The Changing Architecture of Advertising Agencies

July 2006
Marketing Science;Jul/Aug2006, Vol. 25 Issue 4, p367
Academic Journal
In contrast to other marketing activities, advertising is usually outsourced-historically, to an integrated full service advertising agency that provides both creative and media services. Recently, major changes have occurred, specialized media shops have appeared, and large holding companies with several agencies and a separate media shop have emerged. This paper describes how firms in the current industry structure choose their agents. A theoretical section specifies the firm's decision process in obtaining the creative and media components. Conditions under which one or both could be effectively produced internally are identified. In the prevalent case when these components are outsourced, we evaluate whether they can be more efficiently produced by a bundled full-service agency or by unbundling to separate agents. An empirical section tests the theory implications with cross-sectional data on U.S. firm choices of advertising agents. The bundled full-service agency is still widely used. Firms with large advertising budgets unbundle to take advantage of media discounts obtained by market-making media shops. Internal agencies are used when firms have internal creative abilities, or have low-level requirements in both creative and media. The creative and media agencies within holding companies are found to act independently.


Related Articles

  • How creatives can gain value.  // Marketing (00253650);3/28/2002, p17 

    Comments on the creativity of advertising agencies for satisfaction of clients needs in Great Britain. Lack of creative understanding by senior marketers; View on the criticisms of Carol Fisher on the issue of creativity for marketing; Need to realize the creative integrity and freedom from...

  • Creativity in digital goes way beyond advertising. Nutley, Michael // New Media Age;11/4/2010, p5 

    In the article, the author discusses the importance of creativity in the success of interactive agencies in Great Britain as shown in the success of such agencies in Brazil.

  • Up With People. Levine, Harold // Adweek New England Edition;9/3/2001, Vol. 38 Issue 36, p12 

    Discusses the importance of retaining the personal identity of an advertising agency. Impact of the emphasis on the corporate holding company of an agency on its creative output; Significance of corporate leadership in promoting creativity; Importance of making advertising a personal-service...

  • Creative eclipse. Tilles, Daniel // Adweek New England Edition;09/08/97, Vol. 34 Issue 36, p29 

    Recognizes the creativity of the advertising agencies in France. Success of French advertisers in creative competitions; Influence of economic and social climate; Traditional values of French advertising.

  • Creative eclipse. Tilles, Daniel // Adweek Midwest Edition;09/08/97, Vol. 38 Issue 36, p29 

    Recognizes the creativity of the advertising agencies in France. Success of French advertisers in creative competitions; Influence of economic and social climate; Traditional value of French advertising.

  • NOTHING IS DEAD, NOTHING IS THE FUTURE. Rasic, Dejan // B&T Magazine;5/13/2011, Vol. 61 Issue 2741, p10 

    The article focuses on the need for advertising agencies to constantly reinvent their concepts and ideas.

  • Whatever's clever is never enough. Osterman, Jim // Adweek Western Edition;10/25/93, Vol. 43 Issue 43, p54 

    Editorial. Comments on creativity as a measure of the quality of a work an agency does for its clients, not project work, pro bono or other creative exercises. Reputation in the advertising business on the strength of work quality.

  • Clients are welcome in Cannes as long as they bring creativity. Senior, Robert // Campaign;7/2/2010, Issue 26, p24 

    In this article, the author discusses the aspect that advertising agencies can join Cannes Lions International Advertising Festival as long as there is creativity.

  • ON THE CREATIVE FLOOR WIEDEN & KENNEDY. Davidson, Tony // Campaign;5/20/2011, Issue 20, p32 

    The author explains the unconventional artistry of the members of advertising agency Wieden & Kennedy where there is no meeting rooms nor conference hals but rather a place where everyone can comment on another's work to achieve great creativity.


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics