, R.; Peng, M. S.; Reynolds, C. A. // Monthly Weather Review;Sep2006, Vol. 134 Issue 9, p2354 

    Airborne adaptive observations have been collected for more than two decades in the neighborhood of tropical cyclones, to attempt to improve short-range forecasts of cyclone track. However, only simple subjective strategies for adaptive observations have been used, and the utility of objective...

  • Predictability as a Function of Scale. Boer, G. J. // Atmosphere -- Ocean (Canadian Meteorological & Oceanographic Soc;Sep2003, Vol. 41 Issue 3, p203 

    The forecast skill of the Canadian Meteorological Centre (CMC) operational global forecast/analysis system is assessed as a function of scale for the traditional forecast variable of 500-hPa geopotential height using results from January 2002. These results are compared to an earlier analysis of...

  • The Sensitivity of Numerical Forecasts to Convective Parameterization: A Case Study of the 17 February 2004 East Coast Cyclone. Mahoney, Kelly M.; Lackmann, Gary M. // Weather & Forecasting;Aug2006, Vol. 21 Issue 4, p465 

    The sensitivity of numerical model forecasts of coastal cyclogenesis and frontogenesis to the choice of model cumulus parameterization (CP) scheme is examined for the 17 February 2004 southeastern U.S. winter weather event. This event featured a complex synoptic and mesoscale environment, as the...

  • A Comparison of Two Tropical Cyclone Bogussing Schemes. Wang, Dongliang; Liang, Xudong; Zhao, Ying; Wang, Bin // Weather & Forecasting;Feb2008, Vol. 23 Issue 1, p194 

    The impact of two bogussing schemes on tropical cyclone (TC) forecasts is compared. One scheme for bogussing TCs into the initial conditions of the nonhydrostatic version of the fifth-generation Pennsylvania State University–National Center for Atmospheric Research (PSU–NCAR)...

  • Hurricane Watch 2007. Gilkey, Eric // Claims;Jun2007, Vol. 55 Issue 6, p10 

    The article deals with predicting hurricanes and tropical storms for 2007. According to forecasters, slow cyclone seasons will be the exception for next several years. The Atlantic Oceanographic and Meteorological Laboratory says that the formation of Tropical Storm Andrea prior to the official...

  • The BMRC High-Resolution Tropical Cyclone Prediction System: TC-LAPS. Davidson, Noel E.; Weber, Harry C. // Monthly Weather Review;May2000, Vol. 128 Issue 5, p1245 

    A new Tropical Cyclone Limited Area Prediction System has been developed at the Australian Bureau of Meteorology Research Centre. The features of the new prediction system can be summarized as follows: first, a 12-h, coarse-resolution data assimilation is used to define the outer structure and...

  • Predictability of Extratropical Cyclones: The Influence of Initial Condition and Model Uncertainties. Hongyan Zhu; Thorpe, Alan // Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences;May2006, Vol. 63 Issue 5, p1483 

    Errors in numerical weather forecasts can be attributed to two causes: deficiencies in the modeling system and inaccurate initial conditions. Understanding of the characteristics of the growth of forecast spread related to model uncertainty is less developed than that for initial condition...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics