Observing and Interpreting Teaching-Learning Processes: Novice PETE Students, Experienced PETE Students, and Expert Teacher Educators

Graham, Kathy C.; French, Karen E.; Woods, Amelia M.
October 1993
Journal of Teaching in Physical Education;Oct1993, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p46
Academic Journal
The ability to observe and interpret events during instruction is thought to be an important dimension of effective teachers. The purpose of this study was to compare the ability to observe and interpret teaching physical education at different stages of expertise. Ten freshman preservice students, 7 experienced junior students, and 2 teacher educators served as subjects. Each subject viewed a 15-minute videotaped lesson on basketball dribbling taught to approximately 20 third-grade students. Subjects were instructed to observe the lesson, take notes, and write a description or evaluation of what they observed during the lesson. Experienced students wrote substantially more evaluative interpretations than novice preservice students. The interpretations of the experienced preservice students were similar to the teacher educators in the focus of observation and the use of a technical language. However, teacher educators' interpretations were more organized and were focused more on lesson occurrences that influenced students' motor-skill performance.


Related Articles

  • Defining and Assessing College Teaching--Diagnosis and Prognosis: A Message From the Guest Editor. Theall, Michael // Journal on Excellence in College Teaching;2012, Vol. 23 Issue 1, p1 

    The article discusses various reports published within the issue, including one by Audrey Amrein-Beardsley and Thomas Haladyna on evaluating teaching by considering students ratings of instruction, another by Jana Hunzicker and Twila Lukowiak which explored the use of an instructional practices...

  • Physical Education Teachers of the Year. De Marco Jr., George Mario Paul // Teaching Elementary Physical Education;Mar99, Vol. 10 Issue 2, p11 

    Gives examples of characteristics and instructional behavior of exemplary physical education teachers. Possession of extensive content and pedagogical content knowledge acquired over the years; Exhibition of automaticity and fluidity in teaching behavior; Ability to respond to contingent...

  • Developing a Statistically Valid AND Practically Useful Student Evaluation Instrument. Skowronek, Jeffrey; Friesen, Bruce; Masonjones, Heather // International Journal for the Scholarship of Teaching & Learning;2011, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p1 

    The current article presents the findings on the development of a student evaluation instrument in which course evaluation is directly tied to student learning outcomes. With a committee consisting of instructors from six distinct disciplines brought together as part of a working group for this...

  • Enhancing Teaching & Learning: Analysis of Module and End-of-Course Narratives. Gilpin, Lorraine S. // MountainRise;Spring2013, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p1 

    Purposes of student evaluations include measuring teaching effectiveness and helping teachers improve teaching (Lang & Kersting, 2006). Improvement of teaching and learning is the core of SoTL (Huber & Morreale, 2002). This study reflects Lewis' (1991) assertion that, when qualitatively...

  • Texas Board Weighs Plan Reducing Use of State Student Assessments.  // Education Week;1/22/1992, Vol. 11 Issue 18, p2 

    The article reports on the plan of the state board to reform the standardized testing system and reduce the number of hours that the students spend on state assessment in Texas. The planned changes on the average number of testing hours for students was mentioned. Details on the test expansion...

  • ACADEMIC LEARNING TIME IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOL MOVEMENT EDUCATION: A DESCRIPTIVE ANALYTIC STUDY. Shute, Shirley; Dodds, Patt; Placek, Judith H.; Rife, Frank; Silverman, Stephen // Journal of Teaching in Physical Education;Winter1982, Vol. 1 Issue 2, p3 

    This article discusses the questionable effectiveness and methodology of the education that students receive in physical education courses. The article discusses several methods to measure that education including a teaching model called "process-product," which investigates the relationship...

  • The Oppositional Child: Strategies That Work.  // Educational Leadership;Oct2012, Vol. 70 Issue 2, p20 

    The article discusses ways for teachers to effectively manage disruptive behavior in students who are prone to oppositional behavior, focusing on strategies that accommodate students' learning styles, facilitate teacher-student communication, and respond to opposition by setting consequences.

  • The Many Uses of Exit Slips. Marzano, Robert J. // Educational Leadership;Oct2012, Vol. 70 Issue 2, p80 

    The article examines the educational value of using exit slips, or students' personal responses to a lesson. It covers several types of prompts that teachers can use when asking students to write exit slips, such as prompts that provide formative assessment data, prompts that stimulate student...

  • Evaluating Teaching Effectiveness in a Quantity Food Laboratory Settings Phase Three Student Feedback. Weber, Mel; Chandler, James A.; Finley, Dori A. // Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Education;2006, Vol. 18 Issue 2, p28 

    The findings described in this manuscript represent the third phase in an ongoing project that began in 2003. In phase one of the project, the researchers developed a student evaluation tool (SET) for evaluating teaching effectiveness in a quantity foods laboratory taught at four- year...


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics