Supreme disagreement: The highest court affirms an empty right

Flood, Colleen M.; Sullivan, Terrence
July 2005
CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;7/19/2005, Vol. 173 Issue 2, p142
Academic Journal
Analyzes the decision of the Canadian Supreme Court to nullify Quebec laws prohibiting the sale of private health insurance on the basis that they violate Quebec's Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms. Facts of the case; Examination of the arguments presented in the case; Reason behind the decision.


Related Articles

  • LA MISE EN OEUVRE DES DROITS SOCIAUX PAR LA CHARTE CANADIENNE DES DROITS ET LIBERTÉS. Robert, J. J. Michel // Canadian Issues / Thèmes Canadiens;Fall2007, p16 

    Presents an April 2007 speech by the chief justice of Quebec in 2002, delivered at the Association for Canadian Studies conference on the Canadian Charter on Rights and Freedoms on its 25th anniversary. Discusses the charter and compares its guarantees for social rights with that of the Quebec...

  • Le harcèlement sexuel au travail: l'impact de la décision Béliveau Saint-Jacques. Langevin, Louise // Canadian Journal of Women & the Law;1997, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p17 

    The recognition that sexual harrassment is an employment injury within the meaning of the Act Respecting Industrial Accidents and Occupational Diseases (AIAOD) is an important gain for female workers who are victims of this behaviour. However, according to ss. 438 and 441 of this Act, the female...

  • Les enfants autochtones en protection de la jeunesse au Québec: leur réalité comparée à celle des autres enfants. Breton, Alexandra; Dufour, Sarah; Lavergne, Chantal // Criminologie;2012, Vol. 45 Issue 2, p157 

    Research in Canada and elsewhere in the world acknowledges the overrepresentation of aboriginal children in child welfare services. The actual study adds knowledge concerning child maltreatment in the aboriginal children population and the way Quebec child welfare responds to aboriginal...

  • Access to Justice: Human Rights and Legal Aid. McKay-Panos, Linda // LawNow;Sep/Oct2010, Vol. 35 Issue 1, p38 

    The article offers information concerning legal aid services which provides individuals with access to the legal system and to legal representation in Canada. It mentions that while there is no right to counsel under the Canadian Constitution, the Youth Criminal Justice Act provides that a judge...

  • Private health insurance: In one door and out the other?  // CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;9/13/2005, Vol. 173 Issue 6, p565 

    Focuses on the invalidation by the Canadian Supreme Court of Quebec's laws concerning private health insurance in 2005. Recommendation of increasing the efficiency of the public system; Diversion of the public's tax dollars into health care; Reduction of services covered by monopoly.

  • Discrimination Denied: Gould v. Yukon Order of Pioneers. Baines, Beverley // Canadian Journal of Women & the Law;2000, Vol. 12 Issue 2, p464 

    Provides information on the merits of the first human rights sex discrimination case initiated by a woman and lost at the Supreme Court of Canada. Alleged failure of the judges to meet one of the basic tenets of the ethic of justice; Requisites of a good adjudication; Notion that impartiality...

  • Canada Ruling Could Pave Way For Public/Private HC System. Gusman, Phil // Insurance Advocate;6/20/2005, Vol. 116 Issue 13, p10 

    The article focuses on the Supreme Court of Canada which has struck down a law prohibiting the use of private health insurance in Quebec for medically necessary procedures. Associations, unions, legislators and others are now left grappling with the decision and there is debate as to whether it...

  • Private medical care comes to Canada.  // CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;8/2/2005, Vol. 173 Issue 3, p225 

    Comments on the decision of the Canadian Supreme Court to repeal laws prohibiting commerce in private health insurance in Quebec as of August 2005. Implication of the decision on laws prohibiting physicians to practice in the private sector; Opinion on Lawrie McFarlane, a former deputy minister...

  • 10 YEARS OF MIXED DECISIONS. McCann, Marcus // Capital Xtra (Ottawa);11/19/2008, Issue 196, p13 

    This section presents mixed decisions issued by the Canadian Supreme Court in the span of 10 years. They include a decision in a case involving Delwin Vriend which obliged employers not to discriminate against gay employees. Another decision is a controversial one which paved the way for gay...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics