TITLE

Structure: Its Shadow and Substance

AUTHOR(S)
Van Fraassen, Bas C.
PUB. DATE
June 2006
SOURCE
British Journal for the Philosophy of Science;Jun2006, Vol. 57 Issue 2, p275
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
Structural realism as developed by John Worrall and others can claim philosophical roots as far back as the late 19th century, though the discussion at that time does not unambiguously favor the contemporary form, or even its realism. After a critical examination of some aspects of the historical background some severe critical challenges to both Worrall's and Ladyman's versions are highlighted, and an alternative empiricist structuralism proposed. Support for this empiricist version is provided in part by the different way in which we can do justice to Worrall's original demands and in part by the viewpoint it provides (in contrast to e.g. Michael Friedman's) on the stability maintained through scientific theory change.
ACCESSION #
21810240

 

Related Articles

  • Reconsidering Structural Realism. McArthur, Dan // Canadian Journal of Philosophy;Dec2003, Vol. 33 Issue 4, p517 

    Examines arguments for and against structural realism made by John Worrall and Stathis Psillos. Overview of structural realism; Outline of cases for and against structural realism; Re-examination of main scientific example that is the locus of debate for both Worrall and Psillos.

  • Structural realism and Davidson. Jack Ritchie // Synthese;May2008, Vol. 162 Issue 1, p85 

    Abstract  Structural realism is an attempt to balance the competing demands of the No Miracles Argument and the Pessimistic Meta-Induction. In this paper I trace the development of the structuralist idea through the work of one of its leading advocates, John Worrall. I suggest that...

  • Hacia una ontología sin objetos: una defensa del realismo estructural óntico en el nivel metodológico. Borge, Bruno José // Filosofia UNISINOS;jan-Apr2013, Vol. 14 Issue 1, p45 

    In the context of contemporary debates on scientific realism, structural realism (SR), explicitly introduced by John Worrall (1989), has shown to be one of the most vigorous philosophical proposals. It suggests that the knowledge that science has given us along its history is about the structure...

  • Background of Literary realism and its species in fiction of the world and Iran. Rahmani, Qumars // Journal of Applied Sciences Research;Apr2014, Vol. 10 Issue 4, p230 

    Realism in a general sense to mean a fundamental interest in the same subject is out of mind and has long preoccupied human thought. Aristotle on the art of poetry, artwork Mimesis is known of the nature. After him; always this thought continued with the ups and downs. Until in the nineteenth...

  • TWO DOGMAS OF STRUCTURAL REALISM. A CONFIRMATION OF A PHILOSOPHICAL DEATH FORETOLD. RIVADULLA, ANDRÉS // Crítica;abr2010, Vol. 42 Issue 124, p3 

    Twenty years ago John Worrall offered an alleged non-standard viable form of scientific realism under the name structural realism. Structural realism was supposed to be both an alternative to standard scientific realism and a viable form of realism. The central questions addressed in this paper...

  • Is it time to get real? Scerri, Eric // New Scientist;11/24/2012, Vol. 216 Issue 2892, p30 

    The author compares at the realism and anti-realism approaches to science. The theory of structural realism developed by science philosopher John Worrall asserts that changes in scientific theories over time are attributed to structure, or form, not content. The author argues that structural...

  • Structuralism and Representation Theorems†. WEAVER, GEORGE // Philosophia Mathematica;Sep1998, Vol. 6 Issue 3, p257 

    Much of the inspiration for structuralist approaches to mathematics can be found in the late nineteenth- and early twentieth-century program of characterizing various mathematical systems upto isomorphism. From the perspective of this program, differences between isomorphic systems are...

  • GÄ°RESUN YAÄžLIDERE TEKKE KÖYÃœ CAMÄ° KALEM İŞİ BEZEMELERÄ°. TALİ, Şerife // Journal of International Social Research;2014, Vol. 7 Issue 31, p403 

    In this study, mural paintings of a mosque was investigated which is in Giresun City, Yağlıdere district, Tekke village. Properties of the pencil-work paintings are examined and evaluated in terms of the technic and composition. Sanctuary walls of the Tekke Village Mosque is ornamented by...

  • Identifying the Other. MEHEDINŢI, MIHAELA // Transylvanian Review;2013 Supplement 3, Vol. 22, p249 

    Travellers who passed through Transylvania in the first half of the 19th century discovered a multicultural province, inhabited by several ethnicities. Amongst these, the Hungarians, the Szeklers and the Saxons drew their attention due to their political status and privileges, while the...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics