A Dense Corpus Study of Past Tense and Plural Overregularization in English

Maslen, Robert J.; Theakston, Anna L.; Lieven, Elena V. M.; Tomasello, Michael
December 2004
Journal of Speech, Language & Hearing Research;Dec2004, Vol. 47 Issue 6, p1319
Academic Journal
In the "blocking-and-retrieval-failure" account of overregularization (OR; G.F. Marcus, 1995; G.F. Marcus et al., 1992), the claim that a symbolic rule generates regular inflection is founded on pervasively low past tense OR rates and the lack of a substantive difference between past tense and plural OR rates. Evidence of extended periods of OR in the face of substantial correct input (M. Maratsos, 2000) and of an initial period in which nouns are more likely to be overregularized than verbs (V.A. Marchman, K. Plunkett, & J. Goodman, 1997) casts doubt on the blocking account and suggests instead an interplay between type and token frequency effects that is more consistent with usage-based approaches (e.g., J. Bybee, 1995; K.Köpcke, 1998; K. Plunkett & V. Marchman, 1993). However, previous naturalistic studies have been limited by data that account for only 1-2% of child speech. The current study reports analyses of verb and noun ORs in a dense naturalistic corpus (1 child, 2;00.12-3;11.06[years;months.days]) that captures 8-10% of child speech and input. The data show (a) a marked difference in verb and noun OR rates; (b) evidence of a relationship between relative regular/irregular type frequencies and the onset and rate of past tense and plural ORs; (c) substantial OR periods for some verbs and nouns despite hundreds of correct tokens in child speech and input; and (d) a strong negative correlation between input token frequencies and OR rates for verbs and nouns. The implications of these findings for blocking and other accounts of OR are discussed.


Related Articles

  • More Writing Rules to Remember.  // Writing is the 'Right' Thing to Do!;2005, p117 

    The article offers several writing rules. When writing a story or an essay, avoid making use of too many unnecessary words or phrases. In number writing, most newspaper and professional writers choose to write numbers less than 10 as words. Avoid the use of double negatives. Use a singular verb...

  • Fast Mapping-Leistungen bei Kindern mit einer semantisch-lexikalischen Stërung im Rahmen einer SSES. Skerra, Antje // Forum Logopadie;jan2009, Vol. 23 Issue 1, p6 

    The study investigated fast mapping by 3-5-year-old children with SLI. The groups learned 2 nouns and two verbs in an interactive setting. Fast Mapping abilities were examined by four tests. The test ‟ Defining„ showed an effect related to the groups, parts of speech and an...

  • On modal tenses and tensed modals. LACA, Brenda // Cahiers Chronos;2012, Vol. 25, p163 

    This paper is devoted to the interaction between temporal configuration and the interpretation of modal verbs in French and Spanish, two languages that exhibit wider and more transparent morphological options than English, but diverge from each other in significant ways. I show that mere...

  • JoniÅ¡kÄ—lio Å¡nektos veiksmažodis. Kurkauskienė, Rasa // Man & the Word / Zmogus ir zodis;2012, Vol. 14 Issue 1, p69 

    The article is intended to the problems of dialectal morphology. The research of Joniškėlis local dialect is being continued. Verb classes and peculiarities of conjugation are discussed in the article. Conclusions: 1) disyllabic verbs having short vowels u or i in their roots, have the...

  • MEG masked priming evidence for form-based decomposition of irregular verbs. Fruchter, Joseph; Stockall, Linnaea; Marantz, Alec // Frontiers in Human Neuroscience;Nov2013, Vol. 7, p1 

    To what extent does morphological structure play a role in early processing of visually presented English past tense verbs? Previous masked priming studies have demonstrated effects of obligatory form-based decomposition for genuinely affixed words (teacher-TEACH) and pseudo-affixed words...

  • WR NEWS WORD WORK!  // Weekly Reader - Edition 2;4/20/2007, Vol. 76 Issue 23, p4 

    A quiz about present and past tense verbs is presented.

  • The Case of the Perfect Party.  // Storyworks;Nov/Dec2010, Vol. 18 Issue 3, p23 

    A quiz concerning the correct verb tense is presented.

  • What's the Tense?  // Scholastic Action;12/5/2011, Vol. 35 Issue 7, p21 

    A discussion of the past, present and future tense of verbs is presented.

  • Verbs - Watch Those Tenses! KOERSELMAN, VIRGINIA // Facts & Findings;May/Jun2013, Vol. 39 Issue 6, p41 

    A quiz concerning different verb tenses is presented.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics