The Difficulty of Selecting Superior Mutual Fund Performance

McGuigan, Thomas P.
February 2006
Journal of Financial Planning;Feb2006, Vol. 19 Issue 2, p50
Academic Journal
• Much has been written about the management of mutual funds and active versus passive management This study attempts to quantify the relative performance of actively managed large- and mid-cap domestic stock mutual funds with a passive strategy during a 20-year period, including 11 10-year rolling periods. • During the study period, most actively managed large- and mid-cap mutual funds underperformed their respective passive strategies. While every period under review had mutual funds that outperformed the passive strategy, few funds did so consistently • Furthermore, predicting in advance which mutual funds would outperform was difficult if not impossible, and the cost of selecting the "wrong" manager was high. These factors combined demonstrate the difficulty for financial planners to select superior performance. • The study also reviewed the impact of taxes on large-cap investments. • Finally, the author provides recommendations for financial planners in discussing action steps regarding clients' portfolios. INSET: Executive Summary.


Related Articles

  • A Battle of the Titans. Israelsen, Craig L. // Money Management Executive;11/25/2013, Vol. 21 Issue 45, p1 

    The article offers information on the investments choices for an investor between mutual funds and exchange traded funds (ETF). It mentions that ETFs will be beneficial if buying and selling is important and if not then mutual funds will be an ideal choice. It discusses the portfolios of ETFs...

  • When every car is a purple car. D'ALLESSANDRO, GARRETT R.; DENIKE, STEVEN // Accounting Today;11/16/2009, Vol. 23 Issue 18, p20 

    The article focuses on achieving effective portfolio diversification in a non-normal equity market environment. It says that due to the vast majority of investors finding non-domestic equity exposure, the benefits of allocating to international markets have declined. Also, the traditional asset...

  • Baird Aggregate Bond Joins the 500. Kinnel, Russel // Morningstar FundInvestor;Mar2008, Vol. 16 Issue 7, p22 

    The article reports that Morningstar FundInvestor 500 has listed Baird Aggregate Bond BAGIX. It provides the profile, business strategy, performance and portfolio analysis of Baird Aggregate Bond BAGIX. The article also presents the lists of mutual funds institutions category with the...

  • Quick tips for busy investors. Corbin, David; Villegas, Melissa // Fort Worth Business Press;8/8/2005, Vol. 18 Issue 32, p27 

    Provides information on investing in mutual funds in the U.S. American Century Value Fund which focuses on mid-capitalization and large-capitalization stocks; Dreyfus Appreciation Fund which is loaded with high quality, large and mega-capitalization stocks; Advantage and disadvantages of the...

  • Impact of 12b-1 Fees on Expense Ratios of Large-Cap Growth, Mid-Cap Growth, Small-Cap Growth, and Income Objective Mutual Funds. Rao, S. P. Uma; Schaub, Mark // Journal of Business & Society;2006, Vol. 19 Issue 1/2, p250 

    A total of 674 mutual funds were analyzed based on data pulled in 2004. Our up-to-date examination of the differential effects fund size, age, objective, load versus no-load status and the existence of a 12b-1 plan have on cross-sectional differences in mutual fund expense ratios extends prior...

  • Top-Performing Mutual Funds For Week. DOUG ROGERS // Investors Business Daily;6/27/2014, p00 

    Stock mutual funds' recently renewed rally lost steam in the latest week ended June 26, with gains limited to 0.35% for large-cap growth, 0.20% for multicap and 0.7% for midcap growth. Most other diversified categories slipped.

  • The Perfect Mix of Large-, Mid-, and Small-Cap Stocks.  // Morningstar GrowthInvestor;Jan2007, Vol. 2 Issue 8, p1 

    The article focuses on mixing large-, mid- and small-capitalization stocks in portfolio management. Adding mid and small-capitalization stocks in a large-capitalization portfolio may enable returns improvement without increasing the portfolio risk. The volatility of stocks increases as market...

  • L.A.'s 911 to Boot Large-Cap Value Mgr. Sorondo, Marc // Investment Management Weekly;4/10/2006, Vol. 19 Issue 14, p1 

    Deals with the decision reached by the board of directors of the Los Angeles Fire & Police Pension System during a board meeting on April 6, 2006, to allegedly terminate Alliance Capital Management from a large-capitalization value mandate. Value of the large-cap mandate; Implications of the...

  • We're Trading Turner for Primecap. Carlson, Greg // Morningstar FundInvestor;Oct2006, Vol. 15 Issue 2, p18 

    The article advises investors to invest in the Primecap Odyssey Aggressive Growth mutual fund in favor of Turner Midcap Growth. According to the author, the action should not be taken as against the Turner fund, but rather to the enthusiastic endorsement of the team from Primecap Management. The...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics