Energy Employees Compensation: Case-Processing Bottlenecks Delay Payment of Claims: GAO-04-298T

Robertson, Robert E.
December 2003
GAO Reports;12/6/2003, p1
Government Document
The Department of Energy (Energy) and its predecessor agencies and contractors have employed thousands of workers in the nuclear weapons production complex. Some employees were exposed to toxic substances, including radioactive and hazardous materials, during this work and many subsequently developed illnesses. Subtitle D of the Energy Employees Occupational Illness Compensation Program Act of 2000 allows Energy to help its contractor employees file state workers' compensation claims for illnesses determined by a panel of physicians to be caused by exposure to toxic substances in the course of employment at an Energy facility. Energy began accepting applications under this program in July 2001, but did not begin processing them until its final regulations became effective on September 13, 2002. The Congress mandated that GAO study the effectiveness of the benefit program under Subtitle D of this Act. This testimony is based on GAO's ongoing work on this issue and focuses on three key areas: (1) the number, status, and characteristics of claims filed with Energy; (2) the extent to which there will be a "willing payer" of workers' compensation benefits, that is, an insurer who--by order from, or agreement with Energy--will not contest these claims; and (3) the extent to which Energy policies and procedures help employees file timely claims for these state benefits. As of June 30, 2003, Energy had completely processed only about 6 percent of the nearly 19,000 cases it had received. More than three-quarters of all cases were associated with facilities in nine states. Processing had not begun on over half of the cases and, of the remaining 40 percent of cases that were in processing, almost all were in the initial case development stage. While the majority of cases (86 percent) associated with major Energy facilities in nine states potentially have a willing payer of workers' compensation benefits, actual compensation is not certain. This figure is based primarily on the method of workers' compensation coverage used by Energy contractor employers and is not an estimate of the number of cases that will ultimately be paid. Since no claimants to date have received compensation as a result of their cases filed with Energy, there is no actual experience about how contractors and state programs treat such claims. Claimants have been delayed in filing for state worker's compensation benefits because of two bottlenecks in Energy's claims process. First, the case development process has not always produced sufficient cases to allow the panels of physicians who determine whether the worker's illness was caused by exposure to toxic substances to operate at full capacity. While additional resources may allow Energy to move sufficient cases through its case development process, the physician panel process will continue to be a second, more important, bottleneck. The number of panels, constrained by the scarcity of physicians qualified to serve on panels, will limit Energy's capacity to decide cases more quickly, using its current procedures. Energy officials are exploring ways that the panel process could be more efficient.


Related Articles

  • Belatedly, an attempt to make amends. Pasternak, Douglas // U.S. News & World Report;04/24/2000, Vol. 128 Issue 16, p23 

    Reports United States government plans to compensate nuclear-weapons-plant workers who were exposed to radiation and beryllium and who as a result contracted lung diseases and cancer. Details of the plan; Comments from the Paper, Allied-Industrial, Chemical and Energy Workers Union (PACE),...

  • Clinical: Miner's knee.  // GP: General Practitioner;4/11/2012, p24 

    The article offers information on how patients in Great Britain can avail industrial injuries disablement benefit (IIDB), which is a tax-free and 'no fault' and non-contributory benefit provided to individuals who become disabled due to certain prescribed diseases or, because of an accident at...

  • DOE Urged By AIA To Drop Regulatory Proposal That Would Impact State W.C. Laws.  // Insurance Advocate;10/20/2001, Vol. 112 Issue 40, p3 

    Reports on the testimony of the American Insurance Association on the issue of workers' compensation before the United States (U.S.) Department of Energy (DOE) on October 10, 2001. Proposal by the DOE on the process of filing insurance claims for nuclear weapons facility workers; Overview of...

  • The Adversary System: Cui Bono? Morgan, W. Keith C. // Annals of Internal Medicine;Dec82, Vol. 97 Issue 6, p919 

    Editorial. Comments on a study that reviewed workers' compensation for industrial disease in the U.S. Information on disability expenditures in the country; Impact of the black lung program on the Social Security Administration and the Department of Labor in the country; Background on the...

  • Avoiding workers' compensation claims for stress-related injuries. Bohman, Lisa // Enterprise/Salt Lake City;1/16/2006, Vol. 35 Issue 29, p10 

    The article focuses on ways to avoid workers' compensation claims for mental stress-related injuries. Several factors precipitating the mental stress among employees are enumerated. Evidences that needs to be presented for making such claims are discussed. The provision for stress-related claims...

  • New York Revises Workers' Comp Statutes.  // Risk Management (00355593);Nov84, Vol. 31 Issue 11, p65 

    This article reports on the decision of the New York State Legislature to enact several changes in its workers' compensation laws in 1984. Perhaps most significant was the enactment of Chapter 659 of the Laws of 1984. The new law eliminates all previous time limits that governed how long after...

  • DATES AHEAD.  // Risk Management (00355593);May88, Vol. 35 Issue 5, p67 

    The article presents the schedule of several events relevant to the insurance industry in the U.S. from June 1, 1988 to November 11, 1988. From June 1 to June 2, 1988, the Property-Casualty Reinsurance Claims course will be held in New York City. The course is designed to provide training in and...

  • Nuclear defense worker compensation broadened.  // Nation's Health;Jun2000, Vol. 30 Issue 5, p4 

    Discusses the United States Department of Energy's (DOE) proposal to compensate workers with a broad range of work-related illnesses throughout the department's nuclear weapons complex. Comments from David Michaels, DOE assistant secretary for environment, safety and health; Efforts made to...


    The article looks at the decision of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania in the case Tooey v. AK Steel related to the statutory or common law compensation for occupational diseases under the Worker's Compensation Act (WCA) and the Occupational Disease Act (ODA) of Pennsylvania. It mentions that...


Read the Article

Other Topics