Accountability sought by patients following adverse events from medical care: the New Zealand experience

Bismark, Marie; Dauer, Edward; Paterson, Ron; Studdert, David
October 2006
CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;10/10/2006, Vol. 175 Issue 8, p889
Academic Journal
Background: Unlike Canada's medical malpractice system, patients in New Zealand who are dissatisfied with the quality of their care may choose between 2 well-established medicolegal paths: one leads to monetary compensation and the other to nonmonetary forms of accountability. We compared the forms of accountability sought by patients and families in New Zealand who took different types of legal action following a medical injury. This study offers insights into the forms of accountability sought by injured patients and may help to inform tort-reform initiatives. Methods: We reviewed compensation claims submitted to the Accident Compensation Corporation (ACC), New Zealand's national no-fault insurer, following injuries associated with admission to a public hospital in 1998 (n= 582). We also reviewed complaint letters ( n= 254) submitted to the national Health and Disability Commissioner (HDC) that same year to determine the forms of accountability sought by injured patients. We used univariable and multivariable analyses to compare sociodemographic and socioeconomic characteristics of patients who sought nonmonetary forms of accountability with those of patients who claimed compensation. Results: Of 154 injured patients whose complaints were sufficiently detailed to allow coding, 50% sought corrective action to prevent similar harm to future patients (45% system change, 6% review of involved clinician's competence) and 40% wanted more satisfying communication (34% explanation, 10% apology). The odds that patients would seek compensation were significantly increased if they were in their prime working years (aged between 30 and 64 years) (odds ratio [OR] 1.66, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.14-2.41) or had a permanent disability as a result of their injury (OR 1.75, 95% CI 1.14-2.70). When injuries resulted in death, the odds of a compensation claim to the ACC were about one-eighth those of a complaint to the HDC (OR 0.13, 95% CI 0.08-0.23). Interpretation: Injured patients who pursue medicolegal action seek various forms of accountability. Compensation is important to some, especially when economic losses are substantial (e.g., with injury during prime working years or severe nonfatal injuries). However, others have purely nonmonetary goals, and ensuring alternative options for redress would be an efficient and effective response to their needs.


Related Articles

  • The Fault with 'No Fault'. Ford, Thomas A. // American Bar Association Journal;Sep75, Vol. 61 Issue 9, p1071 

    Comments on Jeffrey O'Connell's article, entitled `It's Time for No-Fault for All Kinds of Injuries,' published in the September 1974 issue of the `American Bar Association Journal'. O'Connell's proposal to extend the no-fault principles to injuries arising from products liability, medical...

  • REFORMING TORT LAW IN AUSTRALIA: A PERSONAL PERSPECTIVE. Cane, Peter // Melbourne University Law Review;2003, Vol. 27 Issue 3, p649 

    For 30 years Harold Luntz has been a major participant in personal injury law reform debates and a passionate advocate of the abolition of tort law and its replacement by a no-fault compensation scheme. The aim of this article is to place the 2002 Review of the Law of Negligence in the wider...

  • How about a no-fault medical malpractice act? Moore, W. Henson; Stieglitz, A. Blackwell; Gomez, Maria Isabel // ABA Journal;Jan1985, Vol. 71 Issue 1, p37 

    Discusses issues pertaining to the proposed Alternative Medical Liability Act in the United States which was introduced to create a no-fault system of compensating victims of medical malpractice. Provisions of the bills; Description of economic loss; Views from two lawyers on the merits and...

  • UNCOMPENSATED TORTS. Swedloff, Rick // Georgia State University Law Review;Spring2012, Vol. 28 Issue 3, p721 

    The article focuses on uncompensated torts and discusses the difficulties faced by the victims injured by intentional acts in receiving a remedy. It states that victims are not able to recover the damages mainly because they have few financial resources to aid them and offers solutions for...

  • Algunas consideraciones sobre la responsabilidad precontractual: una mirada a su regulación en Colombia, así como en otros países y la aplicación de la autonomía en negocios de ingeniería. Patricia Arias Henao, Diana; Enrique Arias Henao, Humberto // Tecnura;2012, Vol. 16 Issue 32, p143 

    The parties to a contract formation process should avoid causing any damage and if it happens, the party that violates the right of the other must compensate the injured party. In this article, the reader will find the most relevant aspects of the regulation of pre-contractual responsibility in...

  • Stranded on the Way to Scotland. Bratton, Conrad // Conde Nast Traveler;Feb2004, Vol. 39 Issue 2, p79 

    Provides a question and answer advisory on compensation for stranded travelers in the U.S. Compensations provided by airlines responsible for the delay; Total number of vouchers given to the stranded travelers; Experience of the stranded travelers.

  • Employers turn to state legislators for relief. Fletcher, Meg // Business Insurance;05/19/97, Vol. 31 Issue 20, p48 

    Reports that a controversial workers compensation provision may be resurrected and reinserted into the proposed Product Liability Reform Act of 1997, according to speculation by workers compensation analysts. What the provision dictates; Reason support of the provision is tendered; Opposition...

  • LIABILITY RULES, INSURANCE AND THE COASE THEOREM. McEwin, R. Ian // Australian Journal of Management (University of New South Wales);Dec81, Vol. 6 Issue 2, p103 

    Abstract: In the absence of any empirical evidence on the effect of liability laws,, major enquiries into accident prevention and compensation in the U.K., Australia and New Zealand in the last fifteen years have tended to discount the role of liability laws in deterring careless behaviour. The...

  • We live in a world where somebody has to be blamed for everything. Sowel, Thomas // Enterprise/Salt Lake City;05/31/99, Vol. 28 Issue 49, p22 

    Comments on the increasing efforts of lawyers, advocates and other people in the United States to find moneyed groups to blame for their ills and obtain money in the process. Success of states in getting money from the tobacco industry; Plan to sue manufacturers of firearms; Reason for the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics