Appropriation as Agrarianism: Distributive Justice in the Creation of Property Rights

Schorr, David B.
February 2005
Ecology Law Quarterly;2005, Vol. 32 Issue 1, p3
Academic Journal
The water-law doctrine of prior appropriation, developed in Colorado in the late 1800s, has received much scholarly attention, due to the claimed efficiency advantages of the system of private property rights it is supposed to have instituted. Supporters and critics alike have associated the doctrine with values such as the preference for private over common property, the privatization of the public domain, and the facilitation of markets in natural resources. This article relies on analysis of previously unexamined historical sources to demonstrate that the appropriation doctrine actually was intended to express contemporary radical, agrarian ideals of broadly distributed property and antimonopolism. The unofficial codes of the Colorado mining districts, conventionally thought to be the source of the doctrine's "first in time, first in right" principle, focused primarily on rules designed to ensure wide distribution of property. Similarly, the statutes of the Colorado Territory, the water-rights provisions of the state constitution of 1876, and early judicial decisions culminating in the leading case of Coffin V. Left Hand Ditch Co., were mainly concerned to prevent control of water by capitalists, and did so by breaking the common-law monopoly of riparian owners and opening access to the resource to all bona fide users. This historical analysis raises the broader question of whether distributive justice has been adequately considered, alongside efficiency and public choice, as a factor in explaining the evolution of property-rights regimes.


Related Articles

  • Resource Nationalism: The 21st Century's Challenge to the Global Mining Industry. Kirschke, Joseph // Engineering & Mining Journal (00958948);Apr2013, Vol. 214 Issue 4, p100 

    The article discusses the aspects and challenges of global mining industry in Bolvia. It states that Bolivia has vast natural resources in its reserve and Bolivian miners have long paid homage to small "Tio" statues on the way down. It further states that laws and legislations in Bolvia has left...

  • Ecuador. McAdams, Megan // Washington Report on the Hemisphere;11/4/2009, Vol. 29 Issue 20, p8 

    The article discusses the controversial Water Law proposed by the government of Ecuador that prompted protests against the government in September 2010, by indigenous groups that claimed their rights would be violated by privatization of natural resources, lack of pollution controls and...

  • ECONOMY.  // Background Notes on Countries of the World: Papua New Guinea;Aug2009, p6 

    This article discusses the economy of Papua New Guinea in 2009. The country produces natural resources, including minerals, oil, gas, timber and fish. Foreign investors dominated the minerals, timber and fish sectors. The dependence of the economy on imports for manufactured goods is noted....

  • Are Canadian miners "good players" in CSR? Evans, Marketa D. // Canadian Mining Journal;Feb/Mar2013, Vol. 134 Issue 2, p60 

    The article discusses the relevance of corporate social responsibility in the mining industry. The program suggests numerous definitions such as development projects, ethics implementation, and provision of economic benefits. However, the natural resources sector fails to include communication...

  • JUNGLE HUNTERS. Featherstone, Tony // BRW;3/8/2012, Vol. 34 Issue 9, p50 

    The author discusses investing in the oil exploration and mining industries in Papua New Guinea (PNG). He acknowledges the growing preference of Australian investors in the natural resources of PNG. He describes the share value of Highlands Pacific and the potential of the Frieda River...

  • Sheridan 6 LEMA moves forward this year. GRIEKSPOOR, P. J. // Kansas Farmer (0022-8583);May2013, Vol. 151 Issue 5, p31 

    The article reports on the Sheridan 6 Local Enhanced Management Area (LEMA), the first LEMA designation for Sheridan county in Kansas that was allowed by the changes to water law in 2012, which was established in the state on January 1, 2013.

  • ENRC seeking to go private.  // World Mining News;5/21/2013, p3 

    The article cites a report in 2013 that Kazakhstan's government and the three founders of miner ENRC are seeking to take the company private.

  • Angels for health care. Walters, Kath // BRW;3/3/2011, Vol. 33 Issue 8, p10 

    The article focuses on the results of a survey by Wholesale Investor which showed that the mining sector attracted the strongest attention from angel investors.

  • Miners criticise investors chasing instant gratification. Ingram, Tess // Australian Financial Review (0404-2018);8/6/2015, p27 

    The article reports that mining industry executives are in pressure to deliver good results is being criticised by investors.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics