Rasch Modeling of Revised Token Test Performance: Validity and Sensitivity to Change

Hula, William; Doyle, Patrick J.; McNeil, Malcolm R.; Mikolic, Joseph M.
February 2006
Journal of Speech, Language & Hearing Research;Feb2006, Vol. 49 Issue 1, p27
Academic Journal
The purpose of this research was to examine the validity of the 55-item Revised Token Test (RTT) and to compare traditional and Rasch-based scores in their ability to detect group differences and change over time. The 55-item RTT was administered to 108 left- and right-hemisphere stroke survivors, and the data were submitted to Rasch analysis. Traditional and Rasch-based scores for a subsample of 60 stroke survivors were submitted to analyses of variance with group (left hemisphere with aphasia vs. right hemisphere) and time post onset (3 vs. 6 months post onset) as factors. The 2 scoring methods were compared using an index of relative precision. Forty-eight items demonstrated acceptable model fit. Misfitting items came primarily from Subtest IX. The Rasch model accounted for 71% of the variance in the responses to the remaining items. Intersubtest patterns of item difficulty were well predicted by item content, but unexpected within-subtest differences were found. Both traditional and Rasch person scores demonstrated significant group differences, but only the latter demonstrated statistically significant change over time. Analysis of relative precision, however, failed to confirm a significant difference between the 2 methods. The findings generally support the RTT's validity, but a minority of items appears to respond to a different construct. Also, within-subtest differences in item difficulty suggest the need for further examination of variability in impaired language performance. Finally, the results suggest an equivocal advantage for Rasch scores in detecting change over time.


Related Articles

  • Aspectos anatómicos y funcionales sobre el área de Broca en neurocirugía funcional. Trejo-Martínez, David; Jiménez-Ponce, Fiacro; Marcos-Ortega, José; Conde-Espinosa, Rubén; Fárber-Barquera, Ariana; Velasco-Monroy, Ana Luisa; Velasco-Campos, Francisco // Revista Medica del Hospital General de Mexico;jul-sep2007, Vol. 70 Issue 3, p141 

    In the current review, some aspects of the anatomy of the Brocas´s area like clinical expression of the Broca´s aphasia are discussed, including the alteration in the understanding of the oral language. Also, functional findings with the use of recent techniques are exposed, like the...

  • Impairments of syntactic comprehension in Korean and the location of ischemic stroke lesions: A voxel-based lesion-symptom mapping study. Gottesman, Rebecca F.; Hillis, Argye E.; Kim, M.J.; Jeon, H.A.; Lee, K.M. // Behavioural Neurology;2009/2010, Vol. 22 Issue 1/2, p3 

    In order to assess the capacity of neurological patients to process syntactic features unique to Korean, such as the heavy dependence of parsing on syntactic morphemes rather than the word order in a sentence, the Korean Syntactic Comprehension Test (KSCT) was newly developed. To examine the...

  • ASSESSMENT OF LANGUAGE AFTER STROKE IN ADULTS IN THE STATE OF SERGIPE. Arruda, João Sigefredo; Reis, Francisco Prado; Fonseca, Vânia // Revista CEFAC;mai/jun2014, Vol. 16 Issue 3, p853 

    Purpose: to study the occurrence of language disorders in subjects who had suffered stroke from February to August 2012, under treatment at the center for education and health of Sergipe State, in the section of physiotherapy referral. The language evaluation was based on the Test of Rio de...

  • Comparison of Alternatives to Multidimensional Scoring in the Assessment of Language Comprehension in Aphasia. Odekar, Anshula; Hallowell, Brooke // American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology;Nov2005, Vol. 14 Issue 4, p337 

    Purpose: Multidimensional scoring methods yield valuable information about communication abilities. However, issues of training demands for valid and reliable scoring, especially in current service delivery contexts, may preclude common usage. Alternatives to multidimensional scoring were...

  • Acquired Language Disorders as Barriers to Effective Communication. Ondondo, Emily Ayieta // Theory & Practice in Language Studies;Jul2015, Vol. 5 Issue 7, p1324 

    Communication is a complex process that involves various fundamentals. It not only involves different elements but also entails speaking, listening, writing and reading. Effective communication can be curtailed by a number of factors stemming from either the elements of the communication...

  • Discriminative Validity of Selected Measures for Differentiating Normal From Aphasic Performance. Ross, Katherine B.; Wertz, Robert T. // American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology;Aug2003, Vol. 12 Issue 3, p312 

    Normal elderly and mildly aphasic individuals may exhibit similar impairments in comprehension and expression. The discriminative validity between normal and aphasic performance on most standardized measures of aphasia has not been reported. The authors compared the performance of 18 aphasic and...

  • Comments on "Comparison of Alternatives to Multidimensional Scoring in the Assessment of Language Comprehension in Aphasia" by Odekar and Hallowell (2005). Porch, Bruce E. // American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology;Feb2007, Vol. 16 Issue 1, p84 

    Purpose: These comments are written in response to an article by A. Odekar and B. Hallowell (2005) which argues that the use of plus-minus scoring may be faster and more efficient than " traditional multidimensional scoring" in current clinical contexts. Method: As a long-time clinician and as...

  • Response to Porch (2007). Odekar, Anshula; Hallowell, Brooke // American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology;Feb2007, Vol. 16 Issue 1, p87 

    Purpose: To respond to B. E. Porch's (2007) comments regarding "Comparison of Alternatives to Multidimensional Scoring in the Assessment of Language Comprehension in Aphasia" by A. Odekar and B. Hallowell (2005). Method: In this response letter, we address all of Porch's main criticisms by...

  • Accent on aphasia. Newton, Caroline; Bruce, Carolyn // Speech & Language Therapy in Practice;Summer2011, p17 

    The article explores how difficulty in comprehending unfamiliar and foreign accents can have significant implications on rehabilitation and participation in the community for people with aphasia. Details related to a study presenting questions to chronic aphasia adults on narratives from the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics