Psychotherapy as Civics: The Patient and Therapist as Citizens

Simon, Laurence
March 2005
Ethical Human Psychology & Psychiatry;Spring2005, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p57
Academic Journal
The field of psychotherapy has failed to live up to its promise to be a force in the continued development of democracy by aligning itself with medicine and psychiatry. Psychotherapists must recognize that those with whom they work and disseminate information to are inevitably citizens and that they are redefining citizens as mental patients. By utilizing psychiatric diagnoses, which are in effect, moral labels, psychotherapy unwittingly helps create authoritarian political structures by convincing their patients and the public that they are essentially inferior and can do nothing to change that condition. A series of recommendations are made that suggest ways for psychotherapy to free itself from institutional psychiatry and medicine and build its own "house."


Related Articles

  • A Session with Jack: A Demonstration of Mirroring by Ego-Syntonic Joining. Bernstein, Arnold // Modern Psychoanalysis;2001, Vol. 26 Issue 2, p221 

    Presents an annotated verbatim transcript of a single session of a patient and a psychoanalyst in which heroic measures were employed to resolve a stalemate in an obstinate case of a man who displayed a particularly refractory and abrasive form of resistance in the context of an intense negative...

  • Toward Unification of Psychotherapies: A Complimentary Model. Karasu, Toksoz B. // American Journal of Psychotherapy;Oct1979, Vol. 33 Issue 4, p555 

    Examines the emergence of different models pf psychological healing from Freud to the present, and specific features which characterize new psychotherapies in contrast to psychoanalysis. Type of treatment that is increasingly recommended and practiced; Changes in the nature of the...

  • The First Interview in Modern Psychoanalysis. Liegner, Evelyn // Modern Psychoanalysis;2003, Vol. 28 Issue 1, p87 

    An initial contact and interview between patient and analyst in modern analysis differs in many ways from an initial contact and interview in classical psychoanalysis. Some similarities also exist. In the following discussion these differences and similarities in theory and practice will be...

  • The farthest reaches. Williams, Frances; Sibanda, Sharon // Psycho-Analytic Psychotherapy in South Africa;2013, Vol. 21 Issue 1, p93 

    This paper draws on the responses of two psychoanalytically trained psychotherapists during the course of their work with children in South African community clinics and hospitals. The authors describe some of the impacts on their minds and bodies of both physical and psychic holes in child...

  • Life of the mind. Blundy, Anna // Prospect;May2013, Issue 206, p78 

    The article offers author's insights during her conversation with her female therapy patient during her psychoanalysis training. Topics discussed include the behavior of the patients who keeps on talking regarding her desires to be a famous actress while she was thinking of many things on her...

  • Countertransference in the Treatment of Friends and Relatives. Liegner, Evelyn // Modern Psychoanalysis;2003, Vol. 28 Issue 1, p49 

    Despite Freud's statement that an analyst should not undertake the treatment of friends and relatives because the analyst would have to sacrifice the relationship regardless of the plosive or negative outcome, the author believes that successful therapeutic work can be accomplished through the...

  • Notas sobre temporalidad y transferencia. De Aryan, Delia Torres // Psicoanalisis: Revista de la Asociacion Psicoanalitica de Buenos;2009, Vol. 31 Issue 1, p181 

    The conceptualizations of temporality in classic Greece and the Jewish tradition and the contributions of G Deleuze and G Agamben are developed, applying them to the comprehension of a non-chronological temporality in the psychoanalytic session. The story in the session, the words of the patient...

  • Letter from the Primal Horde. DANIELS, J. D. // Paris Review;Spring2015, Issue 212, p277 

    An essay is presented in which the author discusses his experiences attending a residential group-relations conference as part of his psychoanalysis treatment. He covers his interactions with the others in attendance as well as the therapists before going to to comment on the physical and mental...

  • Letter to a Psychoanalyst. Blumenthal, Michael // Salmagundi;Fall2004/Winter2005, Issue 144/145, p174 

    Presents a letter by a former psychoanalysis patient addressed to a psychoanalyst and the analytic process and the theory of personality upon which it rests. This shows the feelings as to the virtues and weaknesses of psychoanalysisa and the subjects of psychoanalysis and psychology in general...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics