Valentin, Jolene E.; Badylak, John S.; McCabe, George P.; Badylak, Stephen F.
December 2006
Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Dec2006, Vol. 88-A Issue 12, p2673
Academic Journal
Background: Biologic scaffold materials prepared from extracellular matrix are currently available for the surgical repair of damaged or missing musculotendinous tissue. These scaffolds differ in their species and tissue of origin, methods of processing, and methods of terminal sterilization. The purpose of the present study was to evaluate the host-tissue morphologic response to five commercially available extracellular matrix-derived biologic scaffolds used for orthopaedic soft-tissue repair in a rodent model. Methods: One hundred twenty-six Sprague-Dawley rats were divided into six groups of twenty-one animals each. A defect was created in the musculotendinous tissue of the abdominal wall of each animal and then was repaired with one of five different scaffold materials (GraftJacket, Restore, CuffPatch, TissueMend, Permacol) or with the excised autologous tissue. Three animals from each group were killed at one of seven time-points after surgery (two, four, seven, fourteen, twenty-eight, fifty-six, and 112 days), and the specimens were examined with histologic and morphologic methods. The degree of cellular infiltration, multinucleated giant cell presence, vascularity, and organization of the replacement connective tissue were evaluated with semiquantitative methods. Results: Each device elicited a distinct morphologic response that differed with respect to cellularity (p < 0.001), vascularity (p < 0.01), the presence of multinucleated giant cells (p < 0.01), and organization of the remodeled tissue (p < 0.01) at or after the Day 7 time-point. More rapidly degraded devices such as Restore and autologous tissue showed the greatest amount of cellular infiltration, especially at the early time-points. Devices that degraded slowly, such as CuffPatch, TissueMend, and Permacol, were associated with the presence of foreign-body giant cells, chronic inflammation, and/or the accumulation of dense, poorly organized fibrous tissue. Conclusions: Biologic scaffold materials composed of extracellular matrix elicit distinct host-tissue histologic and morphologic responses, depending on species of origin, tissue of origin, processing methods, and/or method of terminal sterilization. Clinical Relevance: The temporal sequence of remodeling events of extracellular matrix devices, including the rapidity of scaffold degradation and the extent of new-tissue deposition by the host, may be predictive of the clinical course and may determine the optimal rehabilitation protocol and functional outcome of the procedure.


Related Articles

  • Mechanics of crural fascia: from anatomy to constitutive modelling. Stecco, Carla; Pavan, Piero G.; Porzionato, Andrea; Macchi, Veronica; Lancerotto, Luca; Carniel, Emanuele L.; Natali, Arturo; De Caro, Raffaele // Surgical & Radiologic Anatomy;Aug2009, Vol. 31 Issue 7, p523 

    Ten dissections of inferior limbs and histological studies were performed to describe the structural conformation of the muscular fascia of the leg (crural fascia) and to propose a constitutive model to be adopted for the analysis of its biomechanical behaviour. The crural fascia had a mean...

  • Use of Cis-[18F]Fluoro-Proline for Assessment of Exercise-Related Collagen Synthesis in Musculoskeletal Connective Tissue. Skovgaard, Dorthe; Kjaer, Andreas; Heinemeier, Katja Maria; Brandt-Larsen, Malene; Madsen, Jacob; Kjaer, Michael // PLoS ONE;2011, Vol. 6 Issue 2, p1 

    Protein turnover in collagen rich tissue is influenced by exercise, but can only with difficulty be studied in vivo due to use of invasive procedure. The present study was done to investigate the possibility of applying the PET-tracer, cis-[18F]fluoro-proline (cis-Fpro), for non-invasive...

  • Fibre-Matrix Interaction in Soft Tissue. Zaoyang Guo // AIP Conference Proceedings;5/21/2010, Vol. 1233 Issue 1, p1249 

    Although the mechanical behaviour of soft tissue has been extensively studied, the interaction between the collagen fibres and the ground matrix has not been well understood and is therefore ignored by most constitutive models of soft tissue. In this paper, the human annulus fibrosus is used as...

  • Long-term outcome after use of an acellular collagen matrix in a finger degloving injury. Bravo, Elena; Nunez-Villaveiran, Teresa // European Journal of Plastic Surgery;Dec2014, Vol. 37 Issue 12, p687 

    In ring avulsion injuries, replantation may not always be possible because of the extent of the injury or the loss of the severed part. Under these circumstances, other treatment options should be considered. We describe our 5-year follow-up experience after the coverage of a complete digital...

  • Acellular extracellular matrix for inguinal hernia repair. Ma, S. Z.; Li, X. H.; Hu, J. // Hernia;Jun2006, Vol. 10 Issue 3, p229 

    To investigate the clinical safety and effectiveness of acellular extracellular matrix (AEM) for inguinal hernia repair, 53 well-conducted and well-chosen sequential cases with inguinal hernia (56 inguinal hernias) were included in our multi-center study. All the inguinal hernias were repaired...

  • The use of cervical fascia for hypopharyngeal reconstruction with laryngeal preservation. &Eth;anić, Davorin; Miličić, Damir // European Archives of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology;Apr2003, Vol. 260 Issue 4, p207 

    Surgical resection of carcinomas of the posterior hypopharyngeal wall and reconstruction of defects with preservation of laryngeal function and swallowing are complex surgical problems. The various reconstructive procedures have been well described. There is no uniform agreement among surgeons...

  • ECM-Chitosan Bandage for Tissue Repair. Lauto, Antonio; Longo, Leonardo // AIP Conference Proceedings;5/31/2010, Vol. 1226 Issue 1, p155 

    Extracellular matrices (ECMs) are currently applied in reconstructive surgery to enhance wound healing and tissue remodelling. Sutures and staples are usually employed to stabilize ECM on tissue although they may damage the matrix structure. In this investigation, a novel biocompatible bandage...

  • Canadian doctor differentiates between fillers. Rutledge, Barbara J. // Cosmetic Surgery Times;Mar2005, Vol. 8 Issue 2, p18 

    This article focuses on an overview of injectable fillers in cosmetic surgery. Categories of temporary fillers include xenogenic fillers, such as Zyplast (bovine collagen, Inamed), Fibrel (porcine collagen. Mentor Corp.) and Hyalform (hyaluranon derived from rooster combs, Inamed); homogeneic...

  • Self-Organization of Muscle Cell Structure and Function. Grosberg, Anna; Po-Ling Kuo; Chin-Lin Guo; Geisse, Nicholas A.; Bray, Mark-Anthony; Adams, William J.; Sheehy, Sean P.; Parker, Kevin Kit // PLoS Computational Biology;Feb2011, Vol. 7 Issue 2, p1 

    The organization of muscle is the product of functional adaptation over several length scales spanning from the sarcomere to the muscle bundle. One possible strategy for solving this multiscale coupling problem is to physically constrain the muscle cells in microenvironments that potentiate the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics