Three Abductive Solutions to the Meno Paradox — with Instinct, Inference, and Distributed Cognition

Paavola, Sami; Hakkarainen, Kai
July 2005
Studies in Philosophy & Education;Jul2005, Vol. 24 Issue 3/4, p235
Academic Journal
This article analyzes three approaches to resolving the classical Meno paradox, or its variant, the learning paradox, emphasizing Charles S. Peirce’s notion of abduction. Abduction provides a way of dissecting those processes where something new, or conceptually more complex than before, is discovered or learned. In its basic form, abduction is a “weak” form of inference, i.e., it gives only tentative suggestions for further investigation. But it is not too weak if various sources of clues and restrictions on the abductive search are taken into account. We present three, complementary versions of abduction: (1) as a sort of guessing instinct or expert-like intuition, where unconscious clues are important; (2) as a form of inference, where a strategic point of view is essential; and (3) as a part of distributed cognition and mediated activity, where the interaction with the material, social, and cultural environment is emphasized. Our starting point is Peirce’s own notion of abduction, but we broaden the perspective, especially to the direction of distributed cognition.


Related Articles

  • The Philosophy of Education. Podd"Iakov, A. N. // Journal of Russian & East European Psychology;Nov/Dec2003, Vol. 41 Issue 6, p37 

    The humanistic ideas of cooperative learning, which gained great popularity throughout the twentieth century, have had an enormous influence on the theory and practice of instruction and education. Instruction began to be considered not simply as the transmission and mastery of some particular...

  • HOT Emotions: Dissolving the Paradox of Fiction. Tullman, Katherine // Contemporary Aesthetics;2012, Vol. 10, p7 

    This essay critiques two of the main theories in the philosophy of emotions, the pure-cognitive theory and the neo-Jamesian theory, through the paradox of fiction. After explaining the different kinds of emotions we experience when engaging with fictions, I argue that a middle-ground, hybrid...

  • THE POTENTIAL FOR EDUCATION IS EXCITING. Bajer, Dustin // ATA Magazine;Summer2013, Vol. 93 Issue 4, p42 

    In this article, the author discusses ways to improve the education system by giving appropriate examples from nature. He suggests expanding the process of learning by the integration of new concepts into the current understanding in the context of forests that grow by expanding their edge...

  • Group Intervention Can Help with Diversity. Peebles-Wilkins, Wilma // Children & Schools;Oct2004, Vol. 26 Issue 4, p195 

    Focuses on the application of the dialogic learning group process in diverse and multicultural precollegiate learning environments. Significance of group intervention in such learning environments; Overview of some research on the importance of group intervention; Benefits of the application of...

  • Seeing an invisible world. Richardson, Joan // Phi Delta Kappan;Mar2013, Vol. 94 Issue 6, p4 

    An introduction is presented about the issue's focus on Hispanic American students, focusing on research on the cognitive learning of Mexican American preschool children by professors Bruce Fuller and Claudia Galindo, Hispanic family values, and the cultural value Hispanics offer U.S. education.

  • Implementing Learning-How-to-Learn Strategies. Giese, Ann // Chief Learning Officer;Jun2006, Vol. 5 Issue 6, p28 

    The article offers guidelines pertaining to the implementation of the learning strategies. First, identification of one's own strengths and weaknesses. Second, actively engage in learning tasks. Third, manage priorities and complete educational and work commitments. Fourth, participate in a...

  • Learning, Education and Training: Is that a Tautology or an Oxymoron? Bradbery, Patrick // International Journal of Diversity in Organisations, Communities;Sep2007, Vol. 7 Issue 2, p75 

    The recent interest in the phenomenon of the learning organisation sparked largely by Peter Senge's The Fifth Discipline has placed a spotlight on the three terms: learning; education; and training. Are they just different ways of describing the same thing, or are there important distinctions to...

  • The Liar-paradox in a Quantum Mechanical Perspective. Aerts, Diederik; Broekaert, Jan; Smets, Sonja // Foundations of Science;Jun1999, Vol. 4 Issue 2, p115 

    In this paper we concentrate on the nature of the liar paradox as a cognitive entity; a consistently testable configuration of properties. We elaborate further on a quantum mechanical model (Aerts, Broekaert and Smets, 1999) that has been proposed to analyze the dynamics involved, and we focus...

  • The aesthetic paradox in processing conventional and non-conventional metaphors: A reaction time study. Christmann, Ursula; Wimmer, Lena; Groeben, Norbert // Scientific Study of Literature;2011, Vol. 1 Issue 2, p199 

    This study focuses on the relationship between cognitive effort and aesthetic-emotional evaluation in the processing of conventional and non-conventional metaphors. We postulate that an increased cognitive load — which is normally perceived as stressful — is evaluated positively...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics