Tarti, Nevzat
March 2003
Ekev Academic Review;Spring2003, Vol. 7 Issue 15, p95
Academic Journal
Critisizm of text, as in the past, is one of the unavoidable problems in the studies of hadiths. The aim of this criticism is to examine if a hadith really belongs to the prophet Muhammad. The usage of contemporary science as a guide in the critisizm system of the new ages makes this problem exceedingly dificult. Because of verifing religious texts (Kur'ân and Hadiths) with scientific paradigm, the muslims had to use that paradigm to decide if a hadith is genuine (sahîh) or false (mevzû). This means that when a hadith is confirmed by results of the science and experiment, itshouldd be genuine, otherwise false. These two anachronic approachs which pretend not to see the historicity of the knowledge and belive that the prophet Muhammad is able to know all of contemporary scientific knowlage, are going to be discussed in this work.


Related Articles

  • "HEPÄ°NÄ°Z YÖNETÄ°CÄ°SÄ°NÄ°Z" HADÃŽSÄ° BAÄžLAMINDA HZ. PEYGAMBER'Ä°N SORUMLULUK EĞİTÄ°MÄ°. Önder, Mustafa; Dölek, Adem // Ekev Academic Review;Fall2009, Vol. 13 Issue 41, p407 

    Responsibility is a characteristic aspecial to human beings. It is impossible for a man to develop personality who lives without resposibiliy. Responsibilities are obligations of a person towards himself, other people, other creatures at his environmetnt, and his Creator (Allah). These...

  • HADITS EDUCATION IN JORDAN. NAZLIGÜL, Habil // Bilimname;2011, Vol. 21 Issue 2, p221 

    People are in great demand to hadith in Jordan. Hadith are read by almost everyone, spoken, debated, taught, learned there. This is reflected in education. Starting from the first years of compulsory education upper secondary education in this area continues to the teaching of Hadith. Each level...

  • HEMMÂM SAHÃŽFESÄ°'NDEKÄ° RÄ°VÂYETLERÄ°N HZ. PEYGAMBER'E NÄ°SBET VE MUHTEVA PROBLEMÄ° -HIZIR HADÄ°SÄ° ÖZELÄ°NDE-. Erdim, Sinan // Review of the Faculty of Divinity of Firat University / Firat Ãœ;2013, Vol. 18 Issue 1, p183 

    Hammâm b. Munabbih's Sahifah has been accepted as the first written book in Hadith's literature. The Sahifah has been called by some muhaddises as "al-Sahifah al-Sahihah" in order to express the reliability of narratives. All expressions of Sahifah are about several subjects of hereafter...

  • CONCEPT OF RIBA (INTEREST) IN ISLAMIC LAW: ITS IMPACT ON SOCIETY. Zubair, Muhammad; Khattak, Sadia // Science International;Jul/Aug2015, Vol. 27 Issue 4, p3601 

    The concept of Riba occupies a significant position in economic system of Islam. Riba is an act of taking advantage of an individual who needs money to meet his/ her basic needs through renting money at a price known as interest. The Holy Qur'an and Hadith (Practices of the Prophet) manifestly...

  • Inspiration of the Subtleties of Authentic Hadith Authenticity of the Science of Hermeneutics. BOZ, Halit // International Journal of Humanities & Social Science;Jan2013, Vol. 3 Issue 2, p187 

    Adopted the basic food source for the works of Tafsir Hadiths solvency of our research, brings an intense effort. After a lot of research phases are considered authentic hadith, again in terms of sanad and the text to identify defects, increases the importance of research and the number of...

  • The Matan and Sanad Criticisms in Evaluating the Hadith. Ismail, Tuan Mohd Sapuan Tuan; Baru, Rohaizan; Hassan, Ahmad Fauzi; bin Salleh, Ahmad Zahid; Amin, Mohd Fauzi Mohd // Asian Social Science;Nov2014, Vol. 10 Issue 21, p152 

    Knowledge on the classification (mustalah) and sciences (ulum) of the al-Hadith that has long existed is the platform for religious scholars to debate the preservation and safeguarding of the originality and authenticity of the Prophet’s SAW hadith. The topic is to determine whether to...

  • EL-BUHÂRÃŽ'NÄ°N HABERU'L-VÂHÄ°D SAVUNUSUNDA KULLANDIÄžI HADÄ°SLERÄ°N HUCCÄ°YETÄ° ÃœZERÄ°NE BÄ°R Ä°NCELEME. Özmen, Ramazan // Ekev Academic Review;Spring2009, Vol. 13 Issue 39, p133 

    This study is aiming to analyze al-BukhāB;'s approach to some hadiths as proofs for defending the transmission of a single person/al-khabar al-vāhid as a juridical argument in religious issues especially connected with practical ones not with faith. al-Bukhārī the excellence of the...

  • "BANA ARZ OLUNDU" KALIBIYLA RÄ°VÂYET EDÄ°LEN HADÄ°SLERÄ°N MENÅžEÄ° ÃœZERÄ°NE. Coşkun, Selçuk // Ekev Academic Review;Fall2009, Vol. 13 Issue 41, p427 

    The hadith that includes the phrase "I was displayed" are being interprated in two different aspects. According to the first, Prophet Mohammed has no knowledge of the unseen world. The hadith of this type are either newly fabricated or transformed from other sources. The other view, on the other...

  • SÃœHEYL B. EBÃŽ SÂLÄ°H NÃœSHASI'NDAKÄ° RÄ°VÂYETLERÄ°N DAHA SONRAKÄ° HADÄ°S EDEBÄ°YATINA Ä°NTÄ°KALÄ°. Budak, Ali // Journal of Divinity Faculty of Hitit University;2011, Vol. 10 Issue 20, p81 

    The first written works on literature of hadith in the second century due to Islamic calendar contain valuable information on the method of reporting hadith. This study aims to determine how the reports in the study of Suhayl ibn Abi Salih influenced later works of hadith, and what they added to...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics