Comparison of Clinician Judgments and Measurements of Swallow Response Time: A Preliminary Report

Karnell, Michael P.; Rogus, Nicole M.
December 2005
Journal of Speech, Language & Hearing Research;Dec2005, Vol. 48 Issue 6, p1269
Academic Journal
Practicing clinicians frequently offer judgments about aspects of swallowing physiology rather than performing actual measurements. Little is known about the accuracy of those judgments. The purpose of this preliminary study was to explore agreement of clinicians' judgments of pharyngeal swallow response time (PSRT) with temporal measurements of PSRT. In preparation for a larger study, PSRTwas measured from the first 3ml liquid bolus swallow that appeared in each of 20 videofluorographic swallowing evaluations. The same 20 swallowswere then shown to 3 clinicians whowere instructed to subjectively rate PSRT. The reliability of the PSRT measurements was strong (r > .95). Intrajudge and interjudge agreement was better than chance in all but 1 interjudge comparison. Percentage agreement between clinicians' judgments and the measurements, when the measurements were categorized as either not delayed or delayed, ranged from 60% to 95%. Chi-square and Phi statistics comparing the outcomes of clinicians' ratings with the measurement outcomeswere significant, supporting the agreement of the judgments with the measurements. Although the results of tests of agreement were found to be acceptable, clinician experience and training remain important issues whenever clinical judgments are involved. Larger studies are needed to establish the accuracy and importance of clinicians' judgments of PSRT and observations of swallowing physiology.


Related Articles

  • Utility of Clinical Swallowing Examination Measures for Detecting Aspiration Post-Stroke. McCullough, G. H.; Rosenbek, J. C.; Wertz, R. T.; McCoy, S.; Mann, G.; McCullough, K. // Journal of Speech, Language & Hearing Research;Dec2005, Vol. 48 Issue 6, p1280 

    The purpose of this investigation was to determine the utility of clinical swallowing examination (CSE) measures for detecting aspiration as defined by videofluoroscopic swallowing examination (VFSE). This study, involving 165 participants, is a follow-up to a previously published investigation...

  • Resolution of Tracheal Aspiration After the Acute Phase of Stroke-Related Oropharyngeal Dysphagia. Terré, Rosa; Mearin, Fermín // American Journal of Gastroenterology;Apr2009, Vol. 104 Issue 4, p923 

    OBJECTIVES:We set out to ascertain the evolution and the clinical and videofluoroscopic (VFS) prognostic factors of aspiration recovery and return to oral intake in patients with stroke and VFS diagnosis of tracheal aspiration.METHODS:Twenty patients with stroke and VFS diagnosis of tracheal...

  • Pneumatic Dilation for Achalasia without Fluoroscopic Guidance: Safety and Efficacy. Lambroza, Arnon; Schuman, Robert W. // American Journal of Gastroenterology;Aug1995, Vol. 90 Issue 8, p1226 

    Objectives: To describe the technique of pneumatic dilation for achalasia without fluoroscopic guidance and to assess its safety and efficacy. Methods: Twenty-seven consecutive patients who underwent pneumatic dilation with the Rigiflex achalasia balloon under direct endoscopic visualization...

  • Pre and post-surgical dysphagia outcome associated with posterior fossa tumour in children. Angela Morgan; Deborah Sell; Martina Ryan; Elizabeth Raynsford; Richard Hayward // Journal of Neuro-Oncology;May2008, Vol. 87 Issue 3, p347 

    Abstract   Background Swallowing impairment (dysphagia) has been reported as a possible sequela following surgical removal of posterior fossa tumours (PFT). Dysphagia may result in aspiration of food/fluid leading to respiratory tract infection, placing the patient at...

  • National Dysphagia Diet: What to Swallow? McCullough, Gary; Pelletier, Cathy; Steele, Catriona // ASHA Leader;11/4/2003, Vol. 8 Issue 20, p16 

    Discusses the diet texture modification for dysphagia management. Publication published to establish standard terminology and practice applications; Proposed four levels of semisolid/solid foods; Proposed terms for liquids and correlating viscosity ranges.

  • A case of dysphagia with solids. Reddy, Sangeetha; Nachimuthu, Senthil; Moola, Kalyani // Patient Care;Sep2002, Vol. 36 Issue 11, p91 

    Discusses the case of a Hispanic woman with dysphagia with solids. Medical background; Results of physical examination; Symptoms of the Plummer-Vinson syndrome, also known as Paterson-Kelly syndrome; Medical treatment recommended.

  • Rehabilitation medicine: 2. Diagnosis of dysphagia and its nutritional management for stroke patients. Finestone, Hillel M.; Greene-Finestone, Linda S. // CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;11/11/2003, Vol. 169 Issue 10, p1041 

    FOLLOWING STROKE, PATIENTS MAY HAVE REDUCED DIETARY intake, swallowing impairments (dysphagia) and other neurological deficits that could affect their nutritional and hydration status and lead to aspiration pneumonia. Impaired nutritional status is associated with reduced functional improvement,...

  • Fixed Corkscrew Pattern of the Esophagus. Hodes, Steven E.; Korsten, Mark A. // American Journal of Gastroenterology;Mar1980, Vol. 73 Issue 3, p249 

    The radiographic, manometric and endoscopic evaluation of an alcoholic patient with dysphagia, a mid esophageal diverticulum and "corkscrewing" of the distal esophagus is reported. The patient displayed a constant deformity of the distal esophagus which was associated with progressive but...

  • A Tough Pill to Swallow? Perhaps It's a Signal to See a Doctor.  // Women's Health Advisor;Mar2012, Vol. 16 Issue 3, p1 

    The article discusses the medical condition, symptoms, and treatment and prevention of dysphagia or swallowing disorders. It states that the dysphagia affects 22 percent of Americans over the age of 50 and can occur at all ages in both men and women. It notes that difficulties of swallowing...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics