Safety and Feasibility of Magnetic Seizure Therapy (MST) in Major Depression: Randomized Within-Subject Comparison with Electroconvulsive Therapy

Lisanby, Sarah H.; Luber, Bruce; Schlaepfer, Thomas E.; Sackeim, Harold A.
October 2003
Neuropsychopharmacology;Oct2003, Vol. 28 Issue 10, p1852
Academic Journal
Magnetic seizure therapy (MST) is a novel means of performing convulsive therapy using rapidly alternating strong magnetic fields. MST offers greater control of intracerebral current intensity than is possible with electroconvulsive therapy (ECT). These features may result in a superior cognitive side effect profile for MST, while possibly retaining the efficacy of ECT. The objective of this study was to determine whether MST and ECT differ in seizure characteristics, and acute objective and subjective cognitive side effects. A total of 10 inpatients in a major depressive episode referred for ECT were enrolled in this randomized, within-subject, double-masked trial. Seizure threshold was determined with MST and ECT in the first two sessions of a course of convulsive therapy, with order randomized. The remaining two sessions consisted of suprathreshold stimulation with MST and ECT. A neuropsychological battery and side effect rating scale were administered by a masked rater before and after each session. Tonic-clonic seizures were elicited with MST in all patients. Compared to ECT, MST seizures had shorter duration, lower ictal EEG amplitude, and less postictal suppression. Patients had fewer subjective side effects and recovered orientation more quickly with MST than ECT. MST was also superior to ECT on measures of attention, retrograde amnesia, and category fluency. Magnetic seizure induction in patients with depression is feasible, and appears to have a superior acute side effect profile than ECT. Future research will be needed to establish whether MST has antidepressant efficacy.


Related Articles

  • Can magnets ease severe depression? Williams, Stephen // Newsweek;9/21/1998, Vol. 132 Issue 12, p107 

    Mentions a therapy called transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) for the treatment of mental depression. How TMS is different from electroconvulsive therapy (ECT); Part of the brain receiving the current; Results of a study by University of Pennsylvania psychiatrist Martin Szuba; Projection of...

  • Electro-convulsive therapy with minimum hazard. Gordon, Douglas; Gordon, D // British Journal of Psychiatry;Jul82, Vol. 141, p12 

    The inter-electrode resistance during ECT is shown to be very variable, a finding which invalidates the measurement of shocks in joules. With square wave pulses of selected current value the threshold for convulsion may be below 100 milliamperes or above 2,000 milliamperes. It is advisable to...

  • EEG monitored ECT. Christensen, Peder; Koldbæk, Ib; Christensen, P; Koldbaek, I B // British Journal of Psychiatry;Jul82, Vol. 141, p19 

    EEG monitored ECT was administrated to 20 patients, 12 females and 8 males. One hundred and fifty-six treatments were given (mean 7.8 treatments/patient), and the relation between clinically observed seizures (COS) and the cerebral patterns of convulsions (EPC) was compared. If clinical...

  • Transcranial magnetic stimulation for patients with depression. Tredget, John; Kirov, George; Dunn, Emma // Nursing Standard;5/25/2005, Vol. 19 Issue 37, p49 

    Transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) is a relatively new technique which has been used to treat depression. I t delivers magnetic radiation to the head using a hand-held coil. Some studies have indicated clinical remission of depressive symptomatology with use of TMS. Methodological...

  • The onset and rate of the antidepressant effect of electroconvulsive therapy. A neglected topic of research. Scott, Allan I.F.; Whalley, Lawrence J.; Scott, A I; Whalley, L J // British Journal of Psychiatry;Jun93, Vol. 162, p725 

    The article discusses the lack of research about the onset and rate of the antidepressant effect of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) in Great Britain. The selection of depressed patients who will receive ECT and the recommended ECT practice have significantly changed. All depressed patients who...

  • Failure to convulse with electroconvulsive therapy. A case report. Sharpe, Michael; Andrew, Bernice; Sharpe, M; Andrew, B // British Journal of Psychiatry;Jan88, Vol. 152, p134 

    A case is reported of a severely depressed patient in whom treatment with electroconvulsive therapy was abandoned because of repeated failure to induce a convulsion. Reasons for the failure to convulse and alternative treatment approaches are discussed.

  • The effect of unilateral E.C.T. on schizophrenic delusions and hallucinations. El-Islam, M. Fakhr; Ahmed, Samia A.; Erfan, M. E.; el-Islam, M F; Ahmed, S A // British Journal of Psychiatry;Oct70, Vol. 117 Issue 539, p447 

    The present investigation studies the effect of unilateral electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) on schizophrenic delusions and hallucinations. 20 patients were treated with unilateral ECT and 21 patients had bilateral ECT. The study shows that the two groups of patients were comparable in their mean...

  • Unilateral versus bilateral ECT in schizophrenia. Doongaji, D. R.; Jeste, D. V.; Saoji, N. J.; Kane, P. V.; Ravindranath, S. // British Journal of Psychiatry;Jul73, Vol. 123 Issue 572, p73 

    The article presents a study on the therapeutic efficacy of unilateral electrode placement versus bilateral eletroconvulsive (ECT) therapy in schizophrenia. The study displays the comparative results in schizophrenia of bilaterally administered ECT and of ECT administered unilaterally to either...

  • Electroconvulsive therapy in the Republic of Ireland 1982: a summary of findings. Latey, R. H.; Fahy, T. J. // British Journal of Psychiatry;Oct85, Vol. 147, p438 

    The article presents a study on the efficiency of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) in Ireland. This study provides an evidence for the validity of the previous study's main findings. In this context, the author encountered wide inter-regional and wider inter-hospital variation in ECT rates. With...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics