TITLE

Attitudes of patients, healthcare professionals and ethicists towards embryonic stem cell research and donation of gametes and embryos in Germany

AUTHOR(S)

Krones, T.; Neuwohner, E.; Bock, K.; Manolopoulos, K.; Tinneberg, H. R.; Richter, G.

PUB. DATE

November 2006

SOURCE

Reproductive BioMedicine Online;Nov2006, Vol. 13 Issue 5, p607

SOURCE TYPE

Academic Journal

DOC. TYPE

Article

ABSTRACT

Due to the Embryo Protection Act, creation of supernumerary embryos, as well as egg and embryo donation, is prohibited in Germany. Human stem cell research is regulated through the Act on stem cells that came into force in 2002. A cross-sectional survey of 101 IVF couples (n = 202) in two fertility centres, and representative samples of healthcare professionals and ethicists (n = 879), was carried out, and their attitudes towards embryonic stem cell research and donation of gametes and embryos compared. A clear majority of IVF couples favoured legalization of egg and embryo donation and embryonic stem cell research for various purposes. The willingness of couples to donate was related to purpose and to other independent influences. The majority of physicians voted for legalization of embryonic stem cell production from surplus embryos. Most human geneticists and obstetricians approved egg, but not embryo, donation to other couples. Ethicists and midwives were opposed to every kind of donation and research on surplus embryos. The IVF couples surveyed have positive attitudes towards donation and research using surplus embryos, whereas the healthcare professionals and ethicists and predominantly sceptical about most research activities destroying human embryos. This difference should be considered carefully in legal and ethical discussions on reprogenetics.

ACCESSION #

23182289

Tags: LEGISLATION;  ATTITUDE (Psychology);  COMMERCIALIZATION;  DONATION of organs, tissues, etc.;  MEDICAL ethics;  EMBRYONIC stem cells

 

Related Articles

• THE NEGLECT OF THE UMBILICAL CORD: OHIO'S FAILURE TO ADEQUATELY PROMOTE BANKING OF UMBILICAL CORD BLOOD STEM CELLS AND THE NEED FOR NEW LEGISLATION. Folger, Shannon // Journal of Law & Health;2009, Vol. 22 Issue 1, p137 

  This article discusses the umbilical cord blood stem cells' use and donation and the insufficiency of the U.S. legislation in promoting public donation. It notes that the federal funding of embryonic stem cell research generates controversy due to the therapeutic potential linked to embryonic...

• An approach to the ethical donation of human embryos for harvest of stem cells. Schwartz, Philip H.; Rae, Scott B. // Reproductive BioMedicine Online;Jun2006, Vol. 12 Issue 6, p771 

  This paper considers embryo grading within a given infertility treatment and suggests an ethical approach to embryo donation for embryonic stem cell harvest. It is concluded that ethical considerations regarding human embryos do not necessarily preclude the use of certain embryos for biomedical...

• Egg Donation and Human Embryonic Stem-Cell Research. Steinbrook, Robert // New England Journal of Medicine;1/26/2006, Vol. 354 Issue 4, p324 

  The article discusses egg donation and human embryonic stem-cell research. The scientific fraud of South Korean scientist Woo Suk Hwang is discussed. Hwang admitted he had used oocytes from other scientists and from paid donors. Hwang retracted two research papers regarding embryonic stem cells....

• Ethics, Eggs And Embryos. Kalb, Claudia // Newsweek;6/20/2005, Vol. 145 Issue 25, p52 

  Looks at the use of human eggs in stem-cell research. Discussion of the ethical aspects of using human human eggs and embryos in scientific research; Efforts of U.S. politicians to legislate the use of human embryos in research; Impact of the success of somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) by...

• Elective ventilation for organ donation: law, policy and public ethics. Coggon, John // Journal of Medical Ethics;Mar2013, Vol. 39 Issue 3, p130 

  This paper examines questions concerning elective ventilation, contextualised within English law and policy. It presents the general debate with reference both to the Exeter Protocol on elective ventilation, and the considerable developments in legal principle since the time that that protocol...

• Egg shortage hits race to clone human stem cells. Maher, Brendan // Nature;6/12/2008, Vol. 453 Issue 7197, p828 

  The article reports on the demand of stem-cell researchers to amend the state laws that prohibit them to compensate women egg cell donors in the U.S. The researchers argue that the laws could deprive the production of embryonic stem-cell lines used in the study of various human diseases. Kevin...

• Will All of Him Be at the Funeral? Klaiman, M. H. // Humanist;Nov/Dec2005, Vol. 65 Issue 6, p36 

  This article urges each U.S. state to adopt legislation to regulate postmortem organ retention. Such legislation is appropriate given the fact that medical authorities have continued the practice knowing there are no laws prohibiting it. Presently no state restricts nonconsensual postmortem...

• Laws could change on organ donation. GEDDES, LINDA // New Scientist;9/18/2008, Vol. 199 Issue 2673, p11 

  The article reports that the British government is considering changing the law on organ donation to presumed consent which would make everyone a potential donor unless they opt out. According to the author, doctors are raising doubts about the proposal, partly for ethical reasons and because of...

• ALTRUISTIC LIVING UNRELATED ORGAN DONATION AT THE CROSSROADS OF ETHICS AND RELIGION. A CASE STUDY.  // Journal for the Study of Religions & Ideologies;Dec2010, Vol. 9 Issue 27, p3 

  No abstract available.

Read the Article