TITLE

DELIBERATIVE AUTONOMY AND LEGITIMATE STATE PURPOSE UNDER THE FIRST AMENDMENT

AUTHOR(S)
Bagchi, Aditi
PUB. DATE
August 2005
SOURCE
Albany Law Review;2005, Vol. 68 Issue 4, p815
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
Argues that the free speech law in the U.S. should revolve around an alternative organizing principle, the autonomy of the listener. Definition of deliberative autonomy; Belief of fundamentalists on their constitutional rights; Response to challenges to autonomy-based theories of the First Amendment.
ACCESSION #
17775195

 

Related Articles

  • THE ARGUMENT FROM TRUTH AS A BASIS FOR LEGISLATION CONCERNING FREEDOM OF SPEECH. R�ikk�, Juha // TRAMES: A Journal of the Humanities & Social Sciences;2003, Vol. 7 Issue 4, p249 

    In recent discussion on free speech the so-called argument from truth has been evaluated from various critical perspectives. In this paper I would like to comment on some of the recent contributions. I shall argue that it is not necessarily a problem for the argument from truth that it works...

  • FROM NIKE V. KASKY TO MARTHA STEWART: FIRST AMENDMENT PROTECTION FOR CORPORATE SPEAKERS' DENIALS OF PUBLIC CRIMINAL ALLEGATIONS. Caillavet, Cynthia A. // Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology;Summer2004, Vol. 94 Issue 4, p1033 

    This article proposes a narrow exception to the doctrine regarding the low U.S. First Amendment protection for false or misleading commercial speech: commercial speakers whose speech rebuts public claims of criminal wrongdoing should not be held liable for claims stemming from the factual...

  • Why Indonesia Revolts. Meyer, Bernard // New Republic;10/29/45, Vol. 113 Issue 18, p565 

    Focuses on the hardships faced by the Indonesians under the Japanese, Dutch and Australian rule. View that the Japanese, though practicing worse brutality, have been more successful with appeals to the Indonesians on independence and Asia for the Asiatics; Information on the more politically...

  • SEANA SHIFFRIN'S THINKER-BASED THEORY OF FREE SPEECH: ELEGANT AND INSIGHTFUL, BUT WILL IT WORK IN PRACTICE? Weinstein, James // Constitutional Commentary;Fall2011, Vol. 27 Issue 2, p385 

    The author analyzes the thinker-based autonomy theory of free speech proposed by the philosophy professor Seana Valentine Shiffrin. He states that the firm connection between speech and its underlying values offers the theory a strong and coherent foundation. He expresses his concern about the...

  • FREE SPEECH AND AUTONOMY: THINKERS, STORYTELLERS, AND A SYSTEMIC APPROACH TO SPEECH. Williams, Susan H. // Constitutional Commentary;Fall2011, Vol. 27 Issue 2, p399 

    The author outlines the functions served by autonomy in our moral and political lives and proposes a narrative model of autonomy describing how it serves these functions highlighting its primary advantages. His systemic approach recognizes autonomy as a process rather than an assumed starting...

  • A THINKER-BASED APPROACH TO FREEDOM OF SPEECH. Shiffrin, Seana Valentine // Constitutional Commentary;Fall2011, Vol. 27 Issue 2, p283 

    The article presents the author views on the thinker-based foundation for the freedom of speech. He states that this theory may present a stronger and more logical base for the most significant free speech protection than competitor free speech theories. Comparison of thinker-based autonomy...

  • REPLY TO CRITICS. Shiffririn, Seana Valentine // Constitutional Commentary;Fall2011, Vol. 27 Issue 2, p417 

    The author addresses the responses of the critics on the thinker-based autonomy theory of freedom of speech proposed by her. She categorizes the responses into four categories including questions about methodological issues, questions about scope, worries about under-inclusivity, and worries...

  • Counterspeech 2000: A New Look at the Old Remedy for "Bad" Speech. Richards, Robert D.; Calvert, Clay // Brigham Young University Law Review;2000, Vol. 2000 Issue 2, p553 

    Examines an eclectic collection of free-speech battles in which various manners and modes of counterspeech have been used as antidotes for allegedly harmful speech. Information on the effective use of public displays of disaffection; Discussion on counterspeech and the art of protest; Conclusion.

  • Freedom's just another word... Brook, Paula // Saturday Night;Nov97, Vol. 112 Issue 9, p58 

    Details the freedom of speech argument between columnist Doug Collins and publisher Peter Speck. Comments of Speck about Collins' performance; Information on reasonably held statements of material fact according to Speck; How Collins case is related to the 1990 Supreme Court of Canada case of...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of VIRGINIA BEACH PUBLIC LIBRARY AND SYSTEM

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics