Evaluation of Stigmatizing Language and Medical Errors in Neurology Coverage by US Newspapers

Caspermeyer, Joseph J.; Sylvester, Edward J.; Drazkowski, Joseph F.; Watson, George L.; Sirven, Joseph I.
March 2006
Mayo Clinic Proceedings;Mar2006, Vol. 81 Issue 3, p300
Academic Journal
OBJECTIVES: To analyze US newspaper coverage of neurologic diseases to determine whether stigmatizing language is used in describing patients and examine its sources where found and to examine stories for medical errors. METHODS: A content analysis of newspaper articles was performed for 2003 using the Lexls-Nexls database. Keyword searches for 11 common neurologic conditions were performed for The New York Times and 8 regional newspapers with circulation greater than 200,000. RESULTS: A total of 1203 stories focusing on 11 neurologic conditions were recovered. Newspaper coverage did not reflect disease prevalence (rank correlation, p=-0.009; P=.98). The topics most covered were Alzheimer disease and other dementias (400 stories, 33% of total), which were eventually, combined into 1 category for purposes of data analysis. Conditions with the highest prevalence were among the least covered topics, including migraine (34 stories, 3% of total) and head trauma (19 stories, 2% of total). Stigmatizing language was found in 15% of all stories. Excluding wire stories, the average among locally produced newspaper stories was higher (21%). Stories on epilepsy (30%) and migraine (29%) contained the highest frequency of stigmatizing language. Sources of stigma within a story included reporters (55%), patients (26%), family (17%), and physicians (16%). In an accuracy analysis, 20% of sampled stories contained medical errors or exaggerations, with half of these concerning neurodegenerative conditions. CONCLUSION: A total of 21% of all stories (excluding wire stories) contained language Judged stigmatizing, with reporters as the most common source of the stigmatizing language. A total of 20% of analyzed stories had medical errors or exaggerations, the latter most often overstating treatment effectiveness.


Related Articles

  • The one-and-a-half syndrome as the presenting sign of systemic lupus erythematosus. Sasannejad, Payam; Olfati, Nahid; Sabi, Mohsen Soltani; Juibary, Ali Ghabeli // Neurology India;May/Jun2014, Vol. 62 Issue 3, p300 

    The article discusses the case of a 34-year old patient who was diagnosed with one-and-a-half syndrome as the presenting sign of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). The results of the patient's neurologic examination, laboratory evaluation of blood, cerebrospinal fluid examination,...

  • The Babinski sign: 100 years on. Ditunno, John F.; Bell, Rodney // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);10/26/96, Vol. 313 Issue 7064, p1029 

    Focuses on the centenary of the Babinski sign, a precise and reliable indicator of neurologic function. Discoverer; Medical significance; Controversy over its relationship with pyramidal defects.

  • Sometimes a detailed examination is warranted. Hamon, Angela // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);10/18/97, Vol. 315 Issue 7114, p996 

    Presents the author's experience illustrating the need for physicians to conduct thorough neurologic examinations. Types of neurological disorders which quick physical examinations cannot detect.

  • The Four-Minute Neurologic Exam. Marshall, Cameron M. // Journal of the Canadian Chiropractic Association;Sep2012, Vol. 56 Issue 3, p233 

    The article reviews the book "The Four Minute Neurologic Exam," by Stephen Goldberg.

  • The Neurodiagnostic Journal Quiz.  // Neurodiagnostic Journal (ASET - The Neurodiagnostic Society);Dec2012, Vol. 52 Issue 4, p374 

    A quiz related to electroneurodiagnostic technology is presented.

  • The Neurodiagnostic Journal Q.  // Neurodiagnostic Journal (ASET - The Neurodiagnostic Society);Dec2013, Vol. 53 Issue 4, p347 

    A quiz concerning neurodiagnostics and neurophysiology is presented.

  • Congenital defect of the anterior arch of the atlas: A case report and review of the literature. Karavelioglu, Ergun; Kacar, Emre; Karavelioglu, Afra; Gonul, Yucel; Guven, Mustafa // Neurology India;May/Jun2014, Vol. 62 Issue 3, p296 

    The article describes the case of a five-year old female patient who was diagnosed with congenital anomalies of anterior arch of atlas. The results of the patient's neurological examination, computed tomography (CT) and cervical spinal T2-weighted magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) are presented....

  • Click.  // Nursing Children & Young People;Apr2014, Vol. 26 Issue 3, p11 

    The article offers information on several applications that can support clinical decision making, including Paediatric Emergencies, Children's Coma Scale and Vital Values.

  • Neurologic Evaluation of a Population Exposed to Arsenic in Alaskan Well Water. Kreiss, Kathleen; Zack, Matthew M.; Feldman, Robert G.; Niles, Clyde A.; Chirico-Post, Jeannette; Sax, Daniel S.; Landrigan, Philip J.; Boyd, Mary H.; Cox, Dennis H. // Archives of Environmental Health;Mar/Apr83, Vol. 38 Issue 2 

    Investigates the neurological conditions of individuals exposed to arsenic from well water in Alaska. Absence of dose response relationships between arsenic ingestion and peripheral neuropathy; Prevalence of abnormal nerve conduction velocities; Inability of arsenic ingestion to develop...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics