Differential Expression of Prognostic Factors and Effect on Survival in Young (≤40) Breast Cancer Patients: A Case-Control Study

Hartley, Michael C.; McKinley, Brian P.; Rogers, Emily A.; Kalbaugh, Corey A.; Messich, H. S.; Blackhurst, Dawn W.; Lokey, Jonathan S.; Trocha, Steven D.
December 2006
American Surgeon;Dec2006, Vol. 72 Issue 12, p1189
Academic Journal
The belief that young women develop more aggressive forms of breast cancer than other women is controversial. The purpose of this study was to determine if women 40 years of age and under with breast cancer have more negative prognostic indicators and a higher 5-year mortality than those women over 40 years of age. From January 1998-December 2002, all women with breast cancer were identified from our tumor registry. Women with metastatic disease at presentation were excluded from our study. The women were divided into two groups, women under 40 (cases) and women 40 and over (controls). Seventy-eight cases were identified and matched to 228 controls. These cohorts were matched 3:1 (cases:controls) based on tumor staging. The data collected on each patient included prognostic factors such as tumor size, tumor type, estrogen and progesterone receptors, Her2/neu, and Ki-67. Information on surgical procedure, postoperative therapy, recurrence, and mortality was also gathered. The mean ages for cases and controls were 35 and 59 years, respectively. The rates of modified radical mastectomy were similar in the two groups, but young women were more likely to have breast reconstruction (33.7% vs 9.8%). The rates of breast conservation therapy were actually lower in the group under 40 (32.5% vs 37.6%). Tumors in the 40 and under group were more frequently estrogen receptor negative (33.8% vs 21.9%: P = 0.046) and progesterone receptor negative (50.0% vs 35.5%: P = 0.033). Younger women also experienced a greater prevalence of Ki-67 (P < 0.001) and higher levels of Her2/neu overexpression (P = 0.013). Women over 40 were more likely to receive hormonal therapy (39.7% vs 36.1%). Women over 40 had a lower overall rate of recurrence. A difference in overall survival does exist between these two groups of women, which trends toward significance. The women 40 and under had a lower overall 5-year survival. The reason for this difference remains unclear. Although we demonstrate a higher percentage of younger women with negative biochemical markers, the only factors independently and significantly related to higher mortality were estrogen receptor negativity and tumor stage at presentation.


Related Articles

  • Long term prognosis of women with breast cancer in New Zealand: study of survival to 30 years. Hibberd, A.D.; Horwood, L.J.; Wells, J.E. // British Medical Journal (Clinical Research Edition);6/4/1983, Vol. 286 Issue 6380, p1777 

    Examines the long-term prognosis of women with breast cancer in New Zealand. Decline of excess mortality rate; Need for prospective study; Biases on the reported cause of death.

  • Malignant Phyllodes Tumors: A Review of 752 Cases. Grabowski, Julia; Salzstein, Sidney L.; Sadler, Georgia R.; Blair, Sarah L. // American Surgeon;Oct2007, Vol. 73 Issue 10, p967 

    Malignant phyllodes tumor (MPT) is a rare breast malignancy. Because of the scarcity of the disease, there are no evidence-based treatment or follow-up guidelines established. This study evaluated the survival of MPT patients to create recommendations for management. We identified 752 cases of...

  • Traditional and Newer Pathologic Factors. Schnitt, Stuart J. // JNCI: Journal of the National Cancer Institute;2001, Vol. 93 Issue 30, p22 

    There has long been a pressing clinical need to identify prognostic and predictive factors for patients with breast cancer. Although numerous candidate biological and molecular markers have been identified during the last two decades, traditional factors such as lymph node status, tumor size,...

  • Commentary: much still to learn about relations between tumour biology, prognosis, and treatment outcome in early breast cancer. Tutt, Andrew; Ross, Gillian // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);02/19/2000, Vol. 320 Issue 7233, p478 

    Discusses the relations between tumor, biology, prognosis and treatment outcome in early breast cancer. Biological processes involved in breast cancer; Evidence of action in breast cancer; Comments on the relations.

  • P-cadherin and cytokeratin 5: useful adjunct markers to distinguish basal-like ductal carcinomas in situ. Nair Lopes // Virchows Archiv;Jan2007, Vol. 450 Issue 1, p73 

    Abstract??Gene expression profiles of invasive breast carcinomas have identified a subgroup of tumours with worse prognosis, which have been called ?basal-like?. These are characterized by a specific pattern of expression, being estrogen receptor (ER) and HER2 negative, and frequently expressing...

  • Computational prognostic indicators for breast cancer. Xinan Yang; Xindi Ai; Cunningham, John M. // Cancer Management & Research;2014, Vol. 6, p301 

    Breast cancer remains the leading cause of cancer-related mortality in women. Comprehensive genomics, proteomics, and metabolomics studies are emerging that offer an opportunity to model disease biology, prognosis, and response to specific therapies. Although many biomarkers have been identified...

  • Breast Cancer in Young Women: Poor Survival Despite Intensive Treatment.  // PLoS ONE;2009, Vol. 4 Issue 11, p1 

    The article presents a study examining the survival ratio and relative excess mortality (RER) of young women with breast cancer. As mentioned, 5-year relative survival ratio was found to be lowest in women aged 20-34 and RER was 2.84 for women aged 20-34 and decreased with increasing age. It is...

  • Autoamputation of breast following breast carcinoma. Agarwal, Pawan; Sharma, Dhananjaya // Internet Journal of Surgery;2009, Vol. 18 Issue 1, p3 

    Carcinoma of the breast is psychologically devastating to the patient. Although the breast is an easily accessible organ, patients frequently present with advanced malignant tumors. Here we report an unusual case of total auto-destruction of the breast following cancer in a middle-aged woman,...

  • A Pooled Analysis of Bone Marrow Micrometastasis in Breast Cancer. Braun, Stephan; Vogl, Florian D.; Naume, Bj�rn; Janni, Wolfgang; Osborne, Michael P.; Coombes, R. Charles; Schlimok, G�nter; Diel, Ingo J.; Gerber, Bernd; Gebauer, Gerhard; Pierga, Jean-Yves; Marth, Christian; Oruzio, Daniel; Wiedswang, Gro; Solomayer, Erich-Franz; Kundt, G�nther; Strobl, Barbara; Fehm, Tanja; Wong, George Y.C.; Bliss, Judith // New England Journal of Medicine;8/25/2005, Vol. 353 Issue 8, p793 

    Background: We assessed the prognostic significance of the presence of micrometastasis in the bone marrow at the time of diagnosis of breast cancer by means of a pooled analysis. Methods: We combined individual patient data from nine studies involving 4703 patients with stage I, II, or III...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics