A Comparison between the 4DVAR and the Ensemble Kalman Filter Techniques for Radar Data Assimilation

Caya, A.; Sun, J.; Snyder, C.
November 2005
Monthly Weather Review;Nov2005, Vol. 133 Issue 11, p3081
Academic Journal
A four-dimensional variational data assimilation (4DVAR) algorithm is compared to an ensemble Kalman filter (EnKF) for the assimilation of radar data at the convective scale. Using a cloud-resolving model, simulated, imperfect radar observations of a supercell storm are assimilated under the assumption of a perfect forecast model. Overall, both assimilation schemes perform well and are able to recover the supercell with comparable accuracy, given radial-velocity and reflectivity observations where rain was present. 4DVAR produces generally better analyses than the EnKF given observations limited to a period of 10 min (or three volume scans), particularly for the wind components. In contrast, the EnKF typically produces better analyses than 4DVAR after several assimilation cycles, especially for model variables not functionally related to the observations. The advantages of the EnKF in later cycles arise at least in part from the fact that the 4DVAR scheme implemented here does not use a forecast from a previous cycle as background or evolve its error covariance. Possible reasons for the initial advantage of 4DVAR are deficiencies in the initial ensemble used by the EnKF, the temporal smoothness constraint used in 4DVAR, and nonlinearities in the evolution of forecast errors over the assimilation window.


Related Articles

  • The Ensemble Kalman Filter: theoretical formulation and practical implementation. Evensen, Geir // Ocean Dynamics;Nov2003, Vol. 53 Issue 4, p343 

    The purpose of this paper is to provide a comprehensive presentation and interpretation of the Ensemble Kalman Filter (EnKF) and its numerical implementation. The EnKF has a large user group, and numerous publications have discussed applications and theoretical aspects of it. This paper reviews...

  • Data assimilation in a system with two scales�combining two initialization techniques. BALLABRERA-POY, JOAQUIM; KALNAY, EUGENIA; SHU-CHIH YANG // Tellus: Series A;Aug2009, Vol. 61 Issue 4, p539 

    An ensemble Kalman filter (EnKF) is used to assimilate data onto a non-linear chaotic model, coupling two kinds of variables. The first kind of variables of the system is characterized as large amplitude, slow, large scale, distributed in eight equally spaced locations around a circle. The...

  • Unscented Kalman Filter Applied to the Spacecraft Attitude Estimation with Euler Angles. Garcia, Roberta Veloso; Kuga, Helio Koiti; Zanardi, Maria Cecilia F. P. S. // Mathematical Problems in Engineering;2012, Vol. 2012, Special section p1 

    The aim of this work is to test an algorithm to estimate, in real time, the attitude of an artificial satellite using real data supplied by attitude sensors that are on board of the CBERS-2 satellite (China Brazil Earth Resources Satellite). The real-time estimator used in this work for attitude...

  • Object tracking system using Camshift, Meanshift and Kalman filter. SALHI, Afef; JAMMOUSSI, Ameni YENGUI // World Academy of Science, Engineering & Technology;2012, Issue 64, p674 

    This paper presents a implementation of an object tracking system in a video sequence. This object tracking is an important task in many vision applications. The main steps in video analysis are two: detection of interesting moving objects and tracking of such objects from frame to frame. In a...

  • Comparing Adjoint- and Ensemble-Sensitivity Analysis with Applications to Observation Targeting. Ancell, Brian; Hakim, Gregory J. // Monthly Weather Review;Dec2007, Vol. 135 Issue 12, p4117 

    The sensitivity of numerical weather forecasts to small changes in initial conditions is estimated using ensemble samples of analysis and forecast errors. Ensemble sensitivity is defined here by linear regression of analysis errors onto a given forecast metric. It is shown that ensemble...

  • Real Time Hand Tracking System Using Predictive Eigenhand Tracker. Asaari, Mohd Shahrimie Mohd; Suandi, Shahrel Azmin // Australian Journal of Basic & Applied Sciences;Feb2012, Vol. 6 Issue 2, p190 

    In this paper, we present a real time vision based hand tracking system by combining predictive framework and appearance model. Due to the nature of hand motion which is flexible, erratic and easily varies in its appearance, the hand tracking from a single camera remains a complex problem. Here,...

  • Local ensemble Kalman filtering in the presence of model bias. Seung-Jong Baek; Hunt, Brian R.; Kalnay, Eugenia; Ott, Edward; Szunyogh, Istvan // Tellus: Series A;May2006, Vol. 58 Issue 3, p293 

    We modify the local ensemble Kalman filter (LEKF) to incorporate the effect of forecast model bias. The method is based on augmentation of the atmospheric state by estimates of the model bias, and we consider different ways of modeling (i.e. parameterizing) the model bias. We evaluate the...

  • Angular Motion Estimation Using Dynamic Models in a Gyro-Free Inertial Measurement Unit. Edwan, Ezzaldeen; Knedlik, Stefan; Loffeld, Otmar // Sensors (14248220);2012, Vol. 12 Issue 5, p5310 

    Abstract: In this paper, we summarize the results of using dynamic models borrowed from tracking theory in describing the time evolution of the state vector to have an estimate of the angular motion in a gyro-free inertial measurement unit (GF-IMU). The GF-IMU is a special type inertial...

  • Parallel Implementation of an Ensemble Kalman Filter. Houtekamer, P. L.; He, Bin; Mitchell, Herschel L. // Monthly Weather Review;Mar2014, Vol. 142 Issue 3, p1163 

    Since mid-February 2013, the ensemble Kalman filter (EnKF) in operation at the Canadian Meteorological Centre (CMC) has been using a 600 × 300 global horizontal grid and 74 vertical levels. This yields 5.4 × 107 model coordinates. The EnKF has 192 members and uses seven time levels,...


Read the Article

Courtesy of

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics