Crump, Kenny S.
October 2005
Dose-Response;2005, Vol. 3 Issue 4, p456
Academic Journal
Although statistical analyses of epidemiological data usually treat the exposure variable as being known without error, estimated exposures in epidemiological studies often involve considerable uncertainty. This paper investigates the theoretical effect of random errors in exposure measurement upon the observed shape of the exposure response. The model utilized assumes that true exposures are log-normally distributed, and multiplicative measurement errors are also log-normally distributed and independent of the true exposures. Under these conditions it is shown that whenever the true exposure response is proportional to exposure to a power r, the observed exposure response is proportional to exposure to a power K, where K < r. This implies that the observed exposure response exaggerates risk, and by arbitrarily large amounts, at sufficiently small exposures. It also follows that a truly linear exposure response will appear to be supra-linear--i.e., a linear function of exposure raised to the K-th power, where K is less than 1.0. These conclusions hold generally under the stated log-normal assumptions whenever there is any amount of measurement error, including, in particular, when the measurement error is unbiased either in the natural or log scales. Equations are provided that express the observed exposure response in terms of the parameters of the underlying log-normal distribution. A limited investigation suggests that these conclusions do not depend upon the log-normal assumptions, but hold more widely. Because of this problem, in addition to other problems in exposure measurement, shapes of exposure responses derived empirically from epidemiological data should be treated very cautiously. In particular, one should be cautious in concluding that the true exposure response is supra-linear on the basis of an observed supra-linear form.


Related Articles

  • Appraising the evidence: what is measurement bias? Page, Lisa A.; Henderson, Max // Evidence Based Mental Health;May2008, Vol. 11 Issue 2, p36 

    The article discusses measurement bias, one of the mayor types of systematic error commonly encountered in epidemiological research. Some general points about bias are it may be introduced by poor study design or poor data collection and it can lead to an over or under-estimation of an effect....

  • Measurement issues in environmental epidemiology Thomas, D.; Hatch, M. // Environmental Health Perspectives Supplements;1993 Supplement 4, Vol. 101, p49 

    No abstract available.

  • Adjusted regression estimation for time-to-event data with differential measurement error. Yu, Menggang // Biometrika;Sep2013, Vol. 100 Issue 3, p757 

    Differential measurement error data plausibly arise in epidemiology and biomedical studies but have been rarely dealt with explicitly, especially for time-to-event data. We propose an estimation equation correction method in semiparametric censored linear regression to deal with differential...

  • Measurement Error and Misclassification in Statistics and Epidemiology: Impacts and Bayesian Adjustments. Levy, Paul S. // American Journal of Epidemiology;May2004, Vol. 159 Issue 9, p911 

    The article reviews the book "Measurement Error and Misclassification in Statistics and Epidemiology: Impacts and Bayesian Adjustments," by Paul Gustafson.

  • A SPECTRAL REGULARIZATION METHOD FOR A HEAT EQUATION BACKWARD IN TIME ON THE PLANE. Nguyen Huy Tuan; Pham Hoang Quan // ROMAI Journal;Jun2011, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p171 

    For a two-dimensional heat conduction problem on the plane, we consider its initial boundary value problem and the related inverse problem of determining the initial temperature distribution from transient temperature measurements. The stability for this inverse problem and the error analysis...

  • Statistical inference for partially linear regression models with measurement errors. Jinhong You; Qinfeng Xu; Bin Zhou // Chinese Annals of Mathematics;Apr2008, Vol. 29 Issue 2, p207 

    In this paper, the authors investigate three aspects of statistical inference for the partially linear regression models where some covariates are measured with errors. Firstly, a bandwidth selection procedure is proposed, which is a combination of the difference-based technique and GCV method....

  • Least-MSE calibration procedures for corrections of measurement and misclassification errors in generalized linear models. Wattanasaruch, Parnchit; Pongsapukdee, Veeranun; Khawsithiwong, Pairoj // Songklanakarin Journal of Science & Technology;Jul-Aug2012, Vol. 34 Issue 4, p467 

    The analyses of clinical and epidemiologic studies are often based on some kind of regression analysis, mainly linear regression and logistic models. These analyses are often affected by the fact that one or more of the predictors are measured with error. The error in the predictors is also...

  • Reporting Bias of Dampness Problems and Smoking--A Result of Study Design. Knutz, Malin; Engman, Linda Hägerhed; Gustavsson, Thorbjörn; Von Kobyletzki, Laura; Bornehag, Carl-Gustaf // Open Journal of Preventive Medicine;Mar2014, Vol. 4 Issue 3, p107 

    Using questionnaire is a common, efficient and cheap way to collect data in population-based epidemiological studies. However, there is a general trend of declining response rates leading to a higher risk for bias affecting the validity of results. Use of anonymous questionnaires and/or other...

  • Implications of a New Dietary Measurement Error Model for Estimation of Relative Risk: Application to Four Calibration Studies. Kipnis, Victor; Carroll, Raymond J.; Freedman, Laurence S.; Li, Li // American Journal of Epidemiology;1999, Vol. 150 Issue 6, p642 

    Food records or 24-hour recalls are currently used to calibrate food frequency questionnaires (FFQs) and to correct disease risks for measurement error. The standard regression calibration approach requires that these reference measures contain only random within-person errors uncorrelated with...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics