Dynamic Assessment of School-Age Children's Narrative Ability: An Experimental Investigation of Classification Accuracy

Peña, Elizabeth D.; Gillam, Ronald B.; Malek, Melynn; Ruiz-Felter, Roxanna; Resendiz, Maria; Fiestas, Christine; Sabel, Tracy
October 2006
Journal of Speech, Language & Hearing Research;Oct2006, Vol. 49 Issue 5, p1037
Academic Journal
Two experiments examined reliability and classification accuracy of a narration-based dynamic assessment task. Purpose: The first experiment evaluated whether parallel results were obtained from stories created in response to 2 different wordless picture books. If so, the tasks and measures would be appropriate for assessing pretest and posttest change within a dynamic assessment format. The second experiment evaluated the extent to which children with language impairments performed differently than typically developing controls on dynamic assessment of narrative language. Method: In the first experiment, 58 1st- and 2nd-grade children told 2 stories about wordless picture books. Stories were rated on macrostructural and microstructural aspects of language form and content, and the ratings were subjected to reliability analyses. In the second experiment, 71 children participated in dynamic assessment. There were 3 phases: a pretest phase, in which children created a story that corresponded to 1 of the wordless picture books from Experiment 1; a teaching phase, in which children attended 2 short mediation sessions that focused on storytelling ability; and a posttest phase, in which children created a story that corresponded to a second wordless picture book from Experiment 1. Analyses compared the pretest and posttest stories that were told by 2 groups of children who received mediated learning (typical and language impaired groups) and a no-treatment control group of typically developing children from Experiment 1. Results: The results of the first experiment indicated that the narrative measures applied to stories about 2 different wordless picture books had good internal consistency. In Experiment 2, typically developing children who received mediated learning demonstrated a greater amount of pretest to posttest change than children in the language impaired and control groups. Classification analysis indicated better specificity and sensitivity values for measures of response to intervention (modifiability) and posttest storytelling than for measures of pretest storytelling. Observation of modifiability was the single best indicator of language impairment. Posttest measures and modifiability together yielded no misclassifications. Conclusion: The first experiment supported the use of 2 wordless picture books as stimulus materials for collecting narratives before and after mediation within a dynamic assessment paradigm. The second experiment supported the use of dynamic assessment for accurately identifying language impairments in school-age children.


Related Articles

  • The Maximum Flows in Planar Dynamic Networks. Schiopu, C.; Ciurea, E. // International Journal of Computers, Communications & Control;Apr2016, Vol. 11 Issue 2, p282 

    An nontrivial extension of the maximal static flow problem is the maximal dynamic flow model, where the transit time to traverse an arc is taken into consideration. If the network parameters as capacities, arc traversal times, and so on, are constant over time, then a dynamic flow problem is...

  • The orientation of professional training of future specialists towards the formation of their readiness to work on the improvement of relations among older pre-school children. Krakovskaya, Marina // Vestnik IKBFU;2013, Issue 5, p151 

    This article describes various aspects of the preparation of future specialists for working towards the improvement of relationships between children of pre-school age and reports the results of scientific experiments aimed at the formation of future specialists' readiness for working towards...

  • An analysis of change in Korean-American and Korean students' learning styles. Hong, Eunsook; Suh, Bernadyn K. // Psychological Reports;Apr95, Vol. 76 Issue 2, p691 

    Analyzes the changes in learning styles of Korean-American and Korean grade school students. Selection of subjects; Use of the Learning Style Inventory; Aspects of changes.

  • Assessment and Instruction of At-Risk Hispanic Students. Duran, Richard P. // Exceptional Children;Oct1989, Vol. 56 Issue 2, p154 

    This article summarizes some of the key limitations underlying existing standardized test use with Hispanic students; it also explores recent developments in testing, teaching, and learning research that suggest major improvements in the way testing and assessment can be developed as tools for...

  • Process/content/design/critique: Generative and dynamic evaluation in a digital world. Tierney, Robert J.; Rogers, Theresa // Reading Teacher;Oct2004, Vol. 58 Issue 2, p218 

    Comments on digital-based literacies in student learning and engagements. Vignettes of classroom literacy involving new technologies and curricular goals; Assessment criteria and practices for interacting with new literacies; Purpose of dynamic assessment tools; Main goal of evaluation.

  • Rapid Dynamic Assessment of Expertise to Improve the Efficiency of Adaptive E-learning. Kalyuga, Slava; Sweller, John // Educational Technology Research & Development;2005, Vol. 53 Issue 3, p83 

    In this article we suggest a method of evaluating learner expertise based on assessment of the content of working memory and the extent to which cognitive load has been reduced by knowledge retrieved from long-term memory. The method was tested in an experiment with an elementary algebra tutor...

  • Application of Nida's theory of functional equivalence in trademark translation. Xu Jian-hang // Sino-US English Teaching;2009, Vol. 6 Issue 12, p47 

    Through the introduction of Nida's translation theory, characteristics of trademark and some principles that should be obeyed in trademark translation, the essay discussed that the theory of dynamic equivalence (functional equivalence) was applied in trademark translation through the literal...

  • Part 6: Geometrical Structure of Boosting Algorithm. Kanamori, Takafumi; Takenouchi, Takashi; Murata, Noboru // New Generation Computing;2007, Vol. 25 Issue 1, p117 

    In this article, several boosting methods are discussed, which are notable implementations of the ensemble learning. Starting from the firstly introduced ‘boosting by filter’ which is an embodiment of the proverb ‘Two heads are better than one’, more advanced versions...

  • A review of South African research in the field of dynamic assessment. Murphy, Raegan; Maree, David J. F. // South African Journal of Psychology;Mar2006, Vol. 36 Issue 1, p168 

    Dynamic assessment, and in particular the learning potential approach, are receiving increasing attention from educators and research practitioners worldwide. This article reports on the status of dynamic assessment in South Africa, with particular reference to its use in higher education. A...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics