TITLE

Public Choice, Pigouvian and Coasian Planning Theory

AUTHOR(S)

Webster, Christopher J.

PUB. DATE

January 1998

SOURCE

Urban Studies (Routledge);Jan98, Vol. 35 Issue 1, p53

SOURCE TYPE

Academic Journal

DOC. TYPE

Article

ABSTRACT

Summary. With urban planning policy in transition in many parts of the world, the need to understand the theoretical bases for planning and to ground discussion about policy innovations on theory is as important as ever. This essay reviews the relevance of three economic paradigms to the theory of development control. It is written as a technical review with the purpose of explaining, contrasting and contextualising the contributions of these paradigms. Much has been written about the Pigouvian case for regulative planning. The Coasian literature is strong especially in the US but is not so well known elsewhere; and little has been written that draws together the diverse perspectives offered by the public choice school. This essay has been written particularly for academic planners and urban social scientists in the UK, and in other European and Commonwealth countries who are not familiar with the technical arguments underlying the Coase vs Pigou zoning debate. It is also an essay on the public choice theory of planning since it contextualises Coasian planning theory within that wider critique of welfare economics. Among other points, it argues that the relevance of Coasian planning theory is not by any means restricted to US-style zoning, nor is it purely a debate about deregulation. Coasian and other public choice perspectives generate a rich source of theoretical and empirical propositions which should be tested and developed, particularly as frameworks for comparative analysis of planning constitutions and policies. In this spirit, the essay concludes with elements of a research agenda.

ACCESSION #

200771

Tags: DEVELOPMENT economics

 

Related Articles

• The `big push' in an open economy with nontradable inputs. Skott, Peter; Ros, Jaime // Journal of Post Keynesian Economics;Fall97, Vol. 20 Issue 1, p149 

  Discusses development economics. Concept of the `big push'; Need for a big push in an open economy; Resurgence of the constant-returns-to-scale paradigm; Industrialization; Model.

• Threats to UK development capitalists.  // Management Accounting: Magazine for Chartered Management Account;Oct94, Vol. 72 Issue 9, p6 

  Focuses on the report entitled `Development Capital in the UK--Responding to Changing Demands?,' published by Ernst & Young. Comments by Nich Pasricha of Ernst & Young; Contact information.

• Development, the state and its leadership in Malawi & Madagascar. Ambert, Cecile // Africa Insight;1997, Vol. 27 Issue 1, p44 

  Focuses on the neoliberal development paradigm in Malawi and Madagasca, with reference to the similarities in state characteristics and how the developmental capacity of each state has failed to materialized its social and economic evolution. Reference to a review of the neoliberal approach;...

• Untitled.  // New Yorker;3/14/1964, Vol. 40 Issue 4, p168 

  An excerpt from a restaurant menu regarding the need for industrial development and fish abundance in Manning, South Carolina is presented.

• Editor's Introduction. Yanowitch, Murray // Problems of Economic Transition;May94, Vol. 37 Issue 1, p3 

  Provides a preview into the May 1994 issue of the periodical 'Problems of Economic Transition.' Debate on economic policy between reformer and hardliners; Overview of articles in the issue.

• Generalized Conclusions from the Experience of Planning Socioeconomic Development in Subjects of the Russian Federation. Nikolaev, M.; Makhotaeva, N. // Problems of Economic Transition;Jan2003, Vol. 45 Issue 9, p50 

  Analyzes the socioeconomic development planning in Russia. Regional laws and regulations governing the drafting of documents on socioeconomic development; Government agencies responsible for drafting documents on socioeconomic development; Types of planning documents; Trends in development...

• Roadmap for the Knowledge-Driven Economy.  // Economic Development Journal;Spring2006, Vol. 5 Issue 2, p54 

  The article presents information on the 2006 Annual Conference of the International Economic Development Council (IEDC) to be held in New York City, N. Y. on September 2006.

• The experiment in California. Nattagh, Nima // Mortgage Banking;Aug94, Vol. 54 Issue 11, p20 

  Discusses the effect of developments in the housing market on California's economy. Forces shaping market conditions; Implication of home prices; Link between foreclosure rates and falling prices.

• WHAT'S NEW IN DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS? Ray, Debraj // American Economist;Fall2000, Vol. 44 Issue 2, p3 

  Describes the frontiers of development economics. Traditional view on economics in developing countries; Perception on economic development as a coordination failure; Conclusions.

Read the Article