The First Water-Privatization Debate: Colorado Water Corporations in the Gilded Age

Schorr, David B.
May 2006
Ecology Law Quarterly;2006, Vol. 33 Issue 2, p313
Academic Journal
Contemporary debates over the worldwide trend toward privatization of water systems and supplies have a historical precedent in the controversies that raged in Gilded Age America over the control of irrigation-canal systems by eastern- and foreign-owned corporations. This Article shows how the law developed in Colorado in this period advanced the agrarian ideal of wide distribution of property in water by applying the principles behind the appropriation doctrine to water corporations claiming ownership of this crucial resource. The involvement of corporations funded by outside capital in Western water projects was seen as a threat to the contemporary yeoman ideal of small, family farms, an ideal that many hoped would solve the social and economic ills of the time. This Article discusses several concrete legal issues that arose in Colorado in the 1880s and '90s, demonstrating how the principle of public ownership of water and the use requirement were applied to curtail the power of water corporations and preserve the profits of irrigated agriculture for small-scale farmers. In conclusion, the Article discusses several implications of this early western water-corporation law. First, it calls into question the view of Gilded Age law as primarily serving the interests of the wealthy and powerful. Second. it challenges the common typology of property, in which private property is opposed with public, demonstrating that these two ideas can be in harmony, with the more important dichotomy distinguishing between widespread, diffuse ownership and concentrated ownership. Finally. the Article briefly points to several implications of this history lot today's water-privatization controversies.


Related Articles

  • Water: Resource or Commodity? Modraska, John // Journal: American Water Works Association;May2006, Vol. 98 Issue 5, p86 

    This article discusses an ongoing debate on whether water is a natural resource to be used to serve the public interest or a commercial product that can be purchased or sold. A model is described that brings together a respect for water and options for fair and efficient distribution to urban,...

  • Haryana may privatize water distribution.  // TIDEE (TERI Information Digest on Energy & Environment);Jun2008, Vol. 7 Issue 2, p182 

    The article reports that the government of Haryana, India is considering handing over the water treatment and distribution system to private companies. It references an article published in the April 2, 2008 issue of "Hindustan Times." According to the article, this move is aimed at assuring...

  • Sustaining water supply through a phased community management approach: lessons from Ghana's 'oats' water supply scheme. Opare, Service // Environment, Development & Sustainability;Dec2011, Vol. 13 Issue 6, p1021 

    Water sector reforms in Ghana and in other developing countries resulted in the adoption of the community management approach for water systems in an effort to ensure better management and service delivery. However, community management is also plagued internal differences, paucity of technical...

  • Discussion. BarraquĆ©, Bernard // Water Policy;2014, Vol. 16 Issue 2, p422 

    No abstract available.

  • Summary of the Discussion.  // OECD Journal of Competition Law & Policy;2006, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p107 

    The article discusses many aspects of competition and regulation in the water sector including its issues. According to chairman, Alberto Heimler, water is less likely to face a stiff competition. It is a common view that the various aspects of water supply are a natural monopoly. Information on...

  • Canada's Water Rights. Smith, Lewis V. // Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists;Apr1969, Vol. 25 Issue 4, p38 

    The article shares the author's contributions to the discussion of the North American Water and Power Alliance (NAWAPA) water scheme. The author said that Canada would have to oppose the scheme because it will split the country into two parts that would be almost impossible to join by rail or...

  • Water, Water Everywhere... Stryker, Rick // Camping Magazine;Sep/Oct2002, Vol. 75 Issue 5, p57 

    Looks at several basic design and operating parameters for small water systems. Pros and cons of having a public supply of water; Monitoring requirements for operating a community water supply; Ways that pressure can be supplied to the network.

  • 1/4 penny sales tax.  // Las Vegas Business Press;07/27/98, Vol. 15 Issue 30, Construction Connection p8 

    Focuses on the possible implementation of the 1/4 sales tax to pay for the water delivery system in Las Vegas, Nevada. Options for the 1/4 penny sales tax; Taxation of the tourists.

  • Locals call for federal support on water bill. Preston, Mark // American City & County;Apr2001, Vol. 116 Issue 5, p14 

    Deals with the appeal of city and county leaders to the United States Congress and President George W. Bush to pass a legislation that would provide funding for the nation's water systems. Water infrastructure needs in the country; Details of the legislation promoted by the Water Infrastructure...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics