Subglobal Regulation of the Global Commons: The Case of Climate Change

Engel, Kirsten H.; Saleska, Scott R.
May 2005
Ecology Law Quarterly;2005, Vol. 32 Issue 2, p183
Academic Journal
In this Article, the authors challenge the conventional wisdom in the legal, economics, and policy literature that unilateral (as opposed to collective) action by individual countries to restrain despoliation of the global commons is presumptively irrational. The conventional view flows from Garrett Hardin's classic "Tragedy of the Commons " analysis, in which commons preservation, though collectively desirable, is economically irrational when undertaken by individuals, hence the tragedy. Motivated by the unexpected actions of many individual nations and states to address climate change (a classic global commons problem) even in the absence of an unambiguous global framework, the authors show that the market imperfections that characterize some global commons problems, including those of climate change, can diverge from those underpinning the standard "Tragedy of the Commons. " The authors argue that this divergence makes room for significant rational unilateral action towards commons preservation, and that this has been underappreciated by many scholars who instinctively disparage unilateral action. In place of the conventional wisdom, the authors suggest that short of the ideal "full glass" of optimal collective action, there exists a "glass half full" of suboptimal unilateral action by larger subglobal governments that is better than no regulation (and hence no benefits) at all, and, indeed, the evidence shows that some larger subglobal governments, the United States in particular, should actually be doing more to address climate change. Furthermore, action by both large and small subglobal governments may function as a mechanism by which individual governments can help trigger the implementation of the preferred solution of an international framework for collective action.


Related Articles

  • Tuvalu.  // Country Fact Sheets: Tuvalu;10/27/2015, p1 

    The article discusses the relationship between the U.S. and Tuvalu which began in 1979 after it signed a treaty of friendship with the U.S. which recognized Tuvalu's possession of four islets formerly claimed by the U.S. Topics cited include efforts of the partnership to curb the effects of...

  • U.S. Relations With Hungary.  // Country Fact Sheets: Hungary;1/5/2015, p1 

    The article focuses on the international relations between the U.S. and Hungary. It is noted that both countries are integrated through contracts in arts, business and scholarship. It discusses topics such as the assistance of the U.S. to Hungary, their bilateral economic relations and their...

  • Globally Warm, Economically Cool. Lucier, James P. // Insight on the News;12/28/98, Vol. 14 Issue 48, p18 

    Focuses on the United States' signing of the Kyoto Protocol to the United Nation's Framework Convention on Climate Change on November 12, 1998. How senators view the Kyoto Protocol; What the agreement calls for; Comments on the issue.

  • Joint Statement by President Barack Obama and Prime Minister John Fredrik Reinfeldt of Sweden. Obama, Barack // Daily Compilation of Presidential Documents;9/ 4/2013, p1 

    The article presents the text of the joint statement by U.S. President Barack Obama and Swedish Prime Minister John Fredrik Reinfeldt, issued on September 4, 2013, wherein they noted the special friendship between the U.S. and Sweden. They also reaffirmed the dedication of both countries to the...

  • The Glue That Binds or the Straw That Broke the Camel's Back?: Exploring the Implications of U.S. Reengagement in Global Climate Change Negotiations. Carlarne, Cinnamon // Tulane Journal of International & Comparative Law;11/1/2010, Vol. 19 Issue 1, p113 

    The article focuses on the implications of the reengagement by the U.S. on international climate change negotiations. It highlights the evolution of global climate change politics from 1997-2010, the events of the 2009 Copenhagen Climate Change Conference, and the implications of the issuing...

  • United States signs Kyoto Protocol on climate change.  // Issues in Science & Technology;Winter98/99, Vol. 15 Issue 2, p28 

    Reports that the United States signed the Kyoto Protocol on climate change on November 12, 1998. Statement from President Bill Clinton; Opposition to the Kyoto Protocol; Information on the protocol.

  • Climate change is drowning in populist politics. Khindaria, Brij // Moderate Voice;1/ 4/2010, p3 

    In this article, the author comments on a divide between the U.S. and most other countries regarding the responsibility for global warming or climate change. The author mentions the failure of U.S. President Barack Obama to convince European Union (EU), China, and India to accept the...

  • Climate Change, Weak States and the "War on Terrorism" in South and Southeast Asia. Smith, Paul J. // Contemporary Southeast Asia: A Journal of International & Strate;Aug2007, Vol. 29 Issue 2, p264 

    Climate change is emerging as one of the key security challenges of the 21st century, a challenge that will increasingly have effects in the realm of counter-terrorism. Since January 2002, the United States Government has grounded its counter-terrorism policies within an international!...

  • Looking South.  // America;1/21/2013, Vol. 208 Issue 2, p4 

    The author discusses the relationship of the U.S. with the neighboring countries in the south. The author mentions the checkered relationship of the U.S. with its neighbors to the south due to the U.S. government's improper intervention in the affairs of the sovereign nations for self-interest....


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics