Using the Bootstrap Method for a Statistical Significance Test of Differences between Summary Histograms

Kuan-Man Xu
May 2006
Monthly Weather Review;May2006, Vol. 134 Issue 5, p1442
Academic Journal
A new method is proposed to compare statistical differences between summary histograms, which are the histograms summed over a large ensemble of individual histograms. It consists of choosing a distance statistic for measuring the difference between summary histograms and using a bootstrap procedure to calculate the statistical significance level. Bootstrapping is an approach to statistical inference that makes few assumptions about the underlying probability distribution that describes the data. Three distance statistics are compared in this study. They are the Euclidean distance, the Jeffries–Matusita distance, and the Kuiper distance. The data used in testing the bootstrap method are satellite measurements of cloud systems called “cloud objects.” Each cloud object is defined as a contiguous region/patch composed of individual footprints or fields of view. A histogram of measured values over footprints is generated for each parameter of each cloud object, and then summary histograms are accumulated over all individual histograms in a given cloud-object size category. The results of statistical hypothesis tests using all three distances as test statistics are generally similar, indicating the validity of the proposed method. The Euclidean distance is determined to be most suitable after comparing the statistical tests of several parameters with distinct probability distributions among three cloud-object size categories. Impacts on the statistical significance levels resulting from differences in the total lengths of satellite footprint data between two size categories are also discussed.


Related Articles

  • Statistical Significance Tests: Equivalence and Reverse Tests Should Reduce Misinterpretation. Parkhurst, David F. // BioScience;Dec2001, Vol. 51 Issue 12, p1051 

    Focuses on situations in which significance tests are used and a null hypothesis is not rejected, and the problem of interpreting the result as providing evidence for the null hypothesis without a logical basis. Description of a method for looking at data statistically but with different null...

  • Vertical Structures of Anvil Clouds of Tropical Mesoscale Convective Systems Observed by CloudSat. Yuan, Jian; Houze, Robert A.; Heymsfield, Andrew J. // Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences;Aug2011, Vol. 68 Issue 8, p1653 

    A global study of the vertical structures of the clouds of tropical mesoscale convective systems (MCSs) has been carried out with data from the CloudSat Cloud Profiling Radar. Tropical MCSs are found to be dominated by cloud-top heights greater than 10 km. Secondary cloud layers sometimes occur...

  • A STUDY OF THE HARTMAN-WATSON DISTRIBUTION MOTIVATED BY NUMERICAL PROBLEMS RELATED TO THE PRICING OF ASIAN OPTIONS. Barrieu, P.; Rouault, A.; Yor, M. // Journal of Applied Probability;Dec2004, Vol. 41 Issue 4, p1049 

    One approach to the computation of the price of an Asian option involves the Hartman- Watson distribution. However, numerical problems for its density occur for small values. This motivates the asymptotic study of its distribution function.

  • A test of fit for a semiparametric additive risk model. YUEN, K. C.; BURKE, M. D. // Biometrika;1997, Vol. 84 Issue 3, p631 

    Kolmogorov-Smirnov and Cramér-von Mises type test statistics based on the standardised cumulative hazard process are proposed. It is very difficult to evaluate their asymptotic distributions, but they can be approximated by the use of the bootstrap. The advantages of the goodness-of-fit test...

  • Statistical tests for limit value transgression–how to deliver unambiguous results. Molt, Karl; Einax, Jürgen W.; Winterstein, Michael // Analytical & Bioanalytical Chemistry;Nov2009, Vol. 395 Issue 6, p1577 

    The article discusses the use of statistical tests for limit value transgression. Statistical tests can be applied to unobjectionably and reproducibly justify a decision on whether a limit value has been violated or seen, and on the other hand to calculate the analytical effort needed to get...

  • Analysis of Markov Model of Slotted ALOHA Protocol in Satellite Communication. Belattar, M.; Benatia, D.; Benslama, M. // International Review of Aerospace Engineering;Jun2010, Vol. 3 Issue 3, p134 

    In this paper we propose a study based on the model of Markov chain, to define optimal binomial distribution probabilities of retransmission and arrival packets, in the case of random multiple access protocol (slotted Aloha), to describe their evolution in function of the number of transmissions...

  • Double block bootstrap confidence intervals for dependent data. Stephen M. S. Lee; P. Y. Lai // Biometrika;Jun2009, Vol. 96 Issue 2, p427 

    The block bootstrap confidence interval for dependent data can outperform the conventional normal approximation only with nontrivial studentization which, in the case of complicated statistics, calls for specialist treatment and often results in unstable endpoints. We propose two double block...

  • contingency table.  // Hutchinson Dictionary of Scientific Biography;2005, p1 

    Table listing information classified as variable according to two or more independent attributes. Such tables are used commonly in commerce, notably by insurance companies.

  • Multiple comparisons distortions of parameter estimates. Neal O. Jeffries // Biostatistics;Apr2007, Vol. 8 Issue 2, p500 

    In experiments involving many variables, investigators typically use multiple comparisons procedures to determine differences that are unlikely to be the result of chance. However, investigators rarely consider how the magnitude of the greatest observed effect sizes may have been subject to bias...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics