Bayesian designs with frequentist and Bayesian error rate considerations

You-Gan Wang; Heng-Yan Leung, Denis; Ming Li; Say-Beng Tan
October 2005
Statistical Methods in Medical Research;Oct2005, Vol. 14 Issue 5, p445
Academic Journal
So far, most Phase II trials have been designed and analysed under a frequentist framework. Under this framework, a trial is designed so that the overall Type I and Type II errors of the trial are controlled at some desired levels. Recently, a number of articles have advocated the use of Bayesian designs in practice. Under a Bayesian framework, a trial is designed so that the trial stops when the posterior probability of treatment is within certain prespecified thresholds. In this article, we argue that trials under a Bayesian framework can also be designed to control frequentist error rates. We introduce a Bayesian version of Simon's well-known two-stage design to achieve this goal. We also consider two other errors, which are called Bayesian errors in this article because of their similarities to posterior probabilities. We show that our method can also control these Bayesian-type errors. We compare our method with other recent Bayesian designs in a numerical study and discuss implications of different designs on error rates. An example of a clinical trial for patients with nasopharyngeal carcinoma is used to illustrate differences of the different designs.


Related Articles

  • Robust bayesian prediction under distortions of prior and conditional distributions. Kharin, A. // Journal of Mathematical Sciences;Mar2005, Vol. 126 Issue 1, p992 

    Considers robust Bayesian prediction under distortions of the hypothetical probabilistic model. Hypothetical Bayesian prediction density; Continuous weighted functions; Robustness to the Tukey-Huber distortions of hypothetical prior distributions.

  • Bayesian and Non-Bayesian Inference for Survival Data Using Generalised Exponential Distribution. Guure, Chris Bambey; Bosomprah, Samuel // Journal of Probability & Statistics;2013, p1 

    A two-parameter lifetime distribution was introduced by Kundu and Gupta known as generalised exponential distribution. This distribution has been touted to be an alternative to the well-known 2-parameter Weibull and gamma distributions. We seek to determine the parameters and the survival...

  • On the Generalized Lognormal Distribution. Toulias, Thomas L.; Kitsos, Christos P. // Journal of Probability & Statistics;2013, p1 

    This paper introduces, investigates, and discusses the γ-order generalized lognormal distribution (γ-GLD). Under certain values of the extra shape parameter γ, the usual lognormal, log-Laplace, and log-uniform distribution, are obtained, as well as the degenerate Dirac distribution. The...

  • How to make OR-results available: a proposal for project scheduling. Müller, Rudolf; Solte, Dirk // Annals of Operations Research;1995, Vol. 55 Issue 1-4, p439 

    This paper addresses the question of how to make available and how to get realistic insight into the behavior of hard algorithms for application fields such as scheduling. A typical situation in this context is the availability of hundreds of algorithms for special subclasses of certain problems...

  • Geometry and exponential coordinates for probabilities on a finite set. Gzyl, Henryk // AIP Conference Proceedings;2004, Vol. 735 Issue 1, p478 

    This work is motivated by a question posed by Peter Cheeseman: How to understand the curves γi(t) = p0t(i)p11-t(i)/Σjp0t(j)p11-t(j) in the set of probability measures? It turns out that P = {p = (p1, ..., pn) ∈ Rn|pi > 0; Σi=1npi = 1} can be thought of as a projective space, more...

  • Approximating Posterior Distributions for Mixture-Model Parameters. Center, Julian L. // AIP Conference Proceedings;2004, Vol. 735 Issue 1, p437 

    We consider a fully-Bayesian approach to using mixture models in pattern classification problems. From a Bayesian point of view, classification should be done by integrating over the posterior distribution for the model parameters (including the number of components in the mixture) given...

  • Some Recent Developments in Bayesian Variable Selection. Berger, James O.; Molina, German // AIP Conference Proceedings;2004, Vol. 735 Issue 1, p417 

    After a general discussion of some basic issues in Bayesian model selection, we briefly review three fairly recent developments: (i) The median probability model (rather than the highest posterior probability model) is the model which is typically optimal for prediction in variable selection...

  • Bayesian Experimental Design — Studies for Fusion Diagnostics. Fischer, R. // AIP Conference Proceedings;2004, Vol. 735 Issue 1, p76 

    The design of fusion diagnostics is essential for the physics program of future fusion devices. The goal is to maximize the information gain of a future experiment with respect to various constraints. A measure of information gain is the mutual information between the posterior and the prior...

  • The Marginalization Paradox and the Formal Bayes' Law. Wallstrom, Timothy C. // AIP Conference Proceedings;11/13/2007, Vol. 954 Issue 1, p93 

    It has recently been shown that the marginalization paradox (MP) can be resolved by interpreting improper inferences as probability limits. The key to the resolution is that probability limits need not satisfy the formal Bayes' law, which is used in the MP to deduce an inconsistency In this...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics