The Orthodoxy in RT-PE and the Research/Practice Gap: A Critique and an Alternative View

Kirk, David
January 1989
Journal of Teaching in Physical Education;Jan1989, Vol. 8 Issue 2, p123
Academic Journal
In this paper I argue that there is currently an orthodoxy in RT-PE that is unable, through its present epistemologies and methods, to make a major impact on curriculum practice. Three particular issues are highlighted as problematic: strategies for change adopted within the orthodoxy, who has the power to define and legitimate the research agenda, and an apolitical view of change. In presenting an alternative view of how we might close the research/practice gap in RT-PE, I suggest that researchers must develop more democratic approaches to working with teachers, for example along the lines of the teacher-as-researcher movement rather than on them. I also argue that in order to do this, we must develop more appropriate research epistemologies and methodologies. Finally, these two developments must be framed within a more sophisticated and systematically developed understanding of the social change process, and of the political nature of our attempts as educators to bring about change.


Related Articles

  • Evolución de las relaciones entre la epistemología y la metodología de la investigación. Cazau, Pablo // Paradigmas;jul-dic2011, Vol. 3 Issue 2, p109 

    Epistemology and methodology are two areas of knowledge that tend to be considered jointly, although on occasion they are presented as if they were different separate fields. This paper offers elements, some historical, for reflection on the relationship between these two disciplines, on which...

  • Las reformas en la historia del currículo en Venezuela (El proceso de implantación de la Educación Básica 1980-1998). Mora-García, José Pascual // Revista Historia de la Educación Latinoamericana;jul-dic2013, Vol. 15 Issue 21, p51 

    The approaching to the curriculum as a topic of research linked to the social history of the curriculum goes through a preliminary look of epistemological status. The epistemological approach of the curriculum history must transcend the equal view of the discipline that abounded in the schools...

  • The Dialectic of the General and Particular in Social Science Research and Teaching Praxis. Roth, Wolff-Michael // Forum: Qualitative Social Research;2003, Vol. 4 Issue 2, p32 

    Cross-Cultural Research Methods pretends to be a primer on the "how to" of conducting cross-cultural research, but focuses only on quantitative methods that use secondary data in the service of generating knowledge. The book is caught twice in the dialectic of the general and the specific, by...

  • A Paradigm Analysis of Arts-Based Research and Implications for Education. ROLLING JR., JAMES HAYWOOD // Studies in Art Education;Winter2010, Vol. 51 Issue 2, p102 

    This article represents a paradigm analysis of the characteristics of arts-based research (ABR) in an effort to reconceptualize the potential of arts-based practices in generating new curriculum approaches for general education practice and the development of the learner. Arts-based theoretical...

  • Nudging toward Inquiry: Re-Envisioning the Animal Report.  // School Library Monthly;Dec2009, Vol. 26 Issue 4, p5 

    The article presents the teachers' ways of re-envisioning research projects to enhance student learning with emphasis on animal reports. It focuses on the teacher challenge for innovative curricular design to move students toward inquiry and critical thinking. It explores the responses of...

  • Teaching for understanding--within and across the disciplines. Gardner, Howard; Boix-Mansilla, Veronica // Educational Leadership;Feb1994, Vol. 51 Issue 5, p14 

    Describes methods of teaching for understanding within and across disciplines. Disciplines as the most useful means for illuminating issues that engages the curiosity of human beings; Application of the four-part framework developed by the Teaching for Understanding Project; Link of common...

  • A Conceptual Model for Curriculum Planning and Evaluation in the Visual Arts. Detmers, William R. // Studies in Art Education;1980, Vol. 21 Issue 2, p57 

    The article focuses on a conceptual model for curriculum planning and evaluation in the visual arts. It notes that many art educators believe that curriculum schemes that are used in general education lack adaptability to the visual arts. It informed that five types of content for devising this...

  • "I Follow the Blue..." A Primary Teacher and the Impact of Packaged Curricula. Crawford, Patricia // Early Childhood Education Journal;Dec2004, Vol. 32 Issue 3, p205 

    In the primary grades, literacy teachers often face dual and competing challenges. On one hand, they are expected to provide developmentally appropriate practice in a contextually-sensitive manner. On the other hand, they are often charged with using packaged literacy curricula that contains...

  • Reflexões teóricas sobre a construção do conhecimento pedagógico do conteúdo dos futuros professores. Marcon, Daniel; Dos Santos Graça, Amândio Braga; Vieira Do Nascimento, Juarez // Revista Educação: Teoria e Prática;jan-abr2012, Issue 39, p16 

    The pedagogical content knowledge (PCK) is used by the teacher to transform his/her knowledge about the content in knowledge comprehensible and teachable for students. For the construction of PCK, literature indicates that prospective teachers should come across to issues inherent to carrying...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics