Benoit, William L.; Sheafer, Tamir
June 2006
Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly;Summer2006, Vol. 83 Issue 2, p281
Academic Journal
This study applied functional theory, developed for political campaigns in the United States, to six televised debates in Israel and compared debates in both countries. In both countries, acclaims were the most common function, followed by attacks and then defenses. Policy was addressed more often than character. Incumbent candidates in both countries acclaimed significantly more and attacked less than the challengers. Incumbents used past deeds significantly more often to acclaim—and less to attack—than the challengers. The similarities discovered suggest that candidates for elective political office may employ common discursive practices that transcend national borders.


Related Articles

  • WINSTON-SALEM JOURNAL.  // Hill;5/17/2007, Vol. 14 Issue 59, p16 

    The author reflects on the resurrection of an old campaign idea of dedicating nine Sundays in fall 2008 for the debate of two major party nominees in the U.S. This campaign was proposed by House Speaker Newt Gingrich. Marvin Kalb argued that the public deserves more thoughtful discussion of the...

  • Determinants of Defense in Presidential Debates. Benoit, William L. // Communication Research Reports;Nov2007, Vol. 24 Issue 4, p319 

    This study investigates the relationship between attacks and defenses in political debates. Being the target of an attack provides a candidate with opportunity and motivation to defend; hence, the frequency of attacks directed toward a candidate should be directly related to the number of...

  • Nothing Is True. Hume, Brit // Extra! Update;Dec2006, p2 

    The article offers information about the author's views on negative political advertising. The author holds that he does not like the idea that the mass media is policing the truthfulness of political campaigns. The author believes that political advertisements are arguably true and arguably...

  • New vogue of voluntarism.  // America;6/13/1953, Vol. 89 Issue 11, p294 

    The article presents comments on an art of political debate which is the dodge of diverting the attention from what an opponent said to the person who mentioned about it. It claims that instead of analyzing a man's argument, people tend to prove, that certain person could not say anything...

  • Getting Youth to Vote: Is It Rocking the Boat? Hiscock, Donald // Community College Week;10/25/2004, Vol. 17 Issue 6, p4 

    Deals with the need for educators to enlighten the awareness of the youth about political participation and political issues. Questions to consider when planning for a political debate in the classroom; Opportunities that have been left behind which make the youth a deeply cautious and...

  • Get people back to power. Kennedy, Helena // New Statesman;11/8/2004, Vol. 133 Issue 4713, p32 

    Focuses on the lack of interest of Britons in engaging with politics. Claim that the British government wields unchecked power with insufficient challenge from the public; Statement that low general-election voter turnouts have coincided with large street demonstrations; Dichotomy between Great...

  • Why I Study Public Deliberation. Gastil, John // International Journal of Public Participation;2014 Special Issue, Vol. 10 Issue 1, preceding p1 

    The author argues that scholars can best advance public dialogue and deliberation by conducting systematic research on practical innovations that have the potential to improve political discourse. The author explains and justifies this position through a personal narrative that recounts...

  • THE 1984 DEMOCHATIC DEBATES: DOES FORMAT MAKE A DIFFERENCE? Rowland, Robert C.; Garcia, Rey // Conference Proceedings -- National Communication Association/Ame;1985 Argument & Social Practice, p219 

    The article presents an essay on how the format of the 1984 Democratic primary debates in the U. S. can improve or harm the quality of debating. The interactive format allows the coverage of more issues but the said issues are not covered in detail. In the interactive format, the candidates are...

  • A Functional Analysis of 2004 Ukrainian Presidential Debates. Benoit, William L.; Klyukovski, Andrew // Argumentation;2006, Vol. 20 Issue 2, p209 

    Political leaders’ debates are an important and highly visible instances of public argumentation. As such, they merit scholarly attention. This essay applies the Functional Theory of Political Campaign Discourse to analyze televised presidential debates from the Ukraine in 2004. Overall,...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics