Behind make or buy decisions in export strategy: A replication and extension of Trabold

Peng, Mike W.; Zhou, Yuanyuan; York, Anne S.
September 2006
Journal of World Business;Sep2006, Vol. 41 Issue 3, p289
Academic Journal
Abstract: Given the centrality of make or buy decisions in transaction cost theory, it is important to understand the factors that influence managers’ choices. The empirical evidence to date is unclear as to what conditions influence export managers’ choices to “make” (the direct mode of establishing in-house export channels) versus “buy” (the indirect mode of outsourcing certain services to intermediaries). Peng and Ilinitch [Peng, M. W., & Ilinitch, A. Y. (1998). Export intermediary firms: A note on export development research. Journal of International Business Studies, 29(3): 609–620] propose a transaction cost-based theory of export intermediation. They suggest that market distance and product complexity are the two primary driving forces behind exporters’ decision to “buy” by engaging export intermediary firms. Their hypotheses have been tested and partially supported by Trabold [Trabold, H. (2002). Export intermediation: An empirical test of Peng and Ilinitch. Journal of International Business Studies, 33(2): 327–344] based on French data. Using a new archival database covering 185,731 export transactions over a two-year period, we replicated Trabold''s work using U.S. firm data. Our findings are similar. This strengthens the reliability and validity of Peng and Ilinitch''s theory as well as the generalizability of Trabold''s findings to a more global context. Overall, given both the importance and paucity of replication work in the strategy literature, this study serves as an example of how export strategy research can advance through cumulative empirical efforts.


Related Articles

  • CHARACTERISTICS OF IMMIGRANTS AND BILATERAL TRADE. Blanes-Cristóbal, José Vicente // Revista de Economía Aplicada;2008, Vol. 16 Issue 48, p133 

    This paper tests the impact of immigration on bilateral trade using Spanish data from 1995 to 2003. It also explores some possible mechanisms behind this link. It uses a gravity equation for trade augmented with an immigrant's stock variable and a set of control variables. The immigrants...

  • What credit managers should know about break-even analysis. Dennis, Michael C. // Business Credit;Feb95, Vol. 97 Issue 2, p6 

    Focuses on the need for credit managers to understand the concept of break-even point analysis. Importance of calculating a company's break-even point; Steps on how to calculate break-even points; Formula for break-even analysis.

  • Perspectives on time-to-market. Kemtovicz, Ron // Electronic Design;8/22/94, Vol. 42 Issue 17, p106 

    Reports that a break-even time (BET) chart on a new product is easily forgotten. Reasons for the effect; Accuracy of forecasting; Extracting maximum benefit from the BET chart; Placing competitive information on the chart.

  • ANOTHER WAY TO BUY. Barton, Tim // Overdrive;Jul2003, Vol. 43 Issue 7, p28 

    Discusses factors to be considered when planning to buy trucks through lease-purchase plans in the U.S. High interest rates; Payment of insurance; Potential equity built through a lease-purchase plan. INSETS: TO BUY OR LEASE-PURCHASE?;KNOW YOUR CONTRACT.

  • Sale/leaseback deals gain momentum but what does it mean in a securitization?  // Asset Securitization Report;5/27/2002, Vol. 2 Issue 21, p16 

    Focuses on the effect of credit market deterioration on sale/leaseback transactions. Significance of terms of the operating lease; Implication of deterioration for securitization; Citation of operating lease rental as an operating cost.

  • The basics of lease vs. buy analysis. Duncan Jr., Homer G.; Proctor, Richard E. // Business North Carolina;Jan97 Supplement, Vol. 17 Issue 1, p10 

    Offers tips for lease or buy decisions for businesses and individuals. Identification of objects; Consideration of leasing alternatives; Understanding of rights and responsibilities regarding basic terms of leasing and purchasing; Steps to measure economic effects.

  • Casino applicants buy Greektown car garage. Cantwell, Julie // Crain's Detroit Business;02/24/97, Vol. 13 Issue 8, p17 

    Reports on the acquisition of a parking garage from the Downtown Development Authority by the casino, Greektown developers. Value of the purchase; Information on Primadonna Resorts Incorporated's efforts at obtaining three licenses in Detroit.

  • The leverage of leasing. Brookman, Jerome J. // American Salesman;Sep95, Vol. 40 Issue 9, p21 

    Discusses leasing of equipment and space as a means of corporate financing. Cost analysis of buy or lease decisions; Advantages of leasing equipment.

  • Your money. Blue, Ronald // Marriage Partnership;Spring93, Vol. 10 Issue 2, p68 

    Answers a question on whether to buy or rent a home. Factors that make renting a home a better alternative; Factors that make buying a better alternative; Arguments in favor of one alternative over the other.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics